“Ninguém é obrigado a cumprir decisão ilegal”

O desembargador Guilherme Nucci, do TJ de São Paulo, disse que Sergio Moro “agiu corretamente” ao impedir a soltura de Lula.

O Estadão perguntou-lhe:

“Ao se negar a expedir o alvará, Moro agiu segundo o princípio de que não é obrigado a obedecer a ordem manifestamente ilegal?”

Ele respondeu:

“Correto. Como regra, ninguém é obrigado a cumprir decisão ilegal de qualquer autoridade. Logo, Moro agiu corretamente ao dizer que o plantonista não é competente para o caso. Aliás, devia ter dito que nem ele é. Essa decisão foi uma ‘barbaridade jurídica’, que empobrece a imagem do Judiciário.”

E mais:

“A decisão de prisão partiu da Turma do TRF-4. Então, questionamentos devem seguir para o STJ e, depois, para o STF. Plantonista não pode mudar decisão de colegiado. Jamais.”

Deixe seu comentário

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site; a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem;
Tempo de publicação: 4 minutos

200

  1. Marius disse:

    RXN04SBleHBs7WNpdG8sIHAvIHF1ZW0gcXVpc2VyIHZlci4NCk8gcXVlIGFjb250ZWNldSBlbnRyZSBzZXh0YS1mZWlyYSAoNi83KSBlIG9udGVtLCBkb21pbmdvICg4LzcpLCBmb2kgdW0gYXRlbnRhZG8g4HMgbGVpcyBlIOAgZGVtb2NyYWNpYSwgcGxhbmVqYWRvIHBvciBtaWxpdGFudGVzIGRlIHVtIHBhcnRpZG8gcG9s7XRpY28gYXR1YW5kbyAicG9yIGZvcmEgZSBwb3IgZGVudHJvIiBkYSBKdXN0aedhIEZlZGVyYWwsIHVtYSBkYXMgbWFpcyBpbXBvcnRhbnRlcyBpbnN0aXR1aef1ZXMgZG8gRXN0YWRvLiBHcmF2ZSEh

Ler comentários
  1. Cirval disse:

    QSBjYWRhIHJlc3Bvc3RhIGRlIHBlc3NvYXMgY2F0ZWdvcml6YWRhcyBuYSDhcmVhIGp1cu1kaWNhIGZpY2EgbWFpcyBjbGFyYSBhIGF0aXR1ZGUgaWxlZ2FsIGUgcGFydGlk4XJpYSBkbyBwbGFudG9uaXN0YSBGYXYobylyZXRvLiBFbGUgZmV6IGEgZGVmZXNhIGFkbWluaXN0cmF0aXZhIGRvIHByZXNpZGnhcmlvIEx1bGEgZSBkZXZlIHNlciBwdW5pZG8gcG9yIGlzc28uIE8gcGlvciBkYSBoaXN083JpYSDpIHF1ZSBlbGUgZGVtb3JvdSBkdWFzIG5vaXRlcyBwYXJhIHByb2R1emlyIGVzc2EgbGFtZW504XZlbCBkZWNpc+NvLg==

  2. Bobina disse:

    UHJlbmRhbSBvIGNhcmNlcmVpcm8gZW50428hIE1vcm8gbuNvIGltcGVkaXUgbmFkaW5oYSBlIG5lbSBlc3RhdmEgbOEgcGFyYSBldml0YXIgYSBzb2x0dXJhIGRvIGNvbmRlbmFkby4gRGVzZGUgcXVhbmRvIHJlc3BvbmRlciBhIHBlcmd1bnRhIGRvIGNvbGVnYSwgZXN0YW5kbyBlbSBm6XJpYXMsIOkgZmFsdGEgZGlzY2lwbGluYXI/

  3. Bolsonaro disse:

    RmFsdGEgYSBwdW5p5+NvIGFvIGp1aXogcGV0cmFsaGEh

  4. Nelson disse:

    RmF2ZXRyYXI6IHZlcmJvIGludHJhbnNpdOF2ZWw6IHRlbnRhciwgc2VtIHN1Y2Vzc28sIGFsdGVyYXIgZGVjaXPjbyBqdWRpY2lhbCBkZSDTcmfjbyBDb2xlZ2lhZG8gcGFyYSBmYXZvcmVjZXIgY29uZGVuYWRv

  5. JANA disse:

    Uk9HyVJJTyBGQVZSRVRPIE5BIENBREVJQSBKwS4gUEVSSUdPIEVYVFJFTU8gUEFSQSBBIFNFR1VSQU7HQSBKVVJJRElDQSBFIFBBWiBTT0NJQUwgTk8gQlJBU0lMLiBFIFBFTE8gTUVTTU8gTU9USVZPOiBQUklTQU8gUFJFVkVOVElWQSBERSBUT0ZPTEkgKEUgR0lMTUFSIEUgTEVXQU5ET1NLSSkgRU5RVUFOVE8gySBURU1QTy4gQU1BTkhBIFFVQU5ETyBPUyAzIElOU1RBTEFSRU0gREUgVkVaIEEgRElUQURVUkEgSlVESUNJwVJJQSwgU0VSwSBUQVJERSBERU1BSVMuLg==

  6. Rosa disse:

    RXNzZSBkZXNlbWJhcmdhZG9yIGRlIHRpdmVyIHZlcmdvbmhhIG5hIGNhcmEgZGEgc3VtaXIgZG8gQnJhc2lsLiBBcXVpIGEgY2FycmVpcmEgZGVsZSBhanVkYWRhIHBlbGEgRGlsbWEgZm9pIHBybyBsaXhvLiBRdWVtIHZhaSBhY3JlZGl0YXIgYWdvcmEgIG5lc3NhIGNyaWF0dXJhPyBGb3JhIFJvZ+lyaW8gRmF2cmV0byE=

  7. wanderlei disse:

    TyB0YWwgZGVzZW1iYXJnYWRvciDpIG1haXMgdW0gYWxvcHJhZG8gZG8gbHVsYXLhcGlvLg==

  8. Tatiana disse:

    TuNvIHNlIGFwbGljYSBhIFRvZmZvbGksIExld2FuZG93c2tpLCBHaWxtYXIgZSBNYXJjbyBBdXLpbGlvLCBxdWUgZmF6ZW0gbyBxdWUgYmVtIGVudGVuZGVtLiBBIExlaSBu428gc2UgYXBsaWNhIGFvIHF1YXJ0ZXRvIGRhcyB0cmV2YXMu

  9. Ricardo disse:

    RXNzZSBkZXNlbWJhcmdhZG9yIEZhdnJldG8sIHBsYW50b25pc3RhIG5vbWVhZG8gcGVsYSBwcmVzaWRhbnRhICwgdGVtIHF1ZSBzZXIgZGV2aWRhbWVudGUgcHVuaWRvIGUgZXhwdXJnYWRvIGRlIHF1YWxxdWVyIGNhcmdvIGNvbSByZXNwb25zYWJpbGlkYWRlIHF1ZSBpbXBhY3RhIG8gUGHtcy4=

  10. Ricardo disse:

    UGVyYe0sIHBhcmEgZXNxdWVyZGlzdGEgb3MgcXVlIGN1bXByZW0gYSBsZWkgc+NvIG1hdXMNCm9zIHF1ZSBu428gY3VtcHJlbSBhIGxlaSBz428gYm9ucywgcXVhbHF1ZXIgZGlhIHbjbw0KcHJlY2lzYXIgZGEganVzdGnnYSwgZXN0YW5kbyBjb20gc2V1cyBkaXJlaXRvcyBhbWVh52Fkb3MsIA0KduNvIHF1ZXJlciBib25zIGp17XplcyBwb3IgcXVlIG9zIG1hdXMsIGNvcnJ1cHRvcywgaWRlb2xvZ2ljYW1lbnRlDQpjb21wcm9tZXRpZG9zLCB2ZW5kZW0gc2VudGVu52EsIHPjbyBjYXBhemVzIGRlIGVzY29saGVyZW0gdW0gTHVsYS4=

  11. Eu disse:

    QSB1cmfqbmNpYSBjb20gZGVzZWphdmFtIGZhemVyIGEgc29sdHVyYSwgcXVlYnJhbmRvIHJlZ3JhcyAgY29tbyBhIG7jbyByZWFsaXph5+NvIGRvIGV4YW1lIGRlIGNvcnBvLCBub3MgbW9zdHJhIHF1ZSBq4SB0aW5oYW0gcmVjZWlvIGRlIHF1ZSBhbGd16W0gaW1wZWRpcmlhIG8gZXN0dXBybyBkYSBsZWkuICAgUXVhc2UgY2VydGV6YSBxdWUgaXJpYW0gbGV24S1sbyBwcmEgZm9yYSBkbyBwYe1zLCBjb21vIGFzaWxhZG8gcG9s7XRpY28gZmljYXJpYSBkYW5kbyBwaXRhY29zIG5vIHByb2Nlc3NvIGVsZWl0b3JhbC4=

  12. Cabedelo disse:

    RGV2b2x2YW0gbyBESVJDRVUgUEFSQSBBIFBSSVNBTywgRVNUQSBTT0xUTyBQQVJBIFRVTVVMVFVBUiAgQVRFIE9VVFVCUk8u

  13. Spock disse:

    TyBQVCBudW5jYSBkZWl4YSBkZSBzdXJwcmVlbmRlciwgcHJpbmNpcGFsbWVudGUgcG9yIHN1YSBpbmNvbVBlVOpuY2lhLiBPIHF1ZSB2428gZmF6ZXIgYWdvcmE/IEV4cGxvZGlyIGEgcGFyZWRlIGRhICJjZWxhIiBlIGxpYmVydGFyIEx1bGEgbmEgbWFycmE/

  14. Brasil disse:

    QWdpdSBjb3JyZXRhbWVudGUgbyBwYXJjaWFsIGVzc2UganVpemVjbyB2YWkgc2VyIHByb2Nlc3NhZG8gbm8gQ05KIGUgdmFpIHByYSBjYWRlaWEgZGVzY3VtcHJpciBvcmRlbSBqdWRpY2lhbCBkZSB1bWEgaW5zdOJuY2lhIHN1cGVyaW9yIG8gcXVlIGVzc2UganVpemVjbyBlc3ThIHBlbnNhbmRvICNTTW9yb25hY2FkZWlh

    1. VmFpIHNvbmhhbmRvLiBPIE1vcm8gZSBhIFBGIGZvcmFtIGNvZXJlbnRlcyBhbyBu428gY3VtcHJpcmVtIG9yZGVtIHTjbyB2ZXhhdG9yaWFtZW50ZSBpbGVnYWwuIEFpbmRhIGjhIGVzcGVyYW7nYSBwYXJhIGEgSnVzdGnnYSBCcmFzaWxlaXJhLCBhcGVzYXIgZGUgYWxndW5zICBwb3Vjb3MgYWluZGEgIG9jdXBhcmVtIGNhcmdvcyBwYXJhIG9zIHF1YWlzLCBvYnZpYW1lbnRlLCBu428gZXN0ZWphbSBwcmVwYXJhZG9zLg==

    2. QSB1cmfqbmNpYSBjb20gZGVzZWphdmFtIGZhemVyIGEgc29sdHVyYSwgcXVlYnJhbmRvIHJlZ3JhcyAgY29tbyBhIG7jbyByZWFsaXph5+NvIGRvIGV4YW1lIGRlIGNvcnBvLCBub3MgbW9zdHJhIHF1ZSBq4SB0aW5oYW0gcmVjZWlvIGRlIHF1ZSBhbGd16W0gaW1wZWRpcmlhIG8gZXN0dXBybyBkYSBsZWkuICAgUXVhc2UgY2VydGV6YSBxdWUgaXJpYW0gbGV24S1sbyBwcmEgZm9yYSBkbyBwYe1zLCBjb21vIGFzaWxhZG8gcG9s7XRpY28gZmljYXJpYSBkYW5kbyBwaXRhY29zIG5vIHByb2Nlc3NvIGVsZWl0b3JhbC4=