“Casuísmo do STF preocupa todo o povo brasileiro”, diz procurador da Lava Jato

O procurador Diogo Castor de Mattos, da força-tarefa da Lava Jato em Curitiba, disse à Jovem Pan que viu “com simpatia” a declaração de Cármen Lúcia de que, depois da condenação de Lula pelo TRF-4, mudar o entendimento sobre prisão após condenação em segunda instância seria apequenar o STF.

“O Judiciário tem o papel de ver o Direito de forma definitiva. O Supremo se reuniu duas vezes em 2016 para analisar essa questão. Em ambas as vezes, decidiu no sentido de permitir a execução provisória da pena. No meu ver, é o entendimento mais razoável e é a interpretação mais adequada no sentido do nosso processo penal. Então eu vejo com simpatia e razoabilidade esse entendimento da ministra.

Mas é claro que preocupa muito, não só a Lava Jato, mas eu acho que todo o povo brasileiro, esse casuísmo que tem sido muitas vezes demonstrado em algumas situações em que a jurisprudência acaba sendo moldada conforme a cara do freguês, ou a cara do réu. Então esperamos que o entendimento possa ser mantido.”

E mais:

“A sociedade precisa de segurança jurídica para poder viver tranquilamente e ter um mínimo de previsibilidade em relação às decisões judiciais que muitas vezes [a segurança e a previsibilidade] não são vistas no STF, que é um tribunal predominantemente político, de indicações políticas.”

Ministro Marco Aurélio sobre decisão do STF: "A guinada não inspira confiança. Ao contrário, gera o descrédito, sendo a História impiedosa." Leia aqui

Deixe seu comentário

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site; a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem;
Tempo de publicação: 4 minutos

200

  1. DESENHANDO! disse:

    T3MgVmVsaG9zIENvcm9u6WlzIGRhIFBvbGl0aWNhIGUgIGRvIEp1ZGljaeFyaW8sIGFpbmRhIG7jbyBlbnRlbmRlcmFtIG8gcmVjYWRvIGRhcyBydWFzLiBPIHBvdm8gZW0gYWx0byBlIGJvbSBzb20gZGlzc2U6IENIRUdBISBO428gcXVlcmVtb3MgbWFpcyBlc3NlIHNpc3RlbWEgcXVlIGHtIGVzdOEuIE9zIFBhcnRpZG9zIG7jbyBlbnRlbmRlcmFtIG5hZGEgcXVhbmRvIG8gUFQsIFBNREIgZSBQU0RCLCBlbnRyZSBvdXRyb3MgcGVxdWVub3MsIHByb3RlZ2VyYW0gc2V1cyBjb3JydXB0b3MgY29tIHVuaGFzIGUgZGVudGVzLiAgIFBhcmEgbyBwb3ZvIGZpY291IGNsYXJvIGEgZGlmZXJlbudhIGRlICJjYXN0YXMiICBxdWUgZXhpc3RlbSAgbmEgcG9s7XRpY2EgYnJhc2lsZWlyYS4gUGFyYSBhIGNsYXNzZSBwb2ztdGljYSBUVURPIGUgcGFyYSBvIHBvdm8gTUlHQUxIQVMuIA0KVG9kb3Mgc29tb3MgaWd1YWlzIHBlcmFudGUgYSBsZWkuICBxdWVyIHF1ZWlyYW0gb3UgbuNvICBvcyBDb3JvbulpcyBkYSBQb2xpdGljYSBlIGRvIEp1ZGljaeFyaW8u

Ler comentários
  1. juca disse:

    RXNwZXJhbW9zIHRvZG9zIHF1ZSBzZSBjb25maXJtZSBlc3RlIGludXNpdGFkbyBlbnRlbmRpbWVudG8gZGEgTWluaXN0cmEgQ+FybWVtIEz6Y2lhLCByZWNvbmhlY2lkYSBjb21vIHVtYSBhZG9yYWRvcmEgZG8gTHVsYS4gQXTpIGJlbSBwb3VjbyB0ZW1wbyBlbGEgZGVpeG91IGNsYXJvIHF1ZSBzZSB1bSBwZWRpZG8gZGUgSEMgY2Htc3NlIGVtIHNldSBjb2xvIGVsYSBu428gdGl0dWJlYXJpYSBlLCBkZSBwcm9udG8sIGFzc2luYXJpYSBlIHBlbG8gcXVlIHRpcmFtb3MgZGUgY29uY2x1c+NvIGRlIHNldXMgYXRvcywgZWxhIG8gZmFyaWEgcHJhemVyb3NhbWVudGUu

  2. Agente86 disse:

    Lg0KU1RGIMkgVU1BIFFVQURSSUxIQSEhISEhDQou

  3. Francisco disse:

    TyBTVEYgbuNvIOkgbWFpcyBTdXByZW1vIFRyaWJ1bmFsIEZlZGVyYWwuIEF0dWFsbWVudGUgZGVtb25zdHJhIHNlciBTdXByZW1vIFRyaWJ1bmFsIGRvIEZ1bGFuby4gRGUgYWNvcmRvIGNvbSBvICJmdWxhbm8iLCBlbGUgZGVjaWRlLiBUcmlzdGUgcmVhbGlkYWRlIQ==

  4. Luiz disse:

    RGlzc2UgdHVkbywgc3IuIFByb2N1cmFkb3IgRGlvZ28gQ2FzdG9yIE1hdHRvcw0KRSBhY3Jlc2NlbnRvOiBhbHRlcmFyIGFnb3JhIOkgY2Fzde1zbW8gcHVyby4=

  5. EDMAR disse:

    QlJBVk8gQ0FSTUVNIExVQ0lBISEhIFNFUklBIFBVUk8gQ0FTVUlTTU8hIFVNIFRBUEEgTkEgQ0FSQSBET1MgQlJBU0lMRUlST1MgUVVFIFRFTSBWRVJHT05IQSBOQSBDQVJBISBVTSBFU0NSQUNIRSEgSk9DQVIgTk8gRk9TU08gTyBRVUUgU09CUk9VIERPIFNURiBDT01PIElOU1RJVFVJx0FPIQ==

  6. Leandro disse:

    TXVkYXIgYWdvcmEgLi5uZXN0ZSBtb21lbnRvLi4uc2VyaWEgZGVzbW9yYWxpemHn428gaW50ZXJuYWNpb25hbC4=

  7. José disse:

    TuNvIHNlIGFuaW1lIHByb2N1cmFkb3IsIHBhcmEgb3MgZmFtb3NvcyB0ZW0gaOFiZWFzIGNvcnB1cy4=

  8. Conrado disse:

    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

  9. Lili disse:

    UHJvY3VyYWRvciBEaW9nbyBDYXN0b3IgdGVtIHJheuNvLg==

  10. Getulio disse:

    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

  11. Fabio disse:

    SnVzdGFtZW50ZSBwZWxvcyBtaW5pc3Ryb3Mgc2VyZW0gaW5kaWNhZG9zIHBvbO10aWNvcywgbuNvIGThIHByYSBlc3BlcmFyIG11aXRvIGRlc3NhIGdlbnRlLg==

  12. Renato disse:

    UGFyYWLpbnMgbWluaXN0cmEgUHJlc2lkZW50ZSBkbyBTVEYgQ2FybWVuIEz6Y2lhLCBvcyBCcmFzaWxlaXJvcyBlc3TjbyAiT3JndWxob3NvcyIgZGUgdOotbGEgY29tbyBsZWdpdGltYSByZXByZXNlbnRhbnRlLg==

  13. VTNC disse:

    UGFyYSBtaW0sIGEgbWVsaG9yIGp1c3Rp52Eg6SBhIHBlbmEgZGUgbW9ydGUh

  14. samir disse:

    aW1lZGlhdG8gZmltIGRhcyBpbmRpY2Hn9WVzIHBvbO10aWNhcyEhISBwYXJhIGNvbWXnbyBkZSByZWZvcm1hIGRlc3RhIGNhaXhhIHByZXRhIHF1ZSDpIG8gc3RmLi4uc2Vy4SBxdWUgYSBtaW5pc3RyYSBwYXNzb3UgYSBib2xhIHBhcmEgbyBhbGV4YW5kcmUgZGUgbW9yYWlzIHF1ZSBzZXLhIG8gcHJlc2lkZW50ZSBkbyBzdXByZW1vIGVtIHNldGVtYnJvPz8/Li4uZXN0YW1vcyBkZSBvbGhvISEhIS4uLg==

    1. bWUgZGVzY3VscGVtIGV1IHF1ZXJpYSBkaXplciBxdWUgZW0gc2V0ZW1icm8gbyB0b2Zmb2xpIGly4SBzdWJzdGl0dWlyIGEgbWluaXN0cmEgY2FybWVuIGx1Y2lhIG7jbyBvIGFsZXhhbmRyZSBkZSBtb3JhaXMgY29tbyBlc2NyZXZpIHBvciBlbmdhbm8sc2UgYmVtIHF1ZSBk4SBubyBtZXNtbyBxdWFzZSB0b2RvcyBlc3TjbyBlbnJvbGFkb3MgY29tIG9zIHBvbO10aWNvcyBjb3JydXB0b3MuLi4=

  15. Bolsonaro disse:

    QSBtaW5pc3RyYSBDYXJtZW0gZXN04SBjZXJ07XNzaW1hLiBBIGp1c3Rp52EgbuNvIHBvZGUgc2UgcGF1dGFyIHBlbGEgY2FyYSBkbyBhY3VzYWRvIHBhcmEgZGFyIG91IG7jbyBzZW50ZW7nYXMgY29uZGVuYXTzcmlhcy4gTyBCcmFzaWwgYWNpbWEgZGUgdG9kb3MgZSBEZXVzIGFjaW1hIGRlIFR1ZG8u

  16. Cidadão disse:

    TyBxdWUgbuNvIGVudGVuZG8g6SBjb21vIHVtIG1pbmlzdHJvIGRvIFNURiBwb2RlIHNlIHJlYmVsYXIgY29udHJhIGEgZGVjaXPjbyBkbyBjb2xlZ2lhZG8gZGEgU3VwcmVtYSBDb3J0ZSBlIG7jbyBzZXIgcHVuaWRvISEhDQpDb21vIHBvZGUgdW0gbWluaXN0cm8gcGFydGlk4XJpbyhQVG9mZm9saSkgcGVkaXIgdmlzdGFzIOAgcGVyZGVyIGRlIHZpc3RhIGltcHVuZW1lbnRlISEh

  17. Adriano disse:

    RW5xdWFudG8gb3MgcGlsYW50cmFzIEdpbG1hciBNZW5kZXMsIERpYXMgVG9mZm9saSBlIE1hcmNvIEF1culsaW8gTWVsbG8gaW50ZWdyYXJlbSBvIFNURiwgb3MgYmFuZGlkb3MgZXN0YXLjbyBjb20gc2V1cyBoYWJlYXMgY29ycHVzIGdhcmFudGlkb3MsIGFzc2ltIGNvbW8gb3MgaW5maW5k4XZlaXMgcGVkaWRvcyBkZSB2aXN0YXMgY29udGludWFy428gYSBwb3N0ZXJnYXIgc3VhcyBjb25kZW5h5/VlcyBpbmRlZmluaWRhbWVudGUuIFNURiDpIGEgdmVyZ29uaGEgZG8gQnJhc2lsLg0KI2x1bGFuYWNhZGVpYQ==

  18. tico disse:

    TyBTVEYgySBVTSBUUklCVU5BTCBQUkVET01JTkFOVEVNRU5URSBERSBORUdPQ0lBx9VFUyBQT0zNVElDQVMu

  19. Lupo disse:

    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

  20. Metamambulante disse:

    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

  21. Corte disse:

    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

  22. Carlos disse:

    ySBwcmVjaXNvIGxlbWJyYXIgcXVlIGx1bGFsYWRy428gZm9pIGNvbnZpZGFkbyBkZSBob25yYSBkZXNzYSBzZW5ob3JhIHBhcmEgc3VhIHBvc3NlLCBtZXNtbyBqYSBlc3RhbmRvIGluZGljaWFkbyBlIGFjdXNhZG8gZGUgaW51bWVyb3MgY3JpbWVzLiAgROEgcHJhIGNvbmZpYXI/

  23. Carlos disse:

    UGFyYWLpbnMgU2VuaG9yYSBNaW5pc3RyYS4NCkVtIHByaW1laXJvIGx1Z2FyIGx1bGEgbmEgY2FkZWlhLg==

  24. Beto disse:

    Pz8/IENhcm1lbSBM+mNpYSBkZXZlIGF1bWVudGFyIHN1YSBzZWd1cmFu52EgZSBKQU1BSVMgVklBSkFSIEVNIEpBVElOSE8sIHByYSBu428gc29mcmVyICAgIHVtICJhY2lkZW50ZSIgcXVlIGJlbmVmaWNpZSBMdWxsYWRy428hIQ==

  25. Edu disse:

    UXVlbSBwb2RlIG1haXMsIGRpZ2Etc2UgdGVtIG1haXMgJCQkJCwgY2hvcmEgbWVub3MuLi4gQ2hlZ2EgZGUgaW1wdW5pZGFkZSBwYXJhIGNyaW1lcyBkZSBjb2xhcmluaG8gYnJhbmNvIHJlbGFjaW9uYWRvcyBjb20gY29ycnVw5+NvISEh

  26. Patriota disse:

    UG9yIHF1ZSBvIGNyaW1lIG9yZ2FuaXphZG8gY3Jlc2NlIGEgb2xob3MgdmlzdG9zPyBDb20gYSBwYWxhdnJhIG8gU1RGLg==