Para soltar executivos, Gilmar flexibiliza regra do STF

A praxe no STF é negar habeas corpus quando eles não terminaram de tramitar no STJ, caso dos pedidos dos três executivos que Gilmar Mendes mandou soltar, registra O Globo.

Gilmar alegou que excepcionalmente essa regra pode ser flexibilizada e disse ter vislumbrado “constrangimento ilegal manifesto” nas prisões de Daurio Speranzini Junior, Miguel Iskin e Gustavo Estellita, decretadas pelo juiz Marcelo Bretas, da Lava Jato no Rio de Janeiro.

Antes de recorrer ao Supremo, a defesa dos três teve pedidos negados pelo TRF-2, com sede no Rio, e pelo vice-presidente do STJ, Humberto Martins.

No caso de Speranzini, executivo da GE, os investigadores haviam alegado que foi apreendido na sua residência um dossiê referente a Israel Masiero, ex-funcionário da Philips que denunciou um esquema de cartelização no Instituto Nacional de Traumatologia e Ortopedia (Into).

Isso indicaria que Speranzini poderia pôr em risco a investigação. Um outro documento, de 2016, mostraria a contemporaneidade dos fatos, justificando a prisão neste momento, de acordo com o jornal.

Gilmar, porém, aceitou o argumento da defesa de que ele está preso por supostos crimes cometidos há vários anos, em 2009 e 2010, não havendo necessidade de prendê-lo preventivamente agora.

“Registro que o paciente (Speranzini) não mais dirige a Philips, sendo atual CEO (executivo) da GE, empresa que não é investigada no âmbito da operação. Ora, se a Philips é a investigada, e o paciente não é mais seu CEO, não ficou demonstrado, no decreto de prisão, como o paciente conseguiria dar continuidade, até os dias atuais, às supostas irregularidades praticadas no âmbito da empresa da qual já se retirou”, decidiu o ministro.

Iskin e Estellita já tinham sido presos em abril de 2017 durante a Operação Fatura Exposta e soltos por Gilmar. O ministro concordou com a alegação da defesa de que o novo decreto de prisão, de julho deste ano, não trouxe argumentos novos.

Deixe seu comentário

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site; a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem;
Tempo de publicação: 4 minutos

200

  1. Denilton disse:

    UGFnb3UgbyBwdXJnYW50ZSBzb2x0b3UuLi4uLi4uIHRhcGEgbmEgY2FyYSBkZSBxdWVtIHBhZ2EgaW1wb3N0bywgcG9yIG1pbSBsaW5jaGFtZW50byBlbSBwcmHnYSBwdWJsaWNhLiBQZW5kdXJhIGEgY2FiZedhIG5vIHBvc3RlIGUgZXNjcmV2ZS4gRXN0ZSBzYWZhZG8gbmFvIGhvbnJvdSBzdWFzIGNhbOdhcy4=

Ler comentários
  1. 3pinos disse:

    c2UgbuNvIHBlZ2FyYW0gbyB0cm9mcm9sbGkgY29tIHN1YSBnZW5lcm9zYSBtZXNhZGEgY29tbyB2428gcGVnYXIgbyBiZWnnb2xhIC4uLi4uLi4uLiBpbmltcHV04XZlbCDpIGEgbWFyY2EgZG8gY2FyZ28gLi4uLi4gcG9kZSBmYXplciBvIHEgcXVpemVyIC4uLi4uLg==

  2. JANA disse:

    ImZsZXhpYmlsaXphJyDpIGV1ZmVtaXNtbywgZGV0dXJwYSBtZXNtbyAsIGNvbW8gTGV3YW5kb3NrIGZleiBubyBpbXBlYWNobWVudC4gREVQT0lTIHF1ZXIgcHJvY2Vzc2FyIHBvcnF1ZSBvIHBvdm8gbyBjaGFtYSBkZSBMQVhBTlRFIG1vciBkbyBCUkFTSUwuLi4u

  3. Guina disse:

    UHJpbWVpcmEsIHNlZ3VuZGEgZSB0ZXJjZWlyYSBpbnN04m5jaWFzIG7jbyBzYWJlbSBkZSBuYWRhLiBRdWVtIHNhYmUgZGFzIGNvaXNhcyDpIG8gR2lsbWFyLg==

  4. TAVARES CMRJ1961 disse:

    RXNzZSBjYXJhIOkgbyBzdXByYS1zdW1vIGRhIHZlbmFsaWRhZGUgLiAuIC4gbyB0b21ibywgcGVsYSBs82dpY2EsIHZhaSBzZXIgZ3JhbmRlLiBJbXBvc3PtdmVsIHVtYSBwZXNzb2EgYXNzdW1pciBhIG1hcmdpbmFsaWRhZGUgZSBwYXNzYXIgbyByZXN0byBkYSB2aWRhIGltcHVuZSAuIC4gLiB2aSBhY29udGVjZXIgREVVUyBFU1TBIFZJVk8u

  5. Chico disse:

    ZGlzc2UgdGVyIHZpc2x1bWJyYWRvID9jb25zdHJhbmdpbWVudG8gaWxlZ2FsIG1hbmlmZXN0bz8tIFJlYWxtZW50ZSBlbGUgVklTTFVCUk9VICBvdXRyYSBtYW5laXJhIGRlIHJlY2ViZXIgJCQkJCQkIHNlbSBjb25zdHJhbmdpbWVudG8uLi4uLi5tYW5pZmVzbWVudGUgbGVnYWlzIGF0cmF2ZXMgZGUgcGF0cm9jaW5pb3MgZSBkb2Hn9WVzLiEhISEu

  6. Alberto disse:

    UG9ycXVlIG7jbyBjb25mZXJpciBhIEdpbG1hciBNZW5kZXMgbyB07XR1bG8gZGUgRE9OTyBkbyBqdWRpY2nhcmlvIGJyYXNpbGVpcm8sIHBvciBjb25zZWd1aW50ZSBET05PIGRvIHBh7XMsIGNvbWFuZGFudGUgZW0gY2hlZmUgZGFzIEZGQUEscyBxdWUgZXN0428gQUNPVkFSREFEQVMu

  7. Ele... Sempre ele !!! disse:

    Pz8/Pz8/Pz9BdOkgcXVhbmRvIHZhbW9zIHRlciBxdWUgc3Vwb3J0YXIgcXVlIG1hcmdpbmFpcyBzZSBwcm90ZWphbSA/Pz8=

  8. Esgotou minha paciência! disse:

    ySB1bSBhYnN1cmRvIG1hcyBuaW5ndeltIHRlbSBvIHBvZGVyIGRlIHF1ZXN0aW9uYXIgZXN0ZSBnYW5nc3RlciBkZSB0b2dhLi4uIG8gQnJhc2lsIOkgcmVm6W0gZGVzdGUgcHVsaGEhIENhZGEgdmV6IG1haXMgZmljYSBldmlkZW50ZSBhIGltcG9ydOJuY2lhIGRvIHZvdG8gQk9MU09OQVJPISEhISEh

  9. CADÊ O MAV JOYCE SOUZA/EDUARDO GARCIA? disse:

    RXNzZSBNQVYgc2VtcHJlIGFwYXJlY2UgcGFyYSBkZWZlbmRlciBvIG1hcmdpbmFsIEdpbG1hciBNZW5kZXMgcnM=

  10. Drummond disse:

    Tm8gaG9y4XJpbyBwb2ztdGljbywgIG8gQnJhc2lsIGVzdGFy4SBvdXZpbmRvIEJvbHNvbmFybyBuYSBuZXQuICBNZXNtbyBxIHNlamEgbm90aWNpYSBhbnRpZ2EuIFVNQSBSRVNQT1NUQSBBIEdJTE1BUiBNRU5ERVMgRSBBT1MgVE9HQVMgQ09OSVZFTlRFUyBDT01PIEVMRSBOQSBPUkNSSU0uLi4gVW1hIHJlc3Bvc3RhIGEgbe1kaWEgZW0gZ2VyYWwu

  11. Nelson disse:

    RmF6IHNlbnRpZG8uIFVtIHRyYWZpY2FudGUgcmVpbmNpZGVudGUsIHByZXNvIGFvIGVzY29uZGVyIGRyb2dhcyBuYSBjYXNhIDQgZGEgUnVhIEEsIGFvIHNlIG11ZGFyIHBhcmEgYSBjYXNhIDMgZGEgUnVhIEIgbuNvIGjhIHBvcnF1ZSBhY2hhciBxdWUgZWxlIGZhcmlhIG8gbWVzbW8sIGrhIHF1ZSBlc3RhcmlhIGVtIGxvY2FsIGRpZmVyZW50ZS4gZOM=

  12. heleno de almeida pinto disse:

    U3VnaXJvIGFvIE8gQW50YWdvbmlzdGEgdmVyaWZpY2FyIHNlIG9zIGFkdm9nYWRvcyBkZXNzZXMgcGlsYW50cmFzIHNvbHRvcyBu428gZXN0428gdmluY3VsYWRvcywgZGUgdW1hIGZvcm1hIG91IGRlIG91dHJhLCBjb20gYSBCYW5jYSBkYSBtdWxoZXIgZGUgR2lsbWFyLg==

  13. IMPEACHMENT DO MARGINAL GILMAR MENDES disse:

    QXNzaW5lIGEgUGV0aefjbyBwZWxvIEltcGVhY2htZW50IGRvIE1hcmdpbmFsIEdpbG1hciBNZW5kZXMuIEEgY2FtaW5obyBkZSBUcupzIG1pbGj1ZXMgZGUgYXNzaW5hdHVyYXM6IGh0dHBzOi8vd3d3LmNoYW5nZS5vcmcvcC9leGlnaW1vcy1vLWltcGVhY2htZW50LWRlLWdpbG1hci1tZW5kZXM=

  14. IMPEACHMENT DO MARGINAL GILMAR MENDES disse:

    QXNzaW5lIGEgUGV0aefjbyBwZWxvIEltcGVhY2htZW50IGRvIE1hcmdpbmFsIEdpbG1hciBNZW5kZXMuIEEgY2FtaW5obyBkZSBUcupzIG1pbGj1ZXMgZGUgYXNzaW5hdHVyYXM6IGh0dHBzOi8vd3d3LmNoYW5nZS5vcmcvcC9leGlnaW1vcy1vLWltcGVhY2htZW50LWRlLWdpbG1hci1tZW5kZXM=

  15. IMPEACHMENT DO MARGINAL GILMAR MENDES disse:

    QXNzaW5lIGEgUGV0aefjbyBwZWxvIEltcGVhY2htZW50IGRvIE1hcmdpbmFsIEdpbG1hciBNZW5kZXMuIEEgY2FtaW5obyBkZSBUcupzIG1pbGj1ZXMgZGUgYXNzaW5hdHVyYXM6IGh0dHBzOi8vd3d3LmNoYW5nZS5vcmcvcC9leGlnaW1vcy1vLWltcGVhY2htZW50LWRlLWdpbG1hci1tZW5kZXM=

  16. Drummond disse:

    TyBwZWRhZ2lvIGRldmUgc2VyIGFsdO1zc2ltbyBubyBTVEYuIFF1YW5kbyBCb2xzb25hcm8gZSBNb3VyP28gZW50cmFyZW0gbm8gcGxhbmFsdG8sIGEgY29udmVyc2EgdmFpIHNlciBvdXRyYSAiQVFVSSIuIEFHVUFSREVNISBDYXNvIGFzIHVybmFzIG5vcyB0cmFpYW0sIHRlcmVtb3MgR1VFUlJBIENJVklMIGNvbnRyYSBPUkNSSU0u

  17. +Marcelo F disse:

    TuNvIGdvc3RvIGRlIHVzYXIgZXNzYSBwYWxhdnJhLCBtYXMgZXN0ZSBjaWRhZONvIOkgdW0gY+JuY2VyIG5vIEJyYXNpbC4=

  18. Mario Temeroso disse:

    UXVlciBkaXplciBvIGJhbmRpZG8gdmVtIGFzc2FsdGFuZG8gZSByb3ViYW5kbyBoYSB24XJpb3MgYW5vcywgbuNvIHRlbSBuZWNlc3NpZGFkZSBkZSBwcmVuZGVyIGFnb3JhID8gRXNzYSBldSByZWFsbWVudGUgbuNvIGVudGVuZGku

  19. Bobina disse:

    Q29pc2EgbWFpcyAgaW5mdW5kYWRhIHByZW5kZXIgZ2VudGUgcXVlIHByYXRpY291IGNyaW1lcyBhIG1haXMgZGUgdW0gYW5vICwgbukgR2lsbWFyPyBPIG1lbGhvciDpIG51bmNhIHByZW5kZXIgbmluZ3XpbSBlIGFzc2ltIG7jbyBk4SB0cmFiYWxobyBwcmEgdm9j6nMgZG8gU1QuLi4gR2lsbWFyIOkgdW0gZXNwYW50byE=

  20. Beiçola ataca novamente disse:

    RXNzZSBzZXIg6SByZXB1Z25hbnRlIQ==

  21. Joyce Souza disse:

    TWFyY2VsbyAiRG9pcyBBdXjtbGlvcyIgQnJldGFzIGUgc2V0b3JlcyBkbyBNUCBlIGRhIFBGIC0gYmVtIGNvbW8gTyBBbnRhZ29uaXN0YSwg6SBjbGFybyAtIGZpY2FtIGlycml0YWTtc3NpbW9zIHF1YW5kbyBjb25zdHJhbmdpbWVudG9zIGlsZWdhaXMgbWFuaWZlc3RvcyBz428gY29pYmlkb3MgZSBhIGxlaSBwcmV2YWxlY2UuLi4=

  22. Bruno disse:

    RXNzZSBHaWxtYXIgTWVuZGVzIG1lcmVjZSBhcG9kcmVjZXIgbmEgY2FkZWlhLiBCYW5kaWRvb29vLiBFc3ThIGFjYWJhbmRvIGNvbSBvIEJyYXNpbC4gQm9sc29uYXJvIHZhaSByZXNvbHZlciBtYWlzIGVzdGUgcHJvYnJvbmEuIEFmaW5hbCBzZSB1bSBTVEYgZXN04SBhY2ltYSBkYXMgTGVpcywgdW0gcHJlc2lkZW50ZSBwb2RlIHR1ZG8u

  23. é gonzaguinha disse:

    UXVhbCBvIHZhbG9yIHF1ZSBhIEdFIGVzdOEgcGFnYW5kbz8=

  24. Sarcástico disse:

    R2lsbWFyIHRlbSB1bWEgYmlycmEgY29tIG8gQnJlZGFzIGRvIFJpbywgauEgbm90YXJhbSBxdWUgZWxlIG7jbyBzb2x0YSBvcyBkbyBNb3JvPw==

  25. humberto picolini disse:

    Z2lsbWFyIGUgYWxndW5zIG91dHJvcyB0ZW0gdGFiZWxhIGRlIHByZedvcy4gU2UgcGFnYXIgZmljYSBzb2x0by4gySBzaW1wbGVzIGFzc2ltLiBkdXJvIGRlIGVuZ29saXIgbWFzIOkgYSB2ZXJkYWRlLg==

  26. Observador777 disse:

    RXNzZSBHaWxtYXIgbuNvIHRlbSBtYWlzIG5lbmh1bWEgdmVyZ29uaGEgbWVzbW8uLi4gySBOT1TTUklPIG8gcXVlIGVsZSBlc3ThIGZhemVuZG8uLi4gc29sdGFuZG8gYW1pZ29zLCBjb25oZWNpZG9zIGUgcmVsYWNpb25hZG9zLi4uIG5lbSBtZXNtbyBzZSBkZWNsYXJhIGltcGVkaWRvLi4uIEVJISEhISEgQVTJIFFVQU5ETyE/Pz8=

  27. Morgana disse:

    UmVjZWl0YSBpbmZhbO12ZWwgcGFyYSBxdWVtIGVzdOEgY29tIHByaXPjbyBkZSB2ZW50cmU6IHRvbWUgMSBnaWxtYXJtZW5kZXMgcG9yIGRpYSBlIHJlc29sdmEgc2V1cyBwcm9ibGVtYXMgaW50ZXN0aW5haXMu

  28. Luiz disse:

    RmljbyBhIGltYWdpbmFyIGNvbW8gc2Vy428gYXMgcHLzeGltYXMgODMgdGVtcG9yYWRhcyBkYSBz6XJpZSA/byBtZWNhbmlzbW8/LiBRdWFuZG8gYSBnZW50ZSBwZW5zYSBxdWUgauEgdml1IGRlIHR1ZG8uLi4gZGVzY29icmUgcXVlIG7jbyB2aXUgbmFkYSA=

  29. Guilherme Maia disse:

    RXNzZSBtaW5pc3RybyBu428gcmVzcGVpdGEgbWFpcyBuYWRhLiBTZXVzIHBhcmVzIGRldmVyaWFtIHRvbWFyIHVtYSBhdGl0dWRlIHBhcmEgbWFudGVyIGEgcG91Y2EgcmVzcGVpdGFiaWxpZGFkZSBlIGluZGVwZW5k6m5jaWEgcXVlIGFpbmRhIHJlc3RhIGFvIHN1cHJlbW8u

  30. Alemão disse:

    RXN0ZSBtaW5pc3RybyBmZWRlISBGZWRlIOAgb21pc3PjbyEgRmVkZSDgIGNvbml26m5jaWEhIEZlZGUg4CBwYXJjaWFsaWRhZGUgZW0gZmF2b3IgZG9zIHJpY29zISBGZWRlIOAgc2Fib3RhZ2VtISBDb3JydXDn428gZGV2ZXJpYSBzZXIgcHVuaWRhIGNvbSBwZW5hIGRlIG1vcnRlIQ==

  31. Pedro Pedreira disse:

    RXNzZSBWQUdBQlVORE8gZGVzc2UgR2lsbWFyIE1lbmRlcywgaW50ZXJwcmV0YSBhIGxlaSBjb25mb3JtZSBvIFLpdSwg6SB1bWEgQ1JFVElOTyBzZW0gY2Fy4XRlciBxdWUgZW0gdW0gUGHtcyBkZSBIb21lbnMgaG9ucmFkb3MgZSBjb3Jham9zb3MgauEgdGVyaWEgdG9tYWRvIHVtIHRpcm8gZW50cmUgb3Mgb2xob3MhIEJhc3RhdmEgdW0gTW9ycmVyIQ==

  32. grilo falante disse:

    TyBwYWNpZW50ZSBzZW5kbyByaWNvIGUgcG9kZXJvc28sIG8gR2lsbWFyIGZsZXhpYmlsaXphIHNlbXByZS4=

  33. Edu Carvalho disse:

    TyBCcmFzaWwgYXR1YWwg6SB1bSBwYe1zIHNlbSBsZWlzIGUgcmVncmFzIGRlZmluaWRhcy4gQSBpbnNlZ3VyYW7nYSBqdXLtZGljYSBwcmV2YWxlY2Uu

  34. Gasparzinho disse:

    RSBvIGltcGVkaW1lbnRvIGRlc3RlIGluZmVsaXo/Pz8/

  35. Danilo disse:

    U2VtIHZlcmdvbmhhICwgY292YXJkZSBlIHRyYWlkb3IgZG8gQnJhc2lsLiBCb2xzb25hcm8gdmFpIGZhemVyIGVsZSBtaWFyIGRpcmVpdGluaG8u

  36. arthur disse:

    TyB1bmljbyBxdWUgcG9kZSAgc2UgcmV2b2x0YXIgIOkgbyBqdWl6IEJyZXRhcy0tLVNlIGVsZSBhY2VpdGEgc2VtIGNoaWFyLGVudONvIG5hZGEgcG9kZSBzZXIgZmVpdG8tLS0=

    1. TuNvIHRlbSBtdWl0byBvIHF1ZSBmYXplciBz8yBzZSBlbGUgY29uc2VndWlyIG91dHJvIHByb2Nlc3NvLg==

  37. Luix disse:

    R2lsbWFyIE1lbmRlcyBlc3ThIGNvbSBvIGNrdS1uYS1t428gc2UgZmljYXJlbSBwcmVzb3MsIHNlbSBoYWJlYXMgY29ycHVzLCBvcyBj+m1wbGljZXMgQmFyYXRhIFJpYmVpcm8sIElza2luIGUgZGVtYWlzIHBhZ2Fkb3JlcyBkZSBwcm9waW5hcyBwYXJhIGVzc2UganVpeiwgYXRyYXbpcyBkYSBsYXZhbmRlcmlhIGRlIHByb3BpbmFzIElEUC4=

  38. Fernando Costa da Silva disse:

    RXNzZSBmYXJzYW50ZSB2YWkgcGFnYXIgY2FybyBwZWxvcyBkZWJvY2hlcyBhbyBwb3ZvLCB0byBhbnNpb3NvIHByYSB2ZXIgbyBkaWEgZW0gcXVlIHNhaXLhIG5hIG1hcnJhLg==

  39. ASSINE PETIÇÃO IMPEACHMENT GILMAR MENDES disse:

    QXNzaW5lIGEgUGV0aefjbyBwZWxvIEltcGVhY2htZW50IGRvIE1hcmdpbmFsIEdpbG1hciBNZW5kZXMuIEEgY2FtaW5obyBkZSBUcupzIG1pbGj1ZXMgZGUgYXNzaW5hdHVyYXM6IGh0dHBzOi8vd3d3LmNoYW5nZS5vcmcvcC9leGlnaW1vcy1vLWltcGVhY2htZW50LWRlLWdpbG1hci1tZW5kZXM=

  40. Marcello disse:

    R2lsbWFyIE1lbmRlcyBlc3ThIGZpY2FuZG8gcmlxde1zc2ltbyBjb20gc2V1IGJhbGPjbyBkZSBuZWfzY2lvcyBkZW50cm8gZSBmb3JhIGRvIFNURi4=

  41. Cyberwatch disse:

    Sm95Y2UgU291emEgZGlzc2U6ICA4IGRlIGFnb3N0byBkZSAyMDE4IOBzIDEzOjA2IC0gUGVyYSBh7Swgdm9j6iBlc3ThIGRlZmVuZGVuZG8gbyBHaWxtYXIhPyBWYyBz8yBwb2RlIHNlciBmdW7nYSBkbyAkVEYgb3UgZG8gSURQLiBOaW5ndeltIGVtIHPjIGNvbnNjaepuY2lhIGRlZmVuZGVyaWEgZXNzZSBjcmltaW5vc28gYWJqZXRvLg==

  42. Lauro Ferreira Melo disse:

    R2lsbWFyIE1lbmRlcyBmYXogbyBxdWUgcXVlciBlIHF1YW5kbyBxdWVyLiBFbGUgZSBtYWlzIG8gVG9mZm9saSwgTGV3YW5kb3N3a2kgZSBNYXJjbyBBdXLpbGlvLCBkZW5pZ3JlbSBvIFNURiBlIGEganVzdGnnYSBjb21vIHVtIHRvZG8uIEUgbmFkYSBhY29udGVjZQ==

  43. Waldomiro Freitas disse:

    TyBjYW5hbGhhICJnaWxtYXIgbWVuZGVzIiDpIHVtIEPCTkNFUiBwYXJhIG8gQnJhc2lsIGUgbyBjb21iYXRlIGEgY29ycnVw5+NvIGUgY3JpbWlub3Nvcy4=

  44. Duro de Matar disse:

    UXVlIHRhbCBmbGV4aWJpbGl6YXIgbyBtYW5kYXRvIGRvIEdpbG1hciBlIGFjYWJhciBjb20gZWxlID8=

  45. Brasileirinho disse:

    TyBjcmltZSBkYXMgZWxpdGVzIGFxdWkgbm8gQnJhc2lsIGRhcyBkaXJldGFzIGrhLCBjb21wZW5zYSB1YWkh

  46. SOLTAR BANDIDOS especialidade do Beiçola disse:

    ySBlc3BlY2lhbGlkYWRlIGRvIEdpbG1hci4gTyBtYWlvciBhZHZvZ2FkbyBkb3MgQkFORElET1Mu