3 a 2 pela validade das conduções coercitivas

Rosa Weber vota em consonância com Gilmar Mendes, ou seja, pela inconstitucionalidade das conduções coercitivas.

“A condução coercitiva para interrogatório é uma medida restritiva de liberdade desprovida de justificativa cautelar.”

Pelo raciocínio da ministra, se o investigado não é obrigado a depor, então ele também não deve ser obrigado a ser conduzido para interrogatório.

Comentários temporariamente fechados.

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site; a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem.

  1. Edu disse:

    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

    1. U2V1cyBpZGlvdGFzLCBhaW5kYSBiZW0gcXVlIEdJTE1BUiBzZWd1ZSBhIENPTlNUSVRVScfDTywgYSBlc3F1ZWNpIGFsZ28sIHF1ZSBlc3RhIGRpcmVpdGEgaWRpb3RhIGUgYnVycmEgbuNvIGNvbmhlY2U=

    2. TXVpdG8gYm9hIGEgc3VhIGNvbnNpZGVyYefjby4gySBvIHF1ZSBldSBwZW5zby4=

Ler comentários
  1. jeep disse:

    RXNzZSBtaW1pbWkganVy7WRpY28g6SBhIGJhZGFyb2NhIGRhIGRlbW9jcmFjaWEuLi4gYWd1ZW50ZW0gLi4uLg==

  2. Ô disse:

    RXNzYSBtaW5pc3RyYSDpIG9yaXVuZGEgZGEganVzdGnnYSB0cmFiYWxoaXN0YS4gQWNobyBxdWUgbuNvIHByZWNpc2EgZGl6ZXIgbWFpcyBuYWRhICEhISBGcmFxdWluaGEgLiBQaW9yIHF1ZSBmcmFjYSDpIGFqdWRhciBjb20gYSBpbXB1bmlkYWRlIG5vIHBh7XMuIE1hcyAsIGNvbW8gZGlzc2Ug6SBvcml1bmRhIGRhIGp1c3Rp52EgdHJhYmFsaGlzdGEgISEhICBBbyBlbXByZWdhZG8gdHVkbyAhIEFvIGVtcHJlZ2Fkb3IgbyByaWdvciBkYSBMZWkgISBVc2EgbyBtZXNtbyByYWNpb2PtbmlvIGNvbSBjb3JydXB0b3MgISEhIQ==

  3. Novo disse:

    UmVpbmFsZG8gQXpldmVkbyBSRUNVU09VIGNvbnZpdGUgZGUgRGlvZ28gTWFpbmFyZGkgcGFyYSBzZXIgbyB0ZXJjZWlybyBBbnRhZ29uaXN0YQ0KaHR0cDovL3ZlamEuYWJyaWwuY29tLmJyL2Jsb2cvcmVpbmFsZG8vZGlvZ28tZS1tYXJpby1tZS1xdWVyaWFtLWNvbW8tc29jaW8tcmVjdXNlaS1lbnRhby12aXJlaS1pbmltaWdvLw==

  4. Estudante, disse:

    ySB1bWEgZGlzY3Vzc+NvIGp1cu1kaWNhIGludGVyZXNzYW50ZSwgYWd1YXJkbyBkZXNmZWNoby4=

  5. De disse:

    Lg0KVkVMSEEgVkEgR0FCVU5EQSEhIQ0KTsNPIFBBU1NBIERFIFVNQSBTQU1BTUJBSUEgU0VDQSBOVU0gWEFYSU0gUkFDSEFETyEhIQ0KVlROQywgUk9TSU5IQSBQSUNBUkVUQSEhIQ==

  6. Cláudio disse:

    VGVtIG1lZG8gZGUgcXVlPyBFbSBxdWUgdW1hIGNvbmR15+NvIHBhcmEgcHJlc3RhciBkZXBvaW1lbnRvLCBhcPNzIHVtYSBjcmlhdHVyYSBzZSBuZWdhciBhIGlyIHBpciBsaXZyZSBlIGVzcG9udOJuZWEgdm9udGFkZSwgYWZldGFy4SBhIGRpZ25pZGFkZSBkZSBhbGd16W0/

  7. Cris disse:

    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

  8. Vergonha disse:

    VW1hID8gZGVzdGEgY29tbyByZXByZXNlbnRhbnRlIGRvIFJpbyBHcmFuZGUgc/MgcGFyYSBlbnZlcmdvbmhhci4=

  9. Marçal disse:

    RXN0ZSBwYe1zIHPzIGFwb2lhIGJhbmRpZG8uIFF1ZSBwYWlz6WNvLiBRdWUgU1RGLiBRdWVtIHB1ZGVyIHF1ZSB24SBlbWJvcmEu

  10. Valter disse:

    U2VuaG9yZXMgQW50YWdvbmlzdGFzLCBvIG1haW9yIGNhYm8gZWxlaXRvcmFsIGRlIEphaXIgTWVzc2lhcyBCb2xzb25hcm8g6SAgbyBtaW5pc3RybyBHaWxtYXIgTWVuZGVzIGUgdmNzIHNhYmVtIHBvcnF1ZSAscGVsYSByZXZvbHRhIGRlIG5vcyBCcmFzaWxlaXJvcyB0ZW1vcyBDb250cmEgZXN0ZSBzZW5ob3Iu

  11. Ma disse:

    QXTpIHF1ZSBvIFByaW1laXJvIFZhZ2FidW5kbyBmb3NzZSBjb25kdXppZG8gY29lcmNpdGl2YW1lbnRlLCBhIHBy4XRpY2EgY29ycmlhIOAgc29sdGEgcGVsbyBCcmFzaWwgYWZvcmEsIGluY2x1c2l2ZSBwYXJhIHRlc3RlbXVuaGFzLiBTZW1wcmUgZm9pIHVtIGluc3RydW1lbnRvIGRhIGp1c3Rp52EgcGFyYSBmYXplciBqdXN0aedhLiBBZ29yYSBvIGTzZG9pIGRhIGVzcXVlcmRhIGZheiBiaXF1aW5obyBlIGRpeiBxdWUg6SBjZXJjZWFtZW50byBkZSBsaWJlcmRhZGUu

  12. Mario disse:

    RXNzZSBTVEYgLCBu428g6SBsZWdpdGltbyEhISAgRm9pIElORElDQURPIHBvciBHb3Zlcm5hbnRlcywgY29tcHJvdmFkYW1lbnRlIGNvcnJ1cHRvcy4NCk7jbyBub3MgcmVwcmVzZW50YSBlIHBvciBpc3NvIGRldmVyaWFtIHNhaXIgZG8gc2V1IHBvc3RvLg0KQmFuZG8gZGUgc2FmYWRvcyBlIGNvcnJ1cHRvcy4=

  13. Perdeu-se disse:

    UXVlbSByb3Vib3Ugb3MgdmFsb3JlcyBncml0YW50ZXMgY29tbyBvcyBhcGFuaWd1YWRvcyBkbyBQVCwgIENsYXF1ZSBkYSBSb3NhIFdlYmVyLCBu428gdGVtIGRpZ25pZGFkZSBtdWl0byBtZW5vcyBob21icmlkYWRlLCBjb2VyY2l0aXZhIG5lc3RlcyB2aWdhcmlzdGFzIQ==

  14. luizs disse:

    TWluaGEgY2FyYSBtaW5pc3RyYSBSb3NhLiBBIGNvbmR15+NvIGNvZXJjaXRpdmEgc2VydmUgcHJpbmNpcGFsbWVudGUgcGFyYSwgY29tbyBkaXplbW9zIGFxdWkgbmEgcm/nYSwgcGVnYXIgbyBnYXR1bm8gY29tIGEgYm9jYSBuYSBib3RpamEu

  15. Maçaranduba disse:

    VGVtIHF1ZSBzZXIgbWVzbW8gY29lcmNpdGl2YSwgc29iIHZhcmEsIHRpcmFyIG8gY2FyYSBkZSBwaWphbWEgYXMgNiBkYSBtYW5o4ywgZSBsZXZhciBzZW0gZXNjb3ZhciBvcyBkZW50ZXMuIENhbmEgdmFnYWJ1bmRvLg==

  16. godofredo disse:

    QVRVQUxNRU5URSBPIEFOVEFHT05JU1RBIFRFTSAgTUFJUyBBTlVOQ0lPICggUFJPUEFHQU5EQSkgRE8gUVVFICBDT05URVVETzsgRkFaIFVNQSBDSEFNQURBIENPTSBVTSBUSVRVTE8gSU5URVJFU1NBTlRFICwgREVQT0lTIERVQVMgTElOSEFTIFNPQlJFIE8gQVNTVU5UTyBFLi4uIFRPTUUgIFBST1BBR0FOREEuLi5RVUUgIFNBQ08gISE=

  17. zóio disse:

    RXNzYSBtaW5pc3RyYSBhY2VuZGUgdW1hIHZlbGEgcHJhIERldXMsIG91dHJhIHBybyBEaWFibyE=

  18. MISS disse:

    Um9zYSBXZWJlciDpIGJlbSBmcmFxdWluaGEsIGNvaXRhZGEu

  19. GILMAR disse:

    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

  20. $TF: disse:

    QSBDb25zdGl0dWnn428gZGV2ZSBzZXIgaW50ZXJwcmV0YWRhIHBlbGEgbGVudGUgZGEg6XRpY2EsIGRhIG1vcmFsIGUgZG9zIGJvbnMgY29zdHVtZXMgY29tbyBub3MgcGHtc2VzIGNpdmlsaXphZG9zLiBBcXVpIG5vIEJyYXNpbCwgZWxhIOkgaW50ZXJwcmV0YWRhIHBlbGEgbGVudGUgZGEgT1JDUklNIHBlbG9zIGJhbmRpZPVlcyBkZSB0b2dhIGRvICRURi4=

  21. IdosO disse:

    U2VtcHJlICBk428gdW0gamVpdGluaG8gIHBhcmEgcHJvdGVnZXIgPSBibGluZGFyPSBlc2NvbmRlciA9ICBjYW11ZmxhciA9ICBhIGNvcnJ1cOfjbyBzaXN06m1pY2EsIHByaW5jaXBhbG1lbnRlIGVtIOlwb2NhIGRlIGNvcGEgZSBvdXRyb3MgZXZlbnRvcywgICBvbmRlIGEgbWFpb3JpYSBkbyBwb3bjbyBlc3ThIGNvbSBhIGNhYmXnYSBlbSBvdXRybyBsdWdhci4gIEFDT1JEQSBCUkFTSUwh

  22. cris disse:

    QWghIG1pbmlzdHJhIFJvc2EhIFVtIGdvbHBlIG5vIGNyYXZvIGUgb3V0cm8gbmEgZmVycmFkdXJhLCBu428g6SBtZXNtbz8=