Decisão de Toffoli contraria entendimento da Primeira Turma do STF

Em fevereiro do ano passado, a Primeira Turma do STF permitiu que o Ministério Público coletasse informações do Coaf para abertura de investigações sem prévia autorização judicial.

Votaram em favor da medida Alexandre de Moraes, Luiz Fux, Rosa Weber e Luís Roberto Barroso — apenas Marco Aurélio ficou vencido no julgamento.

Relator do caso, Moraes citou o julgamento de 2016 do plenário que permitiu à Receita obter dados bancários de contribuintes para fiscalizar eventual sonegação de tributos.

A Primeira Turma aplicou a decisão por analogia: se a Receita pode monitorar as transações (e guardar em sigilo os dados bancários), por que o MP não poderia usar as mesmas informações?

Lula livre e Moro suspeito: será assim no STF? Saiba mais

Comentários temporariamente fechados.

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site; a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem.

  1. DDAISY disse:

    Q29uc2lkZXJhbmRvIG9zIHZvdG9zIGRlIFRvZmZvbGksIENlbHNvIGRlIE1lbGxvLCBNYXJjbyBBdXLpbGlvLCBHTSBlIExld2FuZG92aXNraSwgaXNzbyBzaWduaWZpY2FyaWEgcXVlIHZhbW9zIGRlcGVuZGVyIGRlIEFsZXhhbmRyZSBkZSBNb3JhZXMgbWFudGVyIGEgY29lcupuY2lhIGUgbyB2b3RvIGFudGVyaW9yPyA=

Ler comentários
  1. CCARLOS disse:

    QWluZGEgbuNvIGNhaXUgYSBmaWNoYSBkZSBxdWUgYSBlc3F1ZXJkYSBkZWNsYXJvdSBndWVycmEgYWJlcnRhPyAKySBkZXZlciBkYXMgRkZBQSwgaW50ZXJ2aXIgaW1lZGlhdGFtZW50ZS4gT3UgcXVlcmVtIHVtYSBndWVycmEgY2l2aWw/

  2. PPaulo disse:

    U1VSVE9VIEUgQSBVTklDQSBFWFBMSUNBx0FPLCBBUyBDT05WRU7HT0VTIElOVEVSTkFDSU9OQUlTLCBPQ0RFLCBCQU5DTyBJTlRFUiBBTUVSSUNBTk8gRSBPVVRSQVMgREVURVJNSU5BLCBDT05UUk9MRSBGSU5BTkNFSVJPLCBFIFRFTU9TLCBFTlRBTyBWRU0gVU0gSlVJWiwgTU9OT0NSQVRJQ0FNRU5URSBDT05UUkFSSU8sIEFPIFFVRSBGT0kgSlVMRyA=

    1. RUxFIFBPREUgQ09OVFJBUklBUiBPVSBOQU8gUkVDT05IRUNFUiBVTSBKVUdBTUVOVE8gQU5URVJJT1IsIFBFTEEgUFJPUElBIENPUlRFLCBDT00gQ0lOQ08gVk9UT1MgQSBGQVZPUiBFIFVNIENPTlRSQSwgSVNTTywgRSBCQURFUk5BLCBDT1JSRSBPIFJJU0NPIERPIENJREFEQU8sIE5BTyBSRUNPTkhFQ0VSIE8gU1RGLC5JU1NPIEUgR1JBVkUuQ1JFREk=

  3. Elisabeth disse:

    QSBsYXZhIGphdG8gdmFpIHNlciBkZXN0cnXtZGEgYmVtIG5vIG1vbWVudG8gZW0gcXVlIGlhIGludmVzdGlnYXIgb3MgZXNjcml083Jpb3MgZGUgYWR2b2NhY2lhLiBQb3IgcXVlIHNlcuE/

  4. le disse:

    IEVucXVhbnRvIHVtIG1lbWJybyBkZSBvcmdhbml6YefjbyBjcmltaW5vc2EgaW5zdGFsYWRvIG5vICRURiwgYXBlbmFzICJVTSIsIGZob2RlIGNvbSBhIHZpZGEgZG9zIGJyYXNpbGVpcm9zLCBu83MgcHJlZmVyaW1vcyBhc3Npc3RpciBhbyBmdXRlYm9sLCBhcyBub3ZlbGFzIGRhIEdMT0JPTElYTy4gRGVwb2lzIG7jbyByZWNsYW1lbSBkYSA=

  5. Carlos disse:

    T2EgbWluaXN0cm9zIGRvIHN0ZiBz428gY29tbyBhbGZhaWF0ZXMuIFRlbSB1bWEgbGVpIHRhbGhhZGEgcGFyYSBjYWRhIGNyaW1pbm9zby4g

