A Bia, Paulo Freire e eu

Em sua coluna na Crusoé, Mario Sabino trata do humilhante resultado do Brasil no Pisa, o exame de avaliação de alunos de 15 anos coordenado pela OCDE.

O colunista escreve sobre Paulo Freire e seu método de ensino festejado pelas esquerdas — com o qual Sabino teve contato graças a uma amiga que conheceu em 1980, em um cursinho pré-vestibular.

Leia um trecho:

“Ao fim e ao cabo, não acho que Paulo Freire seja o maior culpado da nossa miséria escolar. Ele é somente um dos culpados — inclusive ao inculcar a ideia de que se deve alfabetizar adultos em massa. Os militares fizeram uso dessa ideia e criaram o Mobral, que serviu apenas para alastrar o analfabetismo funcional. O negócio é alfabetizar crianças. Se vai começar pelas sílabas arbitrárias ou não, pouco importa. O essencial é que, ao final, elas não usem cê-cedilha em ‘opressor’. A verdade é que nossas escolas sempre foram ruins, com as exceções de praxe. Elas só demonstraram que era possível piorar quando passaram a ser centros de doutrinação. Mas há muitos doutrinadores ideológicos capazes de transmitir uma visão ‘bancária’ do conhecimento aos alunos. Eles podem ser bons nisso.”

Leia a íntegra na Crusoé:

A Bia, Paulo Freire e eu

O isolamento do PT e o racha histórico na esquerda. Mais aqui

Comentários temporariamente fechados.

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem. Em respeito a todos os leitores, não são publicados comentários que contenham palavras ou conteúdos ofensivos.

  1. Clayton disse:

    UHJpbWVpcm8gcG9udG86IG5vc3NhcyBlc2NvbGFzIG5lbSBzZW1wcmUgZm9yYW0gcnVpbnMuIFNlZ3VuZG8gcG9udG86IFNJTSwgYSBjdWxwYSBkbyBkZXNhc3RyZSBkZSB0b2RvIG5vc3NvIHNpc3RlbWEgZGUgZW5zaW5vIOkgZGUgUGF1bG8gRnJlaXJlIGUgc2V1IGVtYnVzdGUgcGVkYWfzZ2ljbyE=

Ler comentários
  1. José disse:

    Tm9zIHJlc3RvdSBvIFNvYnJhbCwgYSBzb2JyYSBkbyBNb2JyYWwu

  2. Ricardo disse:

    RWR1Y2Hn428sIG3pcml0byBlIHRyYWJhbGhvLiBPIHJlc3RvIOkgdGV0YS4uLg==

  3. Francisco disse:

    TmEg6XBvY2EgZG9zIG1pbGl0YXJlcywgYXMgZXNjb2xhcyBw+mJsaWNhcyBlcmFtIG8gc29uaG8gZGUgY29uc3VtbyBkb3MgcGFpcyBkb3MgYWx1bm9zLCBwZWxhIGV4Y2Vs6m5jaWEgZG8gZW5zaW5vIGUgbXVpdG8gbWVsaG9yZXMgcXVlIGFzIGVzY29sYXMgcGFydGljdWxhcmVzLiA=

    1. RXNjb2xhcyBxdWUgc/MgYWRtaXRlbSBwb3IgY29uY3Vyc28gdGVuZGVtIGEgc2VyIG1lbGhvcmVzIHF1ZSBlc2NvbGFzIGFiZXJ0YXMuIEFzIHVuaXZlcnNpZGFkZXMgcHJpdmFkYXMgYWNlaXRhbSBxdWFscXVlciB1bSwgbuNvIOkgdW0gcHJpdmls6WdpbyBlc3RhciBlbSB1bWEu

    2. Q29tcGFyYXIgdW0gbGl4byBjb20gb3V0cm8gZSBkaXplciBxdWFsIOkgbyBtZWxob3IgYSBjb252ZXJzYSBkZSByYXRvLi4u

    3. QmFzdGEgdmVyIG9zIG9jdXBhbnRlcyBkb3MgY2FyZ29zIHD6YmxpY29zIG1haXMgYWx0b3MgZG8gcGHtcywgZG9zIGNvbmN1cnNvcyBtYWlzIGRpZu1jZWlzLCBjb21vIG8gZG8gRGVsdGFuIGUgZG8gTW9ybyAocXVhbmRvIGp1aXopLiBWZWphbSBzZSBhIG1haW9yaWEgZXN0dWRvdSBlbSBwYXJ0aWN1bGFyZXMuIE7jby4gUNpCTElDQVMu

    4. Tm8gbWV1IHRlbXBvIGRlIGVzY29sYSBhIHBhcnRpY3VsYXIgZXJhIGNoYW1hZGEgZGUgUFBQLg==

    5. RXN0dWRlaSBlbSBlc2NvbGEgcPpibGljYSBlIHRhbWLpbSBlbSBwYXJ0aWN1bGFyLiBGaXogZ3JhZHVh5+NvIGRlIG7tdmVsIHN1cGVyaW9yIGVtIHD6YmxpY2EgZSB0YW1i6W0gbnVtYSBwYXJ0aWN1bGFyLiBTaW5jZXJhbWVudGU/IE8gZW5zaW5vIGRhIHVuaXZlcnNpZGFkZSBw+mJsaWNhIOkgbXVpdG8gbWVsaG9yLg==

    6. TuNvLCBu428gZXJhbS4gRXJhbSBtZWxob3JlcyBxdWUgaG9qZT8gU2ltLCBlcmFtLCBtYXMgbuNvIGVyYW0gbWVsaG9yZXMgcXVlIGFzIHBhcnRpY3VsYXJlcy4gU2ltLCBldSBFU1RVREVJIG5lc3NlIHBlcu1vZG8gZSBjb25oZedvIGJlbSBkbyBxdWUgZmFsby4gRXNjb2xhIHD6YmxpY2EgZGUgZXhjZWzqbmNpYSBhY2Fib3Ugbm9zIGFubw==

  4. JohnGalt disse:

    QSBlc3F1ZXJkYSBzZW1wcmUgZm9pIHVtIGRlc2FzdHJlLCAgcG9yIG9uZGUgcGFzc2EgZGVpeGEgdW0gcmFzdHJvIGRlIG1pc+lyaWEsIHZpb2zqbmNpYSBlIGJ1cnJpY2UuIEFzIHVuaXZlcnNpZGFkZXMgcPpibGljYXMgbuNvIHBhc3NhbSBkZSBtYWRyYXNzYXMgaWRlb2zzZ2ljYXMg

    1. Qe0gYSBEaXJlaXRhbGhhIHZhaSBmYXplciBjdXJzaW5oby4uLiBFIHBhZ2EgcXVhbCBjdXJzaW5obz8gTyBxdWUgZXN04SByZXBsZXRvIGRlIHByb2Zlc3NvcmVzIGZvcm1hZG9zIG5hcyBQ+mJsaWNhcyBIQUhBSEFIQUhBLCBjYXJhLCB2b2PqcyBz428gcGF06XRpY29zLg==

    2. yT8gU2Vy4T8gQWdvcmEgYSBwZXJndW50YSDpPyBTZSBhIERpcmVpdGFsaGEgZGUgcGFydGljdWxhcmVzIOkgdONvIGJvYSBlIGludGVsaWdlbnRlLCBq4SBxdWUgb3MgZGEgUPpibGljYSBz428gYm/nYWlzIChzZWd1bmRvIHZvY+pzKSwgcG9ycXVlIG7jbyBwYXNzYW0gbm9zIGNvbmN1cnNvcyBlIG9jdXBhbSBvcyBhbHRvcyBjYXJn

    3. RGVsdGFuIG5vIG1vbWVudG8gZXN04SBtYWlzIGVzcXVlcmRpc3RhIGRvIHF1ZSBvIE1vcm8uIE1vcm8gZXN04SBhcHJlbmRlbmRvIGNvbSBCb2xzb25hcm8gbyBvdXRybyBsYWRvIGUgauEgbuNvIHRlbSB0YW50byBjYWNvZXRlIGNvbW8gbm8gcGFzc2FkbywgZSBpc3NvIOkgYm9tLg==

    4. yT8gVmFpIHZlciBvbmRlIERlbHRhbiBlIE1vcm8gZXN0dWRhcmFtLCBwYS1uYS1jYS4=

  5. Renato disse:

    U2UgbyBwcm9ibGVtYSBmb3NzZSBz8yBlc3NlIGFpbmRhIHNlcmlhIHBlcXVlbm8uIE8gcHJvYmxlbWEg6SBxIGVtIG1laW8gYSBkaXNjdXNz9WVzIGltYmVjaXMgZGUgdW1hIHBlZGFnb2dpYSBpbvp0aWwgZWxlIGRlZmVuZGUgbyBhc3Nhc3NpbmF0byBkZSBhZHZlcnPhcmlvcyBjb21vIGZvcm1hIGxlZ+10aW1hIGRlIHByb3Rlc3RvLg==

  6. Izaias disse:

    UGVyZmVpcm8gZml6ZW1vcyB1bSBleGVyY2l0byBkZSBhbmFsZmFiZXRvcyBmdW5jaW9uYWlzIHF1ZSBzZXJ2ZW0gZGUgbWFzc2EgZGUgbWFub2JyYS4gT3Ugc2VqYSB1bSBjdXJyYWwgZWxlaXRvcmFsLiA=

  7. disse:

    QmxhYmxhYmzhLCBlc3F1ZXJkYSBvdSBkaXJlaXRhLCBlbnNpbm8gbm8gQnJhc2lsIHNlbXByZSBmb2kgcG9yY2FyaWEsIHB1YmxpY2Egb3UgcHJpdmFkYSwgY29tIG91IHNlbSBpZGVvbG9naWEuIFF1ZSBmdW5jaW9uYSBuZXN0ZSBwYe1zPyBOYWRhLiBUZW0gZ2VudGUgcXVlIG7jbyBmb2kgImRvdXRyaW5hZGEiIGUg6SBzYWZhLWRhIHRiLg==

  8. Chrisoula disse:

    TGVtYnJvIGRvIHBvbOptaWNvIGxpdnJvIGxhbudhZG8gcGVsbyBNRUMgKHFkby4gTWluLiBkYSBFZHVjYefjbyBlcmEgbyBQb3N0ZSBIYWRkYWQpIHF1ZSBvIGNlcnRvIGVyYSBmYWxhciBlbSBjbGFzc2UgIk7zaXMgcGVnYSBvcyBwZWl4ZSIuICAgIEThIHBhcmEgdGVyIGJvbnMgcmVzdWx0YWRvcyBlbSBlZHVjYefjbyA/Pz8/Pz8/

    1. RSBvIG1pbmlzdHJvIHVzb3UgZSBlc2NyZXZldSBwYXJhbGl6Yefjby4=

  9. José disse:

    QSBkb3V0cmluYSDpIGEgZm9ybWEgYnVyckAgZGUgZWR1Y2FyIGFsZ3XpbS4=

  10. Mezenga disse:

    UGF1bG8gRnJlaXJlIGZ1bmNpb25hIHBhcmEgcXVlbSBq4SB0ZW0gZWR1Y2Hn428sIG1hcyBu428gZOEgcHJhIGRhciBlc3NhIGxpYmVyZGFkZSB0b2RhIHBhcmEgYWx1bm9zIHF1ZSBu428gcmVzcGVpdGFtIG9zIHByb2Zlc3NvcmVzIG91IHTqbSB2b250YWRlIGRlIGFwcmVuZGVyLg==

    1. Q29tdW5pc21vIG7jbyBmdW5jaW9uYSBwcmEgbmluZ3XpbSwgUGF1bG8gRnJlaXJlIOkgcHVybyBsaXhvIGRhIGlkZW9sb2dpYSBtYXJ4aXN0YQ==

    2. VmlkZSBvIG1pbmlzdHJvIHF1ZSBu428gc2FiZSBlc2NyZXZlciBwYXJhbGlzYefjby4=

  11. Marmitademiliciano disse:

    Qm96byBwcmVzaWRlbnRlLCBsaXZyb3MgZG8gTmFybG91Y28gZW50cmUgb3MgbWFpcyB2ZW5kaWRvcy4gQWxndeltIGR1dmlkYSBtZXNtbyBkZSBxdWUgYSBub3NzYSBlZHVjYefjbyDpIHVtIGRlc2FzdHJlPw==

    1. ZSBjb20gZXN0ZSBnb3Zlcm5vIHPzIHBpb3JhLi4uLi5vIHF1ZSBzZSBkaXogZW52aWFkbyBwb3IgRGV1cy4uLi5pbmFjcmVkaXRhdmVs

  12. Ghost disse:

    Sm9ybmFsaXN0YXMsIHBvciBuYXR1cmV6YSwgdOptIHVtYSB2aXPjbyBzaW1wbGlzdGEgc29icmUgbyBtdW5kby4gT3MgYm9sc29uYXJpc3RhcywgZW50428sIGNoZWdhbSBhIHNlciBtYWlzIHJhc29zIGVtIHN1YXMgdGVzZXMgZG8gcXVlIG8gcHLzcHJpbyBndXJ1LCBjb25mdW5kaW5kbyBhbGZhYmV0aXph5+NvIGNvbSBvcnRvZ3JhZmlhLiA=

    1. UXVlbSBmZXogdW1hIGJvYSBhbGZhYmV0aXph52FvIGRpZmljaWxtZW50ZSAgZXJyYSBuYSBncmFmaWEu

  13. Adélio disse:

    TmVzdGUgY2FzbywgbyBtaW5pc3RybyBkYSBkZXNlZHVjYefjbyBu428gZm9pIGFsZmFiZXRpemFkbyBq4SBxdWUgZWxlIGUgdm9j6iBjcml0aWNhIHR1ZG8uIENvbW8gZXhlbXBsbywgZWxlIG7jbyBhcHJlbmRldSBlc2NyZXZlciBQYXJhbGlzYefjby4gTGVtYnJhIGRpc3NvLCBQYXJhbGl6Yefjby4=

  14. Marco disse:

    UGF1bG8gRnJlaXJlLCDpIHPzIHVtIGplZ3VlIOAgbWFpcyBuYSBqZWd1aWNlIG5hY2lvbmFsLg==

  15. Brasileiro disse:

    TyBzZWdyZWRvIGRhIGVkdWNh5+NvIOkgdW0gc/M6IGF1dG9lZHVjYefjbywgb3Ugc2VqYSwgYXByZW5kZXIgYSBlc3R1ZGFyIGUgY3VsdGl2YXIgZXNzZSBo4WJpdG8uIEEgZXNjb2xhIGFwZW5hcyBvcmllbnRhLg==

  16. Aparecida disse:

    ySBwcmVjaXNvIHF1ZSBmaXF1ZSBjbGFybyBxdWUgYSBlZHVjYefjbyBubyBCcmFzaWwg6SBydWltLCBw+mJsaWNhIG91IHByaXZhZGEuIFBpc2EgZGVtb25zdHJhIHF1ZSBhbHVubyBkYSBlc2NvbGEgcHJpdmFkYSBlc3ThIG5vIG1lc21vIG7tdmVsIGRvcyBwaW9yZXMgYWx1bm9zIG5hIFVFLg==

  17. FABIO disse:

    RXN0ZSBjYXJhIG7jbyBjb25oZWNldSBvIE1vYnJhbC4gRXN04SBkaXplbmRvIGJlc3RlaXJhLiBFIHBvciBxdWUgYSBsaWdh5+NvIGRvIGPqLWNlZGlsaGEgY29tIG9wcmVzc29yPyBO428gaOEgb3V0cmFzIHBhbGF2cmFzIHBhcmEgbyBtZXNtbyBleGVtcGxvPyBWYWRlIHJldHJvLg==

  18. EDUARDO disse:

    UHJhIGNvbWXnbyBkZSBjb252ZXJzYSBlc3R1ZGFyIOkgdW0gZGlyZWl0byAoRUNBIHByb+1iZSBleHB1bHP1ZXMpIHF1ZW0gbuNvIHF1ZXIgZXN0dWRhciwgc/MgYXRyYXBhbGhhLiBTZSBwdWRlc3NlIGFzIHNhbGFzIGrhIG1lbGhvcmFyaWFtLCBwLyBxdWVtIGZpY2Fzc2UgdmFsZXJpYSAgYSBmcmFzZSJhIGNhbmV0YSDpICsgbGV2ZSA=

  19. Marcelo disse:

    RSBhIGVkdWNh5+NvIGRvIEJyYXNpbCBjb250aW51YSBhIGxldmFyIHBpc2Eu

  20. Renato disse:

    TyBCcmFzaWwgbuNvIGVzdOEgbmVtIHBlcnRvIGRlIGRlYmF0ZXIgc2VyaWFtZW50ZSBxdWVzdPVlcyBwZWRhZ/NnaWNhcywgdml2ZW1vcyBlbSB1bSBjaGlxdWVpcm8gaWRlb2zzZ2ljby4gUGF1bG8gRnJlaXJlIGVyYSB1bSBtaWxpdGFudGUsIG7jbyBkZXZlIG5lbSBtZXNtbyBmYXplciBwYXJ0ZSBkYSBkaXNjdXNz428u

    1. Q29uY29yZG8gbGl4byBjb211bmlzdGEsIG8gc/NjaW8gY29uc3RydXRpdmlzbW8gc/MgZW1idXJyZWNlIGUgZm9ybWEgbWlsaXRhbnRlcyBkbyBwYXJ0aWTjby4g