Pedido no Supremo para derrubar prisões do TRF-4 já foi negado por Toffoli

O pedido a ser julgado na Segunda Turma do STF para derrubar as prisões de condenados na segunda instância da Lava Jato já havia sido rejeitado no ano passado por Dias Toffoli.

Em maio de 2018, quando ainda não comandava a Corte e era relator do habeas corpus, o ministro negou o pedido, com base no entendimento firmado em 2016 no plenário que permite a execução da pena após condenação em segunda instância.

“As execuções provisórias emanadas do TRF4, à luz do verbete sumular nº 122, não desborda em constrangimento ilegal, uma vez que reflete o entendimento predominante na Corte a respeito da matéria”, escreveu à época.

O habeas corpus contesta regra interna do Tribunal Regional Federal da 4ª Região (TRF-4) que obriga a prisão após segunda instância. Para o autor da ação, a prisão não pode ser automática e deve ser justificada caso a caso.

Como houve recurso, a discussão ocorrerá, em data ainda indefinida, na Segunda Turma, formada por Cármen Lúcia (relatora), Edson Fachin, Gilmar Mendes, Celso de Mello e Ricardo Lewandowski.

NOVO ANTAGONISTA: RESERVE SEU LUGAR NA SEMANA DE LANÇAMENTO. Leia aqui

Deixe seu comentário

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site; a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem;
Tempo de publicação: 4 minutos

200

  1. AADONIS SINICIO JUNIOR disse:

    TuNvIHBvZGVtb3MgY3JpYXIgZXhwZWN0YXRpdmFzIG90aW1pc3RhcyBxdWFudG8g4HMgYef1ZXMgZGUgVG9mZm9saS4gRWxlIHNlbXByZSBpcuEgZmF6ZXIgbyBxdWUgTHVsYSBlIFrpIERpcmNldSBkZXRlcm1pbmFtLg==

Ler comentários
  1. PAULOQUARESMA disse:

    Q29tbyBiZW0gc2FiZW1vcywgbyBlbnRlbmRpbWVudG8gZGEgc2VndW5kYS1mZWlyYSBu428gc2Vy4SBvIG1lc21vIG5hIHF1aW50YS1mZWlyYS4gVHVkbyBkZXBlbmRlIGRvIHF1ZSB0ZXLhIG9jb3JyaWRvIG5hIHRlcudhIGUgcXVhcnRhLiