PEC da 2ª instância da Câmara é “único caminho viável”, diz pesquisador

Na disputa entre Câmara e Senado pelo retorno da prisão em segunda instância, a proposta de emenda constitucional (PEC 199/19), relatada pela deputada Caroline de Toni, parece ter mais viabilidade.

Para o jurista Fabrício Rebelo, coordenador do Cepedes (Centro de Pesquisa em Direito e Segurança Pública), ela seria o “único caminho”.

“O único caminho viável para resolver a questão é mesmo o da PEC, aprovada na CCJ da Câmara, que extingue recursos, sem alterar ou relativizar qualquer garantia constitucional”, opina.

Segundo Rebelo, o julgamento do STF sobre a prisão em segunda instância “acabou delimitando as possibilidades de mudanças legais ou constitucionais”.

“Como ali se entendeu que o art. 283 do CPP é constitucional porque respeita integralmente o texto do art. 5º, LVII, da Constituição, qualquer alteração que disponha em contrário do que há hoje, como se propõe no Senado, será logicamente tida por inconstitucional naquela Corte. Somando a isso o fato de que a presunção de inocência está em cláusula pétrea.”

MST, MTST... os parceiros de Lula para inflamar as ruas do Brasil. Leia aqui

Deixe seu comentário

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site; a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem;
Tempo de publicação: 4 minutos

200

  1. RRICARDO disse:

    TWFpcyAgYmFiYWNhIHF1ZSBzZSBkaXogZW50ZW5kaWRvLi4uIG1lIGFkbWlyYSBvIGFudGFnb25pc3RhIHD6YmxpY2FyIGlzc28uIA==

Ler comentários
  1. disse:

    RXN04SBjbGFybyAucXVlbSBu428gcXVlciBlc3ThIG11ZGFu52Egc+NvIG9zIHF1ZSBlc3TjbyBvdSBlc3RhcuNvIGVudm9sdmlkb3MgZW0gYWxnbyBvYnNjdXJvIGUgcGVuc2FuZG8gbmFzIGZhY2lsaWRhZGVzIGRhIGxlaSxlIHJ1aW0gcGFyYSBPQUIgLg==

  2. NNando disse:

    bmFvIGFkaWFudGEgc2UgbmFkYSBhY29udGVjZXIgdmFpIG11ZGFyIG8gZW50ZW5kaW1lbnRvIG5vdmFtZW50ZSBlbSBub3ZlbWJybyBkbyBhbm8gcXVlIHZlbS4uLi4uLi4gbuNvIHRlbSB4b3Jvcm8g

  3. Adélia disse:

    RXN0428gbm9zIGVuZ2FuYW5kbyBjb20gZXNzZSBibOEgYmzhIGJs4Swgc2FiZW0gcXVlIG8gcG92byBkYXF1aSBhIHBvdWNvIGrhIGVzcXVlY2V1IGVzc2EgTS4gTm9zc29zIGNvbmdyZXNzaXN0YXMgc+NvIHZhZ2FiYXMgcHJvZmlzc2lvbmFpcy4=

  4. Rege disse:

    VW1hIGdyYW5kZSBxdWFudGlkYWRlIGRlIHBvbO10aWNvcyBhY29tcGFuaGFtIG8gc2l0ZSwgZXNwZXJvIHF1ZSBlbGVzIG7jbyBjYWlhbSBuYSBhcm1h5+NvIGRvIFJvZHJpZ28gTWFpYSBlIEFsY29sdW1icmksIHF1ZSBqdW50b3MgZXN0428gdGVudGFuZG8gYmFycmFyIGEgUEVDIGNvbSB1bSBhcnJhbmpvIG5vIHNlbmFkby4=

    1. RXNzZXMgZG9pcyB2428gcGFnYXIgY2FybywgbuNvIHbjbyBnYW5oYXIgbWFpcyBuYWRhIG5hIHBvbGl0aWNhLCB2YW1vcyBtb3N0cmFyIHRvZG9zIGVsZWl0b3JlcyBxdWVtIGVzdONvIGZhdm9yIGRvIEJyYXNpbCwgZWxlcyBlc3TjbyBjb250cmEsIGF0cmFzYWRvIHR1ZG8gZGUgaW50ZXJlc3NlIGRvIEJyYXNpbC4=

  5. Ronaldo disse:

    Q29tIHVtU1RGIGNvbSB2YXJpb3MgTWluLkNvcnJ1cHRvcywgZXN0YSBkaWZpY2lsLCBtYXMgdmFtb3MgdmVuY2VyLCBsdWdhciBkZSBMYWRy429OYUNhZGVpYS4=

  6. Nil disse:

    TuNvIHNlaSwgbWFzIGFjaG8gcXVlIG9zIDUgZG8gU1RGIGEgZmF2b3IgZGEgc2VndW5kYSBpbnN04m5jaWEsIG7jbyBsaWdhcmlhbSBwcmEgaXNzby5U82ZvbGkgZGlzc2UgcXVlIG7jbyBlcmEgcHJlY2lzbyBlIFJvc2EgV2ViZXIgdOEgbG91cXVpbmhhIHByYSB2aXIgcHJvIGxhZG8gZGEgbHV6Lg==