  6. Rosa disse:

    VG9mZm9saSBzaW1wbGVzbWVudGUgcHJvdGVnZW5kbyBvIGpvcm5hbGlzdGEgdmlnYXJpc3RhIG1lbnRpcm9zbyBHbGVlbi4gUXVlIFZlcmdvbmhhIHBhcmEgbyBTVEYu

    1. TyB0YWwgYXBlbmFzICJhanVkb3UiLiAgRSBmYXogcGFydGUgZG8gZ3JhbmRlIHBsYW5vIGRlc3NlcyBtYWzpZmljb3Mu

  7. JohnGalt disse:

    RWxlIHBvZGUgdHVkbyBlc3ThIGFjaW1hIGRlIHF1YWxxdWVyIGVudGVuZGltZW50byBqdXLtZGljbyBvdSBsZWksIGVsZSBqdWxnYSBlIGxlZ2lzbGEgc2VndW5kbyBzdWEgcHLzcHJpYSBvcGluaeNvLCBvIHF1ZSBwYXJlY2UgaXNzbyBwcmEgdm9j6nM/IA==

  8. Luiz disse:

    TuNvIHNlaSBxdWFpcyBwYWxhdnJhcyB1c2FyIHBhcmEgY29tZW50YXIgYXF1aSBxdWUgbuNvIHNlamFtIHNlbnPtdmVpcy5DYWRlIG8gZGljaW9u4XJpbz8=

    1. SG9qZSwgZXNwZWNpYWxtZW50ZSwgInNlbnPtdmVsIiBlIHNpbSA6ICBib2EgaWRlaWEgbWFyY2FyIG8gcXVlIG7jbyBwYXNzYSwgc2VtIGJsb3F1ZWFyIG8gcXVlIGVzY3JldmVtb3Mu

    2. QmFzdGFyaWEgcXVlIG8gc2l0ZSBu428gc3VtaXNzZSBjb20gYSBwb3N0YWdlbSwgZSBpbmRpY2Fzc2VtIHF1YWlzIHBhbGF2cmFzIGRvIHBvc3Qgc+NvICJzZW5z7XZlaXMiLCBhc3NpbSBwb2Rlcu1hbW9zIGFsdGVyYXIgYXMgcGFsYXZyYXMgZSByZXBvc3Rhci4uLiBBIHBhcnRlIHTpY25pY2EgRE8gc2l0ZSDpIHVtYSBt

  9. le disse:

    VG9mZm9saSBwcmVjaXNhIHNlciBiYXJyYWRvLCBhc3NpbSBjb21vIEdpbGFtciBNZW5kZXMuIFPjbyBj+m1wbGljZXMgZG9zICBjbHViZXMgZG9zIGNvci1ydXAtdG9zIFBUIHggUFNEQi4=

  10. Xavier disse:

    SuEgcGFzc291IGRhIGhvcmEgZGVzc2UgY2lkYWTjbyBzZXIgZGVtaXRpZG8hISE=

  11. Schio disse:

    SW52ZXN0ZSBubyBCcmFzaWwsIHZhaSwgYXJyaXNjYSBlIGRlcG9pcyBu428gbGFtZW50ZSEgU/MgaW52ZXN0ZSBhcXVpIHZlbSBwYXJhIHN1Z2FyIGUgZmF6IGFjZXJ0b3MgYW50ZXMgcGFyYSBu428gc2UgbGFzY2FyIG5hIG3jbyBkZSB1bSBpbnRvY+F2ZWwgcXVhbHF1ZXIu

  12. Chiganer disse:

    RXUgbGVtYnJvIHF1ZSBvIGFudGFnb25pc3RhIGRpc3NlLCBhcXVpIG5vcyBwb3N0cywgcXVlIGEgcmVjZWl0YSBwb2RlcmlhLCBhIHBhcnRpciBkYXF1ZWxlIG1vbWVudG8sIHF1ZWJyYXIgc2lnaWxvIGJhbmPhcmlvLg==

  13. Edu_Brasil disse:

    TXVpdGFzIGRlY2lz9WVzIGNvbmZsaXRhbnRlcy4gUXVhbCBvIG1vdGl2bz8gbWluaXN0cm9zICJnYXJhbnRpc3RhcyIgdmVyc3VzIG1pbmlzdHJvcyAibGVnYWxpc3RhcyI/

    1. TuEuICDJIE9yQ3JpbSBtZXNtby4gIEVtIGVzdGFkbyBwdXJvLiAgT1JDUklNLCBlIGRlIHbhcmlvcyBtb2RlbG9zLiAgQSBrb2lzYSDpICJvcmdhbml6YWRhIi4=

  14. brazil-Livre disse:

    ZXNzZSBjYWJvY28gY29udHJhcmlhIHR1ZG8gcXVlIOkgZG8gYmVtLi4gySBwZXRpc3RhLi4uIHZhaSBmYXplciB0dWRvIGUgbWFpcyB1bSBwb3VjbyBwcmEgZW1iYXJhbGhhciBhIGp1c3Rp52EsIGNvbW8gZmF6IG8gWmFuaW4uLi4g8SBzZXJ2ZSBwcmEgbmFkYS4uLiBvIHN0ZiBwcmVjaXNhIHNlciBleHRpbnRv

  15. Elaine disse:

    QWxndeltIGRldmVyaWEgcGVkaXIgdW1hIEF2YWxpYefjbyBQc2lxdWnhdHJpY2EgZGVzc2UgTWluaXN0cm8uIErhIGZvaSByZWxhdGFkbyBwb3Igc2V1cyBwYXJjZWlyb3MgcXVlIGVsZSBhYnVzYSBkZSDhbGNvb2wuIFF1ZW0gcG9kZSBhZmlybWFyIHF1ZSBlbGUgZXN04SBnb3phbmRvIGRlIHN1YSBwbGVuYSBzYW5pZGFkZSBtZW50YWw/IA==

  16. Carlos disse:

    T3MgbWluaXN0cm9zIGRvIHN0ZiBwb2RlbSBzZXIgY29tcGFyYWRvcyBhIGFsZmFpYXRlcy4gUGFyYSBjYWRhIGNyaW1pbm9zbyB1bWEgbGVpIHNvYiBtZWRpZGEu

  17. Luís disse:

    U+NvIHNldGUgdm90b3Mgbm8gcGxlbuFyaW8gcGFyYSBkZXJydWJhciBhIG1hcmN1dGFpYSBkbyBUb2Zmb2xpLg==

  18. Sandra disse:

    T25kZSBlc3TjbyBvcyBvdXRyb3MgTWluaXN0cm9zIGRvIFN1cHJlbW8gcXVlIGRlaXhhbSBlc3NlIHN1cnRhZG8gZGVjaWRpbmRvIGUgZGVzdHJ1aW5kbyBvIHBh7XM/

  19. Alexandre disse:

    RXNzYSBkZWNpc+NvIGNvbnRyYXJpYSB0b2RhIGp1cmlzcHJ1ZOpuY2lhIGUgbPNnaWNhIGp1cu1kaWNhLiA=

    1. U2VtIHRhbXBvdWNvIG5vcyBlc3F1ZWNlcm1vcyBkZSBxdWUgbyBCcmFzaWwgUEFTU0EgQSBTRVIgdW0gYmVsbyBwYXJh7XNvIHBhcmEgbyBURVJST1JJU01PIGludGVybmFjaW9uYWwuICBO428gbm9zIGJhc3Rhc3NlIGEgdmFyaWVkYWRlIGRhIGZhdW5hIGJhbmQg4CBzb2x0YSBlIHBvciB0b2RhIHBhcnRlIGFxdWku

    2. QWZyb250YW5kbyBvcyBBY29yZG9zIEludGVybmFjaW9uYWlzIG7jbyBoYXZlcuEgTkVH00NJT1MgY29tIG8gQnJhc2lsLiAgQmVtLCBlIGFnb3JhIHVtYSBzaW5nZWxhIHBlcmd1bnRpbmhhIDogIHBvciBxdWUgbyBQUiBlc3ThIGZpbmdpbmRvIHF1ZSBkZSBuYWRhIHNhYmUgPyAgTmVtIFVNQSBwYWxhdnJhIC4uLg==

    3. RSBhbnVsYSBxdWFscXVlciBib20gdHJhYmFsaG8gcXVlIEVkdWFyZG8gQiBwb3NzYSB2aXIgYSBURU5UQVIgZW0gV2FzaGluZ3RvbiA6ICBhIGNhbmV0YSBkZXNzZSBzdWplaXRvIHRhIC1yYSAtZG8gZGUgbm9tZSB66SBub3MgdGlyb3UgZG8gTXVuZG8gY2l2aWxpemFkby4gIE7jbyBmYXJlbW9zIG5lZ/NjaW9zIGNvbSBOSU5HVclNLg==

  20. Juscelino disse:

    VW0gc3VqZWl0byBxdWUgbuNvIHRlbSBjb21wZXTqbmNpYSBwYXJhIHBhc3NhciBlbSBjb25jdXJzbyBwYXJhIGp1aXogduEgdGVyIGVudGVuZGltZW50byBkYSBwcmltZWlyYSB0dXJtYSBkbyBTVEY/ICA=

  21. M disse:

    U2VyaWEgcG9ycXVlIHRhbHZleiB0aXZlc3NlIHZhemFkbyBubyBjYXNvIFF1ZWly83ogPw==

  22. KiKa disse:

    QXNzdXN0YWRvci4uLi4gYW50ZXMgbm8gQnJhc2lsIHR1ZG8gYWNhYmF2YSBlbSBQSVpaQSwgYWdvcmEgdHVkbyBhY2FiYSBubyBTVEYgPz8/