6 X 5 para a prisão em segunda instância

Ives Gandra Martins diz que, se o Congresso Nacional aprovar uma lei permitindo a prisão em segunda instância, o STF não vai se opor.

Leia um trecho de seu artigo para o Estadão:

“Quando das conversas com os amigos e constituintes Bernardo Cabral, Ulysses Guimarães e Roberto Campos, assim como com os ministros Moreira Alves, Sydney Sanches e Francisco Rezek, da máxima Corte, à época da Constituinte – na oportunidade escrevi pequeno livro para 66 constituintes intitulado Roteiro para uma Constituição, veiculado pela Editora Forense –, defendia a tese de que os tribunais superiores deveriam ter a função de dar estabilidade às instituições, cabendo às instâncias inferiores fazer justiça. É o que ocorre com a Suprema Corte dos Estados Unidos e com os tribunais constitucionais dos regimes parlamentares europeus (…).

Pessoalmente, entendo, ao concluir este artigo, que se o Congresso Nacional aprovar a execução de sentença a partir da decisão de segunda instância em matéria penal, por 6 votos a 5 a Suprema Corte confirmará sua constitucionalidade.”

LULA ATACA. Leia aqui

Comentários temporariamente fechados.

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem. Em respeito a todos os leitores, não são publicados comentários que contenham palavras ou conteúdos ofensivos.

  1. MMaria disse:

    U/MgZmFsdGF2YSBvIFNURiBxdWVyZXIgZGVycnViYXIgdW1hIGFwcm92YefjbyBkbyBjb25ncmVzc28gKGJvbSwgY29tIHRvZmZvbGkgZSBnaWxtYXIsIHR1ZG8g6SBwb3Nz7XZlbCkuIFNlIHRhbCBiYXJiYXJpZGFkZSBhY29udGVjZXNzZSwgYWluZGEgbWFpcyBzb2JyZSBhIHNlZ3VuZGEgaW5zdOJuY2lhLCBvIEJyYXNpbCBleHBsb2RlLg==

    1. UXVlbSB2b3RhciBjb250cmEgbm8gY29uZ3Jlc3NvLHRlcuEgbyBub21lIGRpdnVsZ2FkbyBlbSBsZXRyYXMgZ2FycmFmYWlzLi4uLkFkZXVzIHZpZGEgcPpibGljYS7JIE5PSVggTkFTIFVSTkFTLi4u

Ler comentários
  1. RRogério disse:

    TyBwcm9mZXNzb3IgSXZlcyBHYW5kcmEgc2VtcHJlIGZvaSB1bWEgdm96IHF1ZSBjbGFtYSBubyBkZXNlcnRvLCBtYXMgdW1hIHZveiBkZSBzYWJlZG9yaWEuIFRvbWFyYSBxdWUgZWxlIGVzdGVqYSBjZXJ0by4g

  2. SSueli disse:

    TyBkaWbtY2lsIOkgbyBDb25ncmVzc28sIGNvbSB0YW50b3MgY29ycnVwdG9zLCBhcHJvdmFyIGEgMqogaW5zdOJuY2lhLiA=

  3. Guilherme disse:

    QXTpIGFsZ3XpbSAiZXZvbHVpciIgZSBtdWRhciBkZSBpZGVpYS4uLi4=

  4. Almeida disse:

    RWxlcyBTQUJFTSBNVUlUTyBCRU0gcXVlIGEgaW5zdGFiaWxpZGFkZSBpbnN0aXR1Y2lvbmFsIGUgYSBpbnNlZ3VyYW7nYSBqdXLtZGljYSB0b3JuYW0gbyBwYe1zIG7jbyBjb25maeF2ZWwgcGFyYSBpbnZlc3RpbWVudG9zLiBT428gYSBnYXJhbnRpYSBkbyBpbnN1Y2Vzc28gZG8gZ292ZXJubyBlIHN1Y2Vzc28gZG9zIGNvcnJ1cHRvcy4=

  5. Nilson disse:

    QXF1aSBhIGNoYW1hZGEgc3VwcmVtYSBjb3J0ZSBwZXJkZXUgc3VhIGNyZWRpYmlsaWRhZGUgZGlhbnRlIGRhcyBh5/VlcyBkZSBhbGd1bnMgZG9zIHNldXMgdG9nYWRvcyBkZXNwcmVwYXJhZG9zIHBhcmEgYSBmdW7n428gZSBtYWwgaW50ZW5jaW9uYWRvcyAgZSBxdWUgYXBlcXVlbmFyYW0gYSBpbnN0aXR1aefjby4=