  7. Sarcástico disse:

    QSBQRUMgZGEgQ+JtYXJhIGFwcm92YWRhIG5hIENDSiDpIGEgbWVsaG9yLCBhY2FiYSBjb20gcmVjdXJzb3MgYW8gU1RKIGUgU1RGLCBxdWUgYXV0b21hdGljYW1lbnRlIHRyYW5zZm9ybWEgYSBDb25kZW5h5+NvIGVtIDKqIGluc3RhbmNpYSBjb21vIFRyYW5zaXRvIGVtIEp1bGdhZG8sIGxvZ28gdmFpIGxvZ28gcHJlc28u

  8. MAZZAROPI disse:

    QmFsZWxhLCBwcmlz428gZW0gMiogaW5zdOJuY2lhIG7jbyBwYXNzYSBuYSBj4m1hcmEu

  9. JoseRMonteiro disse:

    Q2xhdXN1bGEgcOl0cmVhIOkgbWFpcyB1bWEgamFidXRpY2FiYSBicmFzaWxlaXJhLiBBIGNvbnN0aXR1aefjbyDpIGZlaXRhIHBlbG9zIGh1bWFub3MgcGFyYSByZWd1bGFyIGEgc29jaWVkYWRlIGRlIGh1bWFub3MuIFDpdHJlYSwg6SBidXJyaWNlIGUgbWlvcGlhIHNvY2lhbC4=

  10. Jupira disse:

    Sm9pY2UgSGFzc2VsbWFuIGVzdGEgZGl2dWxnYW5kbyBxdWUgbyBHVUdVIGZhbGVjZXUu

    1. ySBtZW50aXJhISAgRXN04SBlbSBvYnNlcnZh5+NvIHBvciA0OGhzIGVtIGhvc3BpdGFsLiAgQm9sZXRpbSBt6WRpY28gYWluZGEgbuNvIHNhaXUu

  11. mara disse:

    QWxjb2x1bWJyZSBlIE1haWEgbuNvIHF1ZXJlbSBhIHByaXPjbyBlbSAyYS4gSW5zdOJuY2lhLiBGYXLjbyBkZSB0dWRvIHBhcmEgZGlmaWN1bHRhciBhIGFwcm92Yefjby4gQmFuZGlkbyBu428gYXByb3ZhLCDzYnZpby4g

  12. Carlos disse:

    U2UgaG91dmVyIGVzc2EgYWx0ZXJh5+NvLCBleHRpbmd1aW5kbyBvcyByZWN1cnNvcyBlc3BlY2lhbCBlIGV4dHJhb3JkaW7hcmlvLCBhIHJlcGVyY3Vzc+NvIG5hIOFyZWEgY2l2aWwgc2Vy4SBlbm9ybWUuT2NvcnJlcuEgbyBpbWVkaWF0byBjdW1wcmltZW50byBkZSBzZW50ZW7nYXMgY29udHJhIEVzdGFkb3MgZSBNdW5pY+1waW9zLiA=

  13. Sergio disse:

    TyBjYW1pbmhvIHZp4XZlbCDpIGRhcXVpIGEgMSBhbm8uIEZ1eCBzZXLhIHByZXNpZGVudGUgU1RGIGUgQ2Vsc28gYXBvc2VudGEuIFR1ZG8gZGVwZW5kZXLhIGRlIHF1ZW0gbyBCb2xzb25hcm8gaW5kaWNhcuEu

  14. Jorge disse:

    U2UgYSBwcmVzdW7n428gZGUgaW5vY+puY2lhIOkgY2zhdXN1bGEgcOl0cmVhLCBpc3RvIG7jbyBzaWduaWZpY2EgcXVlIGEgcHJpc+NvIHPzIG9jb3JyYSBhcPNzIGEgNLAgaW5zdOJuY2lhLiBBIHByaXPjbyBwb2RlIHNlIGRhciBhcPNzIGEgMrAgaW5zdOJuY2lhIGUgY29udGludWFyIGhhdmVuZG8gYSBjaGFuY2UgZGUgaQ==

  15. Nil disse:

    UG94YSwgdGVudGVtIHByaW1laXJvIHPzIGEgbXVkYW7nYSBzaW1wbGVzLi4ucG9kZSBjb2xhciAhIE7jbyBkYW5kbywgZmF6ZXIgbyBxLCB2YW1vcyBwcmEgUEVDLiAgQe0gZXhpc3RlIGEgbWFsYW5kcmFnZW0gZGUgcXVlbSDpIGNvbnRyYSwgY29tZedhciBwZWxvIGZpbmFsLi4ubuNvIGRhbmRvLGFjYWJvdSE=

  16. Ricardo disse:

    VGVjbmljYW1lbnRlIGZhbGFuZG8sIGEgUEVDIGRhIEPibWFyYSDpIG1lbGhvci4gTm8gZW50YW50bywgZWxhIGRlbWFuZGEgYSBtdWRhbudhIGVtIGlu+m1lcmFzIExlaXMgaW5mcmFjb25zdGl0dWNpb25haXMuIERpdG8gcG9yIG91dHJhcyBwYWxhdnJhcywg6SB1bWEgcGVnYWRpbmhhIHBxIGFwcm92YSBwYXJhIGRlaXhhciB0ZCBjb21vIGVz

  17. Ricardo disse:

    TyBwZXNxdWlzYWRvciBlcnJhLCBwb2lzIGjhIG91dHJvcyBjYW1pbmhvcy4gIEJhc3RhIGFjcmVzY2VudGFyIHVtIHBhcuFncmFmbyBhbyBhcnQuIDW6IGUgZGVmaW5pciBxdWUsIHBhcmEgZmlucyBwZW5haXMsIGNvbnNpZGVyYS1zZSAidHJhbnNpdGFkYSBlbSBqdWxnYWRvIGEgZGVjaXPjbyBwcm9mZXJpZGEgZW0gc2VndW5kYSBpbnN04m4=

  18. Márcia disse:

    ySBlc3RhIFBFQyBxdWUgdGVtb3MgZGUgbGV2YXIgYSBkaWFudGUhISBRdWVyZW1vcyBwcmlz428gZW0gc2VndW5kYSBpbnN04m5jaWEgZW50428gdmFtb3MgbHV0YXIgcG9yIGVsYS4=

  19. Ricardo disse:

    UGVyZ3VudGEgcXVlIG7jbyBxdWVyIGNhbGFyOiBwb3IgcXVlIG8gQW50YWdvbmlzdGEgbuNvIGF1bWVudGEgYSBxdWFudGlkYWRlIGRlIGNhcmFjdGVyZXMgZG9zIGNvbWVudOFyaW9zPyDJIGRpZu1jaWwgYXJ0aWN1bGFyIHVtIGJvbSBjb21lbnThcmlvLiBQcmVnYW0gYSB0cmFuc3BhcupuY2lhLCBtYXMgZONvIHDpc3NpbW8gZXhlbXA=

  20. Nil disse:

    UXVlcmVtIOkgaW5jdXRpciBuYSBjYWJl52EgZGUgdG9kb3MgcXVlIGEgc29sdefjbyDpIHPzIGVzdGEgKCBjbOF1c3VsYSBw6XRyZWEpIC5QcSBhIG91dHJhIOkgbXVpdG8gbWFpcyB2aeF2ZWwsIHNpbXBsZXMgZSBwb2RlICggc2UgcG9kZSwgcHEgbuNvIHRlbnRhcj8pIHNpbSBkYXIgY2VydG8hIERlc2lzdGVtIGRhIGbhY2lsIGU=

  21. Chrisoula disse:

    QW50YWdvbmlzdGEgY2l0b3UgZW0gb3V0cm8gcG9zdCBhYmFpeG8sIG1hcyBhc3N1bnRvIHRiIGZvaSBhYm9yZGFkbyBwb3IgUG9s7WJpbyBCcmFnYSBlbSB27WRlbzogIk5ob25obyBlIEFsY29sdW1icmUgZXN0428gbm9zIGVuZ2FuYW5kbyBzb2JyZSBhIHByaXPjbyBlbSAyYS4gaW5zdOJuY2lhIi4gICBBc3Npc3RhbSAhISEgIA==

    1. Q29tcGxlbWVudG86ICAod3d3LnBvbGliaW9icmFnYUBibG9nc3BvdC5jb20pLiAgIA==

  22. Jorge disse:

    TuNvIGjhIGNvbnNlbnNvIGRlIHF1ZSBhIHByZXN1bufjbyBkZSBpbm9j6m5jaWEgc2VqYSBjbOF1c3VsYSBw6XRyZWEuIE1hcyBtZXNtbyBzZSBmb3IsIGEgcHJpc+NvIGVtIDKwIGluc3TibmNpYSBu428gYSB2aW9sYS4gRW0gbmVuaHVtIHBh7XMgY2l2aWxpemFkbyBhIHByaXPjbyBz8yBzZSBk4SBhcPNzIGEgNLAgaW5z

  23. Dene disse:

    NyBtaW5pc3Ryb3Mgc2UgbWFuaWZlc3RhcmFtIGEgZmF2b3IgZGEgYWx0ZXJh5+NvIGRvIDI4MyBkbyBDUFAuICBEaXplciBxdWUg6SBjb21wYXTtdmVsIGNvbSBhIENGIG7jbyBzaWduaWZpY2EgcXVlIG7jbyBwb3NzYSBzZXIgYWx0ZXJhZG8gc2Vu428gYSBDRiBwYXNzYXJpYSBhIHNlciBDb25zdGl0dWnn428gcu1naWRhIGUgaW5hbA==