Barroso diz que ‘há um surto de garantismo’

Luís Roberto Barroso caminha para concluir seu voto pela validade das conduções coercitivas.

O ministro critica as indignações com esse instrumento. Ele lembra que essas conduções, antes de Gilmar Mendes proibi-las, estava em vigor havia quase 80 anos.

Segundo Barroso, “há um surto de garantismo”.

“Ninguém imagina extinguir a polícia porque houve um caso de abuso.”

O ministro também destacou que Câmara, Senado, AGU e PGR se manifestaram a favor da condução coercitiva.

“Seria ativismo do STF acolher essas ações.”

Comentários temporariamente fechados.

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site; a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem.

  1. Rodrigo disse:

    T2xoYSBxdWVtIGZhbGEsIG8gcGFwYSBkbyBnYXJhbnRpc21vLg==

Ler comentários
  1. Alberto disse:

    QmFycm9zbyBwb2RlbSBmYWxhciBvIHF1ZSBxdWlzZXIgZGVsZSBjb21vIGZheiBvIExhY2FpbywgbWFzIHVtYSBjb2lzYSBzZSB0ZW0gY2VydGV6YSwgbuNvIHThIGNvbSBvIFJBQk9QUkVTTyBwZWxvIEJvY2EuINpuaWNvIHF1ZSBlbmZyZW50YSBubyBwdXJnYW50ZS4=

  2. Gilberto Mendes disse:

    TyBTZW5hZG8gRkVERVJBTCBzZSBkZSBmYXRvIHJlcHJlc2VudGEgb3MgYnJhc2lsZWlyb3MsIFRFUklBIGEgb2JyaWdh5+NvIGRlIGNhc3NhciBzZXUgbWFuZGF0bywgdmlhIGltcGVhY2htZW50LCBFWEFUQU1FTlRFIGNvbW8gRGlsbWEuIFZlamFtb3MgbyBjYXNvIGRlIEhDIGRlIEx1bGEgbm8gU1RGLCBvIHBsYWNhciBmb2kgZGUgNiBYIDUgcGFyYSBvIENPUlJVUFRPLCBjb21wcm92YWRvLCBqdWxnYWRvLCBzZW50ZW5jaWFkbywgUVVBTkRPIG5hIHJlYWxpZGFkZSBkZXZlcmlhIHNlciAxMSBYIDAuIE5lc3NlIGRpYSBzZSBvIEdlbmVyYWwgVmlsbGFzIEJvYXMgbuNvIEJFUlJBIHRpbmhhIGRhZG8gTHVsYS4=

  3. Flávia disse:

    QSB2ZXJkYWRlIOkgcXVlIGEgc3VwcmVtYSBjb3J0ZSBlc3ThIHJlZultIGRlIGdpbG1hci4gRSBnaWxtYXIgdGFrdWt1bmFtYW8uIEUgYSBjZXJ0ZXphIOkgYSBkZSBxdWUgdG9kb3MgbOEgZXN0428u

  4. Lecerveau disse:

    QXRpdmlzbW8gc/Mg6SBib20gcXVhbmRvIGF0ZW5kZSBhIGFnZW5kYSBkbyBtaW5pc3Rybz8NCk1hcyDpIHByZWNpc28gYWRtaXRpciBxdWUsIG5lc3NlIGNhc28sIEJhcnJvc+NvIHRlbSByYXrjby4=

  5. tiko tiko disse:

    QmFycm9zbyBxZG8g6SBlbnRlbmRpbWVudG8gZGVsZTogySBwcmVjaXNvIGV2b2x1aXIsIG8gU1RGIHBvZGUgbGVnaXNsYXIuDQpRZG8gY29udHLhcmlvOiBQcm9pYmlyIGNvbmR15+NvIGNvZXJjaXRpdmEg6SBhdGl2aXNtbyBkbyBTVEYhISBra2tra2tra2tra2trDQoNCk8gbWFpb3IgYXRpdmlzdGEgZG8gU1RGIHNlIGNoYW1hIEJhcnJvc28uIEJyYXNpbCwgcGHtcyBkYSBwaWFkYSBwcm9udGEhIQ==

  6. Jorge disse:

    RXN0ZSBhc3N1bnRvIGZvaSBjb2xvY2FkbyBlbSBkaXNjdXNz428gYXBlbmFzIGUgc29tZW50ZSBxdWFuZG8gYSBQRiBjaGVnb3Ugbm8gZ3J1cG8gZGUgYW1pZ29zICwgTGFkcvVlcywgZG8gR2lsbWFyIE1lbmRlcy4NClBvcnRhbnRvLCBlc3ThIG5hIGhvcmEgZGUgbWFuZGFyIG8gR2lsbWFyIE1lbmRlcyBwYXJhIG8gbWVzbW8gbHVnYXIgcXVlIGVzdONvIGrhIHNldXMgcGFyY2Vpcm9zIGRhIE9SQ1JJTS4=

  7. José Coelho disse:

    R2lsbWFyIE1lbmRlcyDJLCBSZWFsbWVudGUsIG8gTUFJT1IgQXRpdmlzdGEgZG8gQ1JJTUUgT3JnYW5pemFkbyBkbyBCcmFzaWwuIFBPVk8gRE8gQ0VBUsEgDQpQT1ZPIEJSQVNJTEVJUk8gDQpWQU1PUyBQUkVTU0lPTkFSIE8gU0VOQURPUiBFVU5JQ0lPIERFIE9MSVZFSVJBIEVTVMEgRU5HQVZFVEFORE8gTyBJTVBFQUNITUVOVCBETyBHSUxNQVIhISEhISEgDQpPIFNlbmFkb3IgRVVOSUNJTyBERSBPTElWRUlSQSBlc3ThIFBSRVZBUklDQU5ETywgZXN04SBUUkFJTkRPIE8gQlJBU0lMICEhISE=

  8. Ze Ruelão disse:

    QWxvIGFsbyDNbmRpbywgdmFtb3MgYWdlbmRhciBlIGNoYW1hciBvIEJlaedvbGEgYXMgZmFsYXMsIHRhaXMgY29tIG1lZG8gZGUgcXXqIM1uZGlvPz8=

  9. Roberto disse:

    TyAiZ2FyYW50aXNtbyIgZXN04SBkZW50cm8gZGEgbGVpIEJhcnJvc28gdm9j6iDpIG1haXMgZG8gZGlyZWl0byBhY2hhZG8gbmEgcnVhPw==

  10. Edvaldo Nunes disse:

    UGVuc2F2YSBxdWUgZXN0YXZhIHNvemluaG8gcXVhbmRvIGFmaXJtYXZhIGlzc28uIEFpbmRhIGJlbSBxdWUgcGVyY2ViZXJhbSBhIGRpc2Z1bufjbyBkYSBwcmVycm9nYXRpdmFzIGNvbnN0aXR1Y2lvbmFpcyBhcGxpY2FkYXMgYW8gcul1IGVtIHBy8yBkYSBpbXB1bmlkYWRlIGZhdm9yZWNlbmRvIGFzIGdyYW5kZXMgQmFuY2EkLiBGYXRvIHNlbWVsaGFudGUgb2NvcnJlIG5vIGNhbXBvIGRvcyBkaXJlaXRvcyBodW1hbm9zLg==

  11. Jorge Alberto disse:

    TmEgbWFpb3JpYSBkYXMgdmV6ZXMsICJnYXJhbnRpc21vIiDpIHVtIGV1ZmVtaXNtbyBwYXJhIG8gcXVlIG5hIHBy4XRpY2Egc2lnbmlmaWNhIHByb3Rl5+NvIGFvcyBhc3NhbHRhbnRlcyBkZSBjb2ZyZXMgcPpibGljb3MuIE8gImdhcmFudGlzdGFzIiBHaWxtYXIgTWVuZGVzLCBEaWFzIFRvZmZvbGksIFJpY2FyZG8gTGV3YW5kb3dza2kgZSBNYXJjbyBBdXLpbGlvIGNvbXBhY3R1YW0gZXhwbGljaXRhbWVudGUgY29tIG9zIGNyaW1pbm9zb3MgcXVlIHJvdWJhbSBvIGRpbmhlaXJvIGRvIHBvdm8u

  12. SPA CURITIBA disse:

    R2lsbWFyIG1haXMgdW1hIHZleiDpIGRlc21vcmFsaXphZG8gY29tIGx1dmEgZGUgcGVsaWNhICAuIEVsZSBhaW5kYSBu428gc2UgZGV1IGNvbnRhIHF1ZSBvIEJyYXNpbCBu428gdG9sZXJhIG1haXMgZXNzZXMgbWFnaXN0cmFkb3MgZGUgcG9ydGEgZGUgY2FkZWlhIC4gQSBnZXJh5+NvIEZIQyAoZSBzZXVzIGFw6m5kaWNlcykgY29tZedhIGEgc2UgZGVzcGVkaXIgZGEgdmlkYSBw+mJsaWNhICwgZSBkYSBmb3JtYSBtYWlzIG1lZO1vY3JlLg==

  13. Fábio Camilo Reis disse:

    RXN0cmFuaG8sIG9rIHF1ZSBvIEJhcnJvc28gdGVtIHJheuNvIHNvYnJlIG8gY2FzbyBkYSBjb25kdefjbyBjb2VyY2l0aXZhLCBtYXMgZWxlIGZhbGFyIGVtIGF0aXZpc21vIGRvIFNURiDpIGRlIHVtIGNpbmlzbW8g4CB0b2RhIHByb3ZhLCBlbGUgcXVlIGp1bGdhIGVtIHBlZGlkbyBkZSBoYWJlYXMgY29ycHVzIGRlIHVtIG3pZGljbyBwb3IgcHLhdGljYSBkZSBhYm9ydG8gZSBkZSBs4SBzb2x0YSB1bWEgZGVjaXPjbyBxdWUgYXTpIG8gdGVyY2Vpcm8gbepzIOkgcGVybWl0aWRvIG8gYWJvcnRvPyBTVEYgbWFsdWNvLiBPIGF0aXZpc21vIGRlIExld2FuZG93c2sgcXVlIGFjaGEgcXVlIHBvZGUgcmVpbnRlcnByZXRhciBhIGNvbnN0aXR1aefjbyBlIGRlc21lbWJyYXIgdW0gYXJ0aWdvIGRlbGEsIG5vIGZhbW9zbyBjYXNvIGRhIERpbG1hLCBlIG8gQmFycm9zbyBxdWUgYXV0b3JpemEgaW52ZXN0aWdh5+NvIGUgcXVlYnJhIGRlIHNpZ2lsbyBkbyBwcmVzaWRlbnRlIHBvciBhY29udGVjaW1lbnRvcyBhbnRlcmlvcmVzIGFvIG1hbmRhdG8sIHRvZG8gbXVuZG8gcGVyZGV1IG8ganXtem8sIG1hcyBwYXJ0ZSBkYSBpbXByZW5zYSBlc3ThIHJlbGV2YW5kbyBhIHNpdHVh5+NvIGRlcGVuZGVuZG8gZG8gY2Fzbywgc2Ug6SBHaWxtYXIgZGVzY2UgbyBwb3JyZXRlLCBCYXJyb3NvLCB0cmF0YWRvIGNvbW8gaGVy82kgZGEgcOF0cmlhLg==

  14. Sergio Cihgral disse:

    UXVhbmRvICBhIGxpc3VyYSBkZSBtZW1icm9zIGRvIFNURiDpIG1hbmNoYWRhLCBlbnTjbyBo4SBkZSBzZSBlc3BlcmFyIHF1ZSB0YWlzIGx1dGVtIHBlbG8gImdhcmFudGlzbW8iIC0g82J2aW8uDQpRdWFuZG8gYSBsaXN1cmEgZGUgbWVtYnJvcyBkbyBDb25ncmVzc28g6SBtYW5jaGFkYSwgZW50428sIGjhIGRlIHNlIGVzcGVyYXIgcXVlIHRhaXMgbHV0ZW0gcGVsbyAiZ2FyYW50aXNtbyIgLSDzYnZpby4NCiJHYXJhbnRpc21vIiwgbmVzdGUgY2Fzbywg6SB1bSBldWZlbWlzbW8gZG8gdGVybW8gaW1wdW5pZGFkZS4=

  15. zóio disse:

    U2FiZS1zZSBs4SBwb3IgcXVhaXMgaW50ZXJlc3NlcyAocHJvdmF2ZWxtZW50ZSBuYWRhIG5vYnJlcyBvdSBob25lc3RvcyksIG1hcyB2aXJhLWUtbWV4ZSBvIFNURiBk4SB1bWEgImludGVycHJldGFkYSIgbmEgQ29uc3RpdHVp5+NvIChxdWUgauEgdGVtIHN1YXMgZmFsaGFzIHRiKSwgZSBkZSByb2TjbywgbGl2cmEgYSBjYXJhIGRlIG11aXRvIHBhdGlmZSBuZXNzZSBwYe1zIQ==

  16. Marcia Torres disse:

    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

  17. Fernando Costa da Silva disse:

    Q0hVUEEgQkVJx09MQSAhISEh

  18. Grandes lábios disse:

    QSBiaWJhIGJlaed1ZGEgZGV2ZSBlc3RhciBiZWdlIGRlIPNkaW8gZG8gQmFycm9zby4=