Advogado da Petrobras aponta provas diretas e indiretas contra Lula

O advogado da Petrobras, René Ariel Dotti, que vai defender no TRF-4 o aumento da pena de Lula, falou ao Estadão sobre as abundantes provas contra o condenado:

“A defesa do ex-Presidente insiste em afirmar que não existe prova suficiente para condenar o seu cliente. Na verdade, porém, o convencimento do juiz criminal – em qualquer tipo de processo e de crime – é formado pela livre apreciação da prova produzida no contraditório judicial, como prevê o Código Penal, art. 155.

Sim, existem não somente as provas diretas, como depoimentos, documentos, exames, mensagens eletrônicas, reformas no apartamento tríplex 164 A, cuja propriedade de fato era do ex-presidente e sua esposa, que demonstram a existência do crime de corrupção passiva, ou seja, obtenção indevida de vantagem decorrente em parte dos contratos do Consórcio CONEST/RNEST, celebrados com a Petrobras em razão do cargo de presidente. Há, também, provas indiretas, indícios, para a condenação.

Há prova mais que suficiente do crime de lavagem de dinheiro pelas condutas de ocultação e dissimulação, inclusive com as reformas do apartamento: fraudes documentais em documentos de aquisição de imóveis, manutenção do imóvel em nome da OAS Empreendimentos, etc. O crime está previsto no art. 1.º, caput, inciso V da Lei  nº 9.613/1998, ‘envolvendo a ocultação e dissimulação  da titularidade do apartamento 164-A, triplex, e do beneficiário das reformas realizadas’. Está no trecho n.º 944, letra b, da sentença do juiz Sergio Moro.

Entre os meios para o convencimento do juiz sobre a existência e autoria de crimes é a existência de indícios.  Segundo o art. 239 do CPP: ‘Considera-se indício a circunstância conhecida e provada, que, tendo relação com o fato, autorize, por indução, concluir-se a existência de outra ou outras circunstâncias’. Existem, por acaso, indícios mais que evidentes da propriedade de fato do apartamento que as visitas feitas ao imóvel por ele e sua falecida esposa? As fotos ilustram muitas reportagens. Algumas até com o homem da OAS.”

Deixe seu comentário

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site; a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem;
Tempo de publicação: 4 minutos

200

  1. Alzira disse:

    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

Ler comentários
  1. Luiz disse:

    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

    1. VmlyYW0gZSBmaWNhcmFtIHF1aWV0aW5ob3MgZHVyYW50ZSBtYWlzIGRlIDEwIGFub3MsIG7pPyBMZWdhbCwgaGVpbj8=

    2. QXTpIG5hIFZhbGUgZWxlIHRpcm91IG8gUm9nZXIgQWduZWxsaSBlIGNvbG9jb3UgdW0gcGF1IG1hbmRhZG8sIHF1ZSB0aW5oYSBxdWUgcGF0cm9jaW5hciBhdOkgYSBjYXJ0YSBjYXBpdGFsLg==

  2. LULA, disse:

    TFVMQURSQU8gICBOQSAgQ0FERUlBICBFICBQUk9OVE8gISEh

  3. #lulanacadeia disse:

    VGVtIOkgcXVlIHRyaXBsaWNhciBhIHBlbmEgZGVzc2Ugc3VqZWl0byENClJvdWJvdSwgYXNzYWx0b3UsIGVzdHVwcm91IG8gcGHtcyENClByb3Zhcz8gVGVtIGRlbWFpcyENCskgc/MgdmVyIGEgc2l0dWHn428gZG8gcGHtcyBob2plIQ0KVmVyIFBldHJvYnJhcywgZWxldHJvYnJhcywgY29ycmVpb3MsIGZ1bmRvcyBkZSBwZW5z428sIEJOREVTIGV0Yw==

  4. Logo, disse:

    TG9nbywgbG9nbyBvIEZIQyBq4SBzYWly4SBlbSBkZWZlc2EgZG8gUFVMSEEuICBWYWkgZmFsYXIgcXVlIGNvbmhlY2UgbyBsYWRy428gZSBxdWUgbyBsYWRy428gbuNvIOkgbGFkcuNvLg==

  5. Beto disse:

    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

  6. Renato disse:

    SOEgdGFtYultIG11aXRvcyByZWdpc3Ryb3MgZGEgaW1wcmVuc2EgKGRlIHF1YW5kbyBhaW5kYSBu428gaGF2aWEgZXN0b3VyYWRvIGVzY+JuZGFsbykgZW0gcXVlIHNlIGRpeiAiTHVsYSBkZXNjYW5zYSBlbSBzZXUgc+10aW8iIGV0YyBzZW0gcXVlIE5VTkNBIGVsZSB0ZW5oYSBkZXNtZW50aWRvLg==

  7. Jose disse:

    U2Ugdm9j6iBwZXRpc3RhIGxlciBvIHRleHRvIGRvIGFkdm9nYWRvIGRhIFBldHJvYnJhcyBhdOkgbyBmaW5hbCB2YWkgZW50ZW5kZXIgcXVlbSBlcmEgZGUgZmF0byBvIHByb3ByaWV04XJpbyBkbyBUcmlwbGV4LCBtYXMgc2VpIHF1ZSB2b2PqcyBu428gcXVlcmVtIGVueGVyZ2FyIGEgcmVhbGlkYWRlIG5lPw==

  8. Pensando disse:

    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

  9. José disse:

    TmVuaHVtIGp1aXogY29uZGVuYSBhbGd16W0gc2VtIHByb3Zhcy4NClPzIGEgcmVjbGFtYefjbyBkbyBiYW5kbyBwZWxhIHByZXNzYSBlbSBqdWxnYXIgdW0gaW5vY2VudGUgZGl6IHR1ZG8uDQpO428gcXVlcmVyIHVtIGp1bGdhbWVudG8gZGUgdW0gaW5vY2VudGUga2tra2tra2tr

  10. Joe disse:

    U3VnaXJvIGFvcyBwZXRpc3RhcyBxdWUgc2FiZW0gbGVyIGUgbuNvIHPjbyBhbmFsZmFiZXRvcyBmdW5jaW9uYWlzIHF1ZSBlc3R1ZGVtIFRlb3JpYSBkYXMgUHJvdmFzIHBhcmEgdG9tYXIgY29uaGVjaW1lbnRvIGRvcyBkaWZlcmVudGVzIHRpcG9zIGRlIHByb3Zhcy4=

  11. Cristaldo-SP disse:

    THVnYXIgZGUgbGFkcuNvIGNvcnJ1cHRvIGUgbmEgY2FkZWlhLCBu428gc2VpIG8gcXVlIGZhbHRhIHBhcmEgcHJlbmTqLWxvcyB0b2Rvcy4NClRpcmFyIGVzc2EgY2FuZ2EgZG8gQnJhc2lsIHNlcmlhIHVtIGFs7XZpbyBwYXJhIGFzIHBlc3NvYXMgZGVjZW50ZXMsIGhvbmVzdGFzIGUgdHJhYmFsaGFkb3Jhcy4NCiNsdWxhTmFQcmlz428NCiNsdWxhTmFDYWRlaWENCiNEaWxtYU5hUHJpc+NvDQojZXh0aW7n429Eb1BU

  12. Jocival disse:

    UGFyYSBvcyBqdW1lbnRvcyBhbGllbmFkb3Mgc/MgcG9kZW0gc2VyIGNvbnNpZXJhZG8gcG92YXMgZG91bWV0b3MgcmVnaXN0cmFkb3MgZW0gY2FydPNyaW8sIGF0ZXN0YW5kbyBhIHByb3ZhIGRhIHRpdHVsYXJpZGFkZSBkbyBpbfN2ZWwsIGUgbWVzbW8gYXNzaW0gc2UgbyBhY3VzYWRvIGFkbWl0aXIu

  13. eleitor disse:

    QSBPQUIgbuNvIHZhaSB0b21hciBuZW5odW1hIHByb3ZpZOpuY2lhIGNvbnRyYSBvIGFkdm9nYWRvIGRlIEx1bGEgcXVlIHRlbSBpbnN1bHRhZG8gZSBkZXNtb3JhbGl6YWRvIGEganVzdGnnYQ==

  14. Miguel disse:

    UGV0cm9icmFzIGpvZ291IHBlc2FkbyBhbyBjb250cmF0YXIgUmVuZSBEb3R0aS4gRXNzZSDpIG8gbWFpb3IganVyaXN0YSBkbyBwYe1zLg==

  15. CONTRA disse:

    RkhDIGUgUFVMSEEgc+NvIGZhcmluaGEgZG8gbWVzbW8gc2Fjby4NCk8gcHVsaGEgc2VtcHJlIHZpc2l0YXZhIG8gZmhjIGVtIHNldSBhcGFydGFtZW50byBkYSBydWEgbWFyYW5o428uDQpT428sIGp1bnRvcywgZnVuZGFkb3JlcyBkbyBGb3JvIGRlIFPjbyBQYXVsby4NCskgcHJlY2lzbyBkaXplciBhbGdvIG1haXM/

  16. MIMADO disse:

    S0QgQVMgUFJPRkE/IEx1bGEgZm9pIG11aXRvIG1pbWFkbywgc2VtcHJlIHRldmUgdHVkbyBxdWUgcXVpcyBkb3Mgc2V1cyBwdXhhIHNhY29zLCBhY2Fib3UgdmlyYW5kbyB1bSBpZG9zbyByZWJlbGRlLg==

  17. Hell disse:

    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

  18. ivanor disse:

    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

  19. Japonês disse:

    TWFuZGEgYSBkb2N1bWVudGHn428gcGFyYSBvIFJBLi4ucnM=

  20. NERO disse:

    RXNzZSBEci4gUmVu6SBBcmllbCBEb3R0aSDpIG11aXRvIHJlc3BlaXRhZG8gYXF1aSBubyBQYXJhbuEu

  21. SPA disse:

    RW0gcmVzdW1vLCAgZXNzYSBzZW1hbmEgbyBQaW5ndedvIGNvbWXnYSBhIHByZXBhcmFyIGFzIG1hbGFzIHBhcmEgbyBub3ZvIGVuZGVyZedvLg==