  6. siqueira disse:

    Y29tIG8gaW1wZWFjaGltZW50IGRvIGdpbG1hciBtZW50ZXMgZmFjaWxpdGEgbXVpdG8sIHNpbXBsZXMgYXNzaW0h

    1. VmVqYSBFc3NlIExJTksgLi4uICBpcy5nZC9WZW5lenVlbGFhVklTVEE=

    2. UFRvZm9saSwgR2lsbWFyZG9sYXJlJCQkIHPjbyB0dWRvIENSSU1JTk9TT1MsdW0gcmVjZWJlIE1lc2FkYSBkZSBSJDEwMCBNSUwgZGUgdW1hIENhZmV0aW5hIG8gb3V0cm8gdGVtIHVtYSBBZHYgUFJPU1RJLlRVVEEgZSB1bSB0YWwgZGUgIklEUCIuLi5WZWphIEFRVUk6Li4u

  7. antonio disse:

    RXN04SBjb250YW5kbyBjb20gYSBWaXJhIENhc2FjYSBSb3NhIFdlYmVyPyEgS2trLiDJIHPzIG1vc3RyYSBxdWUgb3MgQ3LhcHVsYXMgcXVlIG5lZ2FyYW0gYSBwcmlz428gZW0gMmEgbuNvIGxpZ2FtIHBhcmEgYSBDb24kdG90dW8kJONvLiBT8yBvIGJvbHNvISBGIGRhIFA=

  8. João disse:

    TmVtIGRldmVyaWEgc2Ugb3BvciBtZXNtbywgYWZpbmFsIHF1ZSBsZWdpc2xhIOkgbyBDb25ncmVzc28uIE91IGRldmVyaWEsIGVzdGUgU1RGIGrhIHVzdXJwb3UgYSBwcmVycm9nYXRpdmEgZG8gQ29uZ3Jlc3NvLg==

  9. leopoldo disse:

    QSByZWFsOiA2eDUgcHLzIGx1bGEuIEFsZ3XpbSB0ZW0gZPp2aWRhcz8=

  10. socrates2019 disse:

    VeksIG1hcyBhcXVpIG5hIHJlcPpibGljYSBkZSBiYW5hbmFzIG7jbyDpIG8gU1RGIHF1ZSBsZWdpc2xhPyBO428g6SBvIFNURiBxdWUgcmFzZ2EgYSBjb25zdGl0dWnn428g4CBsYSBMZXZhbmRvd3NraSBubyBpbXBlYWNobWVudCBkZSBEaWxtYT8gTuNvIOkgbyByZWlubyBkZSBUb2Zmb2xpIGUgR2lsbWFyIE1lbmRlcz8=

  11. Jorge disse:

    QSBiYW5kYSBwb2RyZSBkbyBTVEYgcXVlIGThIHByb3Rl5+NvIGEgY29ycnVwdG9zIOkgY2FwYXogZGUgdHVkby4gRWxlcyB2aW9sYW0gYSByYXrjbywgaW52ZW50YW0gcmVncmFzIGEgcG9zdGVyaW9yaSwgYnVybGFtIGEgbGVnaXNsYefjbywgYWdyaWRlbSBhIHNvY2llZGFkZSBlIG11aXRvIG1haXMu

  12. SPA disse:

    RGlm7WNpbCBhcnJpc2NhciBwYWxwaXRlcy4gIERvIG91dHJvIGxhZG8gdGVtb3MgZmlndXJhcyBkZSBwZXNvIDogR2lsbWFyICwgTUFNLCBUb2Zmb2xpLCAgV2hpc2t5ICwgRGVjYW5vICAuLi5BdHVhbmRvIG5hIGJhc2UgZGEgcHJlc3PjbyAgLCB0ZW1vcyBvIFBpbmdndedvIGUgc2V1IHPpcXVpdG8uIA==

    1. VG9kbyQgb3MgJGl0YWRvJCBhJCRpbWEgc+NvIEbpbGEkIGRhIFB1dGEgZSBsYWRy9WUkLiAkaW1wbGUkJCBhJCRpbQ==

  13. Ronaldo disse:

    U1RGIG5vIEJyYXNpbCBu428gbm9zIHJlcHJlc2VudGFtIHPjbyBhIGZhdm9yIGRlQmFuZGlkb3MsIHF1ZXJlbSBsZWdpc2xhciwgduNvIHNlIGNhbmRpZGF0YXIgYWxndW0gY2FyZ28gcG9saXRpY28u

  14. SANDRO disse:

    QWdvcmEgcXVlIGrhIHNvbHRhcmFtIG9zIGNvcnJ1cHRvcyBlIG8gY2hlZmUgZGVsZXM/IFBvZGUgbWFuZGFyIHVtYSBtZWRpZGEgcHJvdmlz83JpYSBxdWUgYXByb3ZhbSAuLiBuaG9uaG9jcmFjaWEuIA==

  15. Thanos disse:

    QSBjb25zdGl0dWnn428gZGUgODgg6SB1bSByYWJpc2NvIGNvbXVuaXN0YSBxdWUgcHJvdGVnZSBjcmltaW5vc29zLiBD83BpYSBlc2NyYWNoYWRhIGRhIHBvcnR1Z3Vlc2EgZSBuZW0gcHJldml1IHJlY2FsbCBkZSBwb2xpdGljb3MuIMkgbWFsIHJlZGlnaWRhLCBjb21vIG8gYXJ0LiA1ui4gTk9WQSBDT05TVElUVUlOVEUgSsEu

    1. VWxpJCRlJCBHdWltYXLjZSQ6IEbpbGEgZGEgUHV0YS4gQXBvZHJl52Egbm8gZnVuZG8gZG8gTWFy

  16. NELSON disse:

    QVTpIHBvciBxdWUgc2UgaW5zaXN0aXJlbSBuZXNzYSBiYW5kYWxoZWlyYSBub3MgdmFtb3MgaW52YWRpciBvIFNURi4=

  17. josé disse:

    TWFzLGVzc2UgdGFsICJzdXByZW1vIiBwZXRpc3RhIOkgZG8gcG92byBicmFzaWxlaXJvLlRyYWlkb3JlcyBkYSBw4XRyaWEuSW5pbWlnb3MgZG8gQnJhc2lsLg==

  18. Felipe disse:

    Um9zYSBXZWJlciwgbuNvIOkgbWF1IGNhcuF0ZXIsIHPzIOkgYnVycmluaGE=

  19. ant!pet!sta disse:

    QXNzaW0gbWVzbW8sIGFjaG8gcXVlIG8gU1RGIHZvdGFyaWEgY29udHJhLCBuYXMgcGFsYXZyYXMgZGUgTWVsbG8u

  20. Ronaldo disse:

    UGVzcXVpc2UgU1RGIG5vIEdvb2dsZTogInZjIHF1aXMgZGl6ZXIgU1RMIHN1cHJlbW8gdHJpYnVuYWwgZG8gTHVsYSI=

  21. Edu_Brasil disse:

    U2Vy4SBxdWUgbyBTVEYgauEgbuNvIGRldmVyaWEgc2VyIGFwZW5hcyB1bSB0cmlidW5hbCBjb25zdGl0dWNpb25hbCwgc2VtIHNlIGltaXNjdWlyIGVtIG91dHJhcyBtYXTpcmlhcz8gT3Ugc2Vy4SBxdWUsIGFs6W0gZGUgbGVnaXNsYXIsIG8gcHLzcHJpbyBTVEYgcXVlaXJhIGRlY2lkaXIgc29icmUgbyBxdWUgcG9kZSBqdWxnYXI/IA==

  22. Paulo disse:

    RGV1cyBvdedhIG8gZXgtbWluaXN0cm8uIE8gbm9zc28gU1RGIOkgdW1hIHJlYefjbyBxde1taWNhIGluc3ThdmVsLiBVbWEgcmVh5+NvIHF17W1pY2EgaW5zdOF2ZWwg6SBhcXVlbGEgcXVlIG11ZGEgbyByZXN1bHRhZG8gYW8gbWVub3IgZGVzZXF1aWztYnJpby4g

  23. Michael disse:

    U2UgYWNvbnRlY2UgdW1hIGNvaXNhIGRlc3NhcyBvIHBvdm8gZmVjaGEgdHVkbw==

  24. Rodrigo disse:

    U2UgbyBTVEYgc2Ugb3B1c2VyIG1haXMgdW1hIHZleiBhIHZvbnRhZGUgZGUgcG9wdWxhciwgY29tIGNlcnRlemEgbyBCcmFzaWwgZW50cmEgbnVtYSBndWVycmEgY2l2aWwuIA==

  25. Antonio disse:

    U2VtcHJlIGhhdmVy4SA1IGVtcHJlZ2Fkb3MgZG8gUFQ=

  26. Marcos disse:

    QW8gdm90YXIgYSBxdWVzdONvLCBvIFNURiBu428gZXN0YXLhIHZvdGFuZG8gcGVsYSBwcmlz428gZW0gc2VndW5kYSBpbnN04m5jaWEgZSBzaW0gcGVsYSBwcvNwcmlhIHNvYnJldml26m5jaWEgYSBjdXJ0byBwcmF6by4g

  27. Mauricio disse:

    Tm9zc28gYW1pZ28gZXN04SBjaHV0YW5kby4gQXJndW1lbnRvIHBhcmEgZ2FsZXJhIGlnbmFyYS4gVm9sdGFuZG8gYSByZWFsaWRhZGUgZnJpYSwgc2Vy4SBiYXJyYWRvIHBvaXMg6SBpbmNvbnN0aXR1Y2lvbmFsLg==

  28. Lucas disse:

    SXNzbyDpIHF1YW5kbyB2YyB0ZW0gdW0gU1RGIG5vcm1hbCwgY29tIHBlc3NvYXMgbm9ybWFpcywgcXVlIG1lc21vIGRpdmVyZ2luZG8sIGJ1c2NhbSBvIG1lbGhvci4gUXVhbmRvIHZjIHRlbSBCQU5ESURPUyBpbmRpY2Fkb3MgcG9yIFBFVElTVEFTIGEgY29pc2EgbXVkYS4uLiBWaXJhIHVtIHRyaWJ1bmFsIGJvbGl2YXJpYW5vLCBjb21vIG8gbm9zcw==

  29. Fabio disse:

    UXVlbSBlIG8gU1RGPyBlbGUgbuNvIGxlZ2lzbGEsIG8gU1RGIGrhIHVsdHJhcGFzc291IHNldXMgbGltaXRlcyBsZWdhaXMgc3VhcyBhdHJpYnVp5/VlcywgcXVlIFRvZmZvbGkgc2VyIHByZXNpZGVudGUgZGEgUmVw+mJsaWNhIHVzdXJwYW5kbyBvIHBvZGVyIGRvcyBvdXRyb3MgcG9kZXJlcyBjcmltaW5vc2FtZW50ZQ==

  30. mara disse:

    U28gZmFsdGF2YSBlc3NhIG8gU1RGIGRlcnJ1YmFyIGFwcm92YefjbyBkbyBDb25ncmVzc28gcWRvIGNhYmUgYSBlc3NlIGxlZ2lzbGFyLiAgU1RGIGRldmVyaWEgZm9jYXIgbm9zIGlucXXpcml0b3MgcGFyYWRvcyBlIGRlaXhhciBkZSBwcmlvcml6YXIgb3MgcGVkaWRvcyBkZSBMdWxhIGUgbuNvIGxlZ2lzbGFyIGVtIGNhdXNhIHBy83ByaWEu

  31. Marcia disse:

    TyBxdWUgZWxlcyBxdWVyaWFtIHVyZ2VybnRlbWVudGUgamEgZm9pIGNvbnN1bWFkbyBpc3RvIOksb3MgIm1pZ3V4b3MiIGNvcnJ1cHV0b3MgZm9yYW0gc29sdG9zIC4uLg==

  32. GILMAR disse:

    TyBwaW9yIOkgcXVlIGVzc2Ugc3RmLCDpIG8gcGlvciBzdGYgZGEgaGlzdPNyaWEgZGVzc2UgcGHtcywgc2Vy4SBxdWUgbyBzci4gTuNvIGVzdOEgc2VuZG8gbXVpdG8gb3RpbWlzdGEsIGrhIHRldmUgdW0gZ21kZXNzZXMgIm1pbmlzdHJvcyAiYWkgcXVlIGrhIGZhbG91IHF1ZSBzZXJpYSB1bSBhZnJvbnRvIGRvIGNvbmdyZXNzbyxh

  33. Marcelo disse:

    U3IuIEdhbmRyYTogbWUgYWRtaXJhIG8gU2VuaG9yIGRlaXhhciBzdWJlbnRlbmRpZG8gcXVlIHVtYSBsZWkgcXVlIHBvc3NpYmlsaXRhIGEgcHJpc+NvIGVtIHNlZ3VuZGEgaW5zdOJuY2lhIG5vIGNvbmdyZXNzbyB0ZW5oYSBkZSwgZW0gc2VndWlkYSwgcGFzc2FyIHBlbG8gY3Jpdm8gZG8gU1RGLiBJc29sYSEhIQ==

  34. Billy disse:

    Q2xhcm8gcXVlIG7jbyBpcuEgc2Ugb3BvciEgTyB1bHRyYWNvcnJ1cHRvIGrhIGVzdOEgc29sdG8=