O argumento irrespondível de Celso de Mello

Gilmar Mendes “tentou um atalho” para soltar Lula, segundo Merval Pereira.

E fracassou.

“O voto decisivo foi do ministro Celso de Mello, que usou um argumento irrespondível: para ele, é possível ao juiz usar seu ‘poder geral de cautela toda vez que se cuidar de algo favorável ao acusado’, mas, nesse caso, há ‘três títulos condenatórios emanados [contra Lula]’.

O decano se referia às condenações na primeira instância, em Curitiba, no TRF-4 em Porto Alegre e no STJ. Mesmo sendo contra a prisão em segunda instância, o ministro Celso de Mello não teria dúvidas sobre o caso de Lula, que já cumpriu o requisito que deve ser definido pelo plenário do STF: a prisão depois da condenação pelo STJ.”

Redução de pena no STJ é combustível para mais uma narrativa petista. CONFIRA

Comentários temporariamente fechados.

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site; a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem.

  1. Luis disse:

    RXNzZSBtaW5pc3RybyB2ZWxoYWNvLCBxdWVybyB2ZXIgc2UgdGVtIGNvcmFnZW0gZGUgc29sdGFyIG8gYmFuZGlkbyBkbyBMdWxhIGUgY29uZGVuYXIgbyBtaW5pc3RybyBT6XJnaW8gTW91cm8uIA==

Ler comentários
  1. Paulorobertomoura disse:

    QXJtYXJhbSBvIGNpcmNvIG9uZGUgbmEgcGxhdOlpYSBz8yBoYXZpYSBpbmRpY2lhZG9zIG5hIGxhdmEtamF0byBhZ3VhcmRhbmRvIGRlICBzZXVzIGluZGljYWRvcyBhbyBTVEYsZGVtb25zdHJh5+NvIGRlIGdyYXRpZONvLiA=

  2. Juscelino disse:

    TyBwcm9ibGVtYSDpIHF1ZSBhcmd1bWVudG9zIHPzbGlkb3MsIGJlbSBjb25zdHJ17WRvcyBlIGVtYmFzYWRvcyBkZSBuYWRhIHNlcnZlbSBxdWFuZG8gc2UgZXN04SBsaWRhbmRvIGNvbSBiYW5kaWRvcyBpbmVzY3J1cHVsb3Nvcy4g

  3. MARIA disse:

    RSBu428gdmFpIHVtIHBpdG8gYW8gR2lsbWFyIHBvciBpZ25vcmFyIG8gZW50ZW5kaW1lbnRvIGRvIHBy83ByaW8gU1RGPyBFbSBxdWFscXVlciBlbXByZXNhLCBmdW5jaW9u4XJpbyBxdWUgZXJyYSDpIGFkdmVydGlkbywgYWxpIGNhZGEgdW0gZmljYSBubyBzZXUgbXVuZGluaG8gcGFydGljdWxhci4=

  4. ORRORORRÍVEL()PQP() disse:

    TVVMSEVSQURBLCBFU1RPVSBUQVJBRE8gZSBNQUxVQ08gUEFSQSBDSFVQQVIgVU1BICgoKCgoKCgoKCgoKCgoKCgoKCgoKCgjQk8jQ0UjVEEjKSkpKSkpKSkpKSkpKSkpKSkpKSkpLiBRdWFudG8gTWFpcyBFVSBUUkVQTywgTWFpcyBFVSBERVNFSk8gKCgoRiBPIEQgRSBSKSkpIC4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4=

  5. Paulo disse:

    Q2FkZWlhIGrhIG5hIDJhIGluc3TibmNpYSBlIFBUIGZpbmFsLi4uIA==

  6. ORRORORRÍVEL()PQP() disse:

    TUVMTEFEw08gJiBNZWxsYWRpbmhvLCBvcyBUT0JBUyBkbyBTVEYgZG8gR0FNQsEgTUFNQURPICYgTUVMQURPIC4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4u

  7. Lili disse:

    UXVlIGhpc3TzcmlhIOkgZXNzYSBkZSBwcmlz428gc/MgZGVwb2lzIGRlIHNlbnRlbudhIG5vIFNUSj8=

    1. TWFzIGlzc28gcHJhIHF1ZW0gdGVtICQuIFByYSBxdWVtIG7jbyAgdGVtLCBwcmltZWlybyDpIGNhbmEgZSBkZXBvaXMganVsZ2FtZW50by4uLg==

    2. Qm9hIHBlcmd1bnRhLCBkYXF1aSBhIHBvdWNvIHPzIHNlcuEgY29uZGVuYWRvIHNlIHBhc3NhciBwZWxhIHNlbnRlbudhIGRvIGNhcGV0YS4=

  8. ISAYAS disse:

    U2UgZm9zc2UgcHJhIGNvbnZlbmNlciB1bSBob21lbSBob25yYWRvIHF1YWxxdWVyIGFyZ3VtZW50byByYXpv4XZlbCBzZXJ2aXJpYSwgbWFzIHRyYXRhbmRvLXNlIGRlIEdpbG1hciBNZW5kZXMsIG5lbSBT82NyYXRlcyAoTyBmaWzzc29mbykgY29uc2VndWlyaWEgZmF66i1sbyBkZXNpc3RpciBkZSBzdWFzIG1hbm9icmFzIGluc2FuYXMg

  9. Roberto disse:

    SW5mZWxpem1lbnRlIHRlbW9zIG5vIFNURiBqdWl6ZXMgY29tbyBHTSBlIFJMLiBJbmZlbGl6bWVudGUsIGUgYXTpIHF1YW5kbz8=

    1. SW5mZWxpem1lbnRlLCBvIGppcGUgY29tIG8gY2FibyBlIG8gc29sZGFkbyB2YWkgYWNhYmFyIGZhemVuZG8gdW0gY2l0eSB0b3VyIGVtIEJyYXPtbGlhLCBjb20gZXNjYWxhcyBubyBTVEYgZSBDb25ncmVzc28uLi4gcmVwaXRvLCBpbmZlbGl6bWVudGUuLi4=

  10. ROBERTO disse:

    UXVhbmRvIENlbHNvIGRlIE1lbGxvIHZvdG91IHBvciBjcmltaW5hbGl6YXIgYSBob21vZm9iaWEgdGl2ZW1vcyBhdGFxdWVzIHNlbSBjZXNzYXIgY29udHJhIG8gbWluaXN0cm8uIEFnb3JhIHF1YW5kbyB2b3RhIHByYSBtYW50ZXIgbHVsYSBwcmVzbyB2aXJhIO1kb2xvLiA=

    1. UGFyYSBtaW0sIGVsZSBhY2VydG91IG5vcyBkb2lzIGNhc29zLiA=

    2. TyBhdGFxdWUgbuNvIGZvaSBwZWxvIHZvdG8gZGUgbmluZ3XpbSwgbWFzIHNpbSBwZWxvIGZhdG8gZGUgbyBTVEYgZXN0YXIgYSBsZWdpc2xhciwgbyBxdWUg6SBhdHJpYnVp5+NvIGRvIGNvbmdyZXNzbyBuYWNpb25hbCwgbnVtYSBkZW1vY3JhY2lhIG8ganVkaWNp4XJpbyBu428gbGVnaXNsYSwgc/MgbyBjb25ncmVzc28=

  11. Jorge disse:

    QSBwZW5hIGFwbGljYWRhIGEgTHVsYSBwb3IgTW9ybyBkZSA4IGUgcG91Y29zIGFub3MsZGVwb2lzIGF1bWVudGFkYSBwZWxvIFRSRjQgcGFyYSAxMiBhbm9zLGNvbmZpcm1hcXVlTW9ybyBmb2kgbXVpdG8ganVzdG8gY29tIEx1bGEscG9pcyBvIFNUSiBkaW1pbnVpdSBwYXJhIGEgcGVuYSBkbyBNb3JvIGRlIDggYW5vcyzxIHRlbSBvIHEgcmVjbGFtYQ==

  12. Vanderlei disse:

    YXF1aSBu428gauEgdGluaGEgY2VydGV6YSwgbWFzIGEgbPNnaWNhLCBudW5jYSBvIGFjZWl0ZSBkYSBzb2x0dXJhIGRvIGVudONvIGNvbmRlbmFkbywgY29uZmlybWFkYSBlbSAzIGluc3TibmNpYXMsIGNlcnRlemEgZSBs82dpY2EgY29uZmlybWFkYSwgY29udGludWFy4SBwcmVzbyBhdOkgMS8zIGRlIGNvbmRlbmHn428sIGJhYmFjYQ==

  13. Antonio disse:

    UXVlcmVtIHJlc29sdmVyIG8gcHJvYmxlbWEgZGFzIHJlcGV0aef1ZXMgY3JpbWlub3NhcyBubyBCcmFzaWw/IGRldGVybWluZW0gcXVlIGRlc2RlIGNvbmRlbmFkbyBuYSAxqiBJTlNUQU5DSUEsIG8gYXBlbmFkbyBq4SB2YWkgcHJhICJjYW5hIi4gRmljYXJpYSB1bWEgbWFyYXZpbGhhISEh

    1. RW0gYWxndW5zIHBhaXNlcyBkbyAxIG11bmRvIOkgYXNzaW0=

  14. Marcos disse:

    ySBzdXJyZWFsIGF06SBjb2dpdGFyIGVtIHNvbHRhciB1bSBy6XUgcG9yIGNhdXNhIGRlIHVtYSBwcm92YSBxdWUg6SBhcGVuYXMgdW0gbWlsaXRhbnRlIGRpZ2l0YW5kbyBlbSB1bSBzaXRlLiBI4SBldmlk6m5jaWFzIGRlIHF1ZSBhcyBtZW5zYWdlbnMgZm9yYW0gYWR1bHRlcmFkYXMu

  15. Gonçalo disse:

    RXhhdGFtZW50ZS4gTHVsYSBmb2kgY29uZGVuYWRvIGVtIDNhIGluc3TibmNpYSBq4S4gR2FtZSBvdmVyLg==

  16. Ana disse:

    RXNzZSBwcm9qZXRvIGRlIGFidXNvIGRlIGF1dG9yaWRhZGUgbWUgZXNwYW50YS4uLi4u

  17. egidio disse:

    TuNvIOkgY2FzbyBkZSBoYWJlYXMgY29ycHVzLiBOZW0gZGV2ZXJpYSBzZXIgY29uaGVjaWRvLiBFIGEgY2FyYSBkZSBwYXUgZG8gYWR2b2dhZG8sIGNoYW1hbmRvIG8gY29uZGVuYWRvIGRlIGFjdXNhZG8uIFBvciBxdWUgYWluZGEgbuNvIGFwcmVzZW50YXJhbSBwZWRpZG8gZGUgYW51bGHn428gYW8ganXtem8gY29tcGV0ZW50ZSA/

  18. JOSE disse:

    R2lsbWFyIHF1ZXIgYWNhYmFyIGNvbSBNb3JvLCBhIExhdmEgSmF0byBlIG8gcGHtcyBwYXJhIGRlcG9pcyBmdWdpciBwYXJhIFBvcnR1Z2FsLiBPIHF1ZSBu83MgZml6ZW1vcyBwYXJhIG1lcmVjZXIgbyB0cmFzdGUgZGVzc2UgR2lsbWFyPw==

  19. Nelson disse:

    ZXNzZSBiYW5kaWRvIGVzdOEgY29tIHRvZG9zICBvcyByZXF1aXNpdG9zIGUgbelyaXRvcyBwYXJhIGFwb2RyZWNlciBudW1hIGNhZGVpYSBmZWRlcmFsLi4uLi4uLmUgbGV2ZW0gYWxndWVtIGRhIEZvbGhhIGp1bnRvIC4uLi4uLi4=

    1. TmVsc29uLCBxdWFudG8g82RpbyBuZXNzZSBjb3Jh5+NvLHF1ZXJlcyBwZWdhciBhdOkgbyBIYWRkYWQgPyBTZXLhIHF1ZSBubyB0ZXUgZGlhIGVzdOFzIGxpbXBvID8/PyBO428gc2VpICEgU/MgcGVyZ3VudG8gPz8/Pw==

  20. VPB disse:

    T2xoYSwgbyBwYe1zIHNlbXByZSBlc3RhcuEgbmEgYmVybGluZGEganVy7WRpY2EgZSBkbyBjYW9zIGVucXVhbnRvIHRpdmVybW9zIHVtIEdpbG1hciBlIHVtIExldmFuZPNsYXJlcyBuYSBjb3J0ZSEgVW0gYWNpbnRlIHNlbSBwcmVjZWRlbnRlcyE=

  21. Andressa disse:

    RXNwZXJvIHEgQ2Vsc28gZGUgTWVsbyBu428gc3VqZSBzdWEgYmlvZ3JhZmlhIGZhbHRhbmRvIHTjbyBwb3VjbyB0ZW1wbyBwYXJhIHNlIGFwb3NlbnRhciEg

  22. claudio disse:

    R2lsbWFyIE1lbmRleiBlc3RhIGhhY2tlYWRvLCBsb2dvIGxvZ28gYXMgY29udmVyc2FzIGRlbGUgdmFvIHNlciBsaWJlcmFkYXMgbnVtIHNpdGUgZGUgZGlyZWl0YS4uLi5vIGVzdHJhZ28gdmFpIHNlciBncmFuZGlvc28uLi4udW1hIGJvbWJhIGF0b21pY2EgYSBjYW1pbmhvLi4u

  23. Márcia disse:

    T250ZW0gbmEgZW50cmV2aXN0YSBjb20gbyBHaWxtYXIgTWVuZGVzIG8gRW1lcnZhbCBmb2kgZXNwZXRhY3VsYXIsIHBhbG1hcyBwYXJhIGVsZSwgb3MgZGVtYWlzIHRiZW0sID8/P2F06SBxdWUgZW5maW0gZW0gR2xvYm9OZXdzLi4uLi4=

  24. Texugo disse:

    SGFoYWhhISBBdOkgcXVhbmRvLCBCZWnnb2xhPw==

  25. Alina disse:

    T2JyaWdhZGEsIG1pbmlzdHJvIENlbHNvIGRlIE1lbGxvLCBvIEJyYXNpbCBkZSBiZW0gYWdyYWRlY2UhISEhID8/Pz8/Pz8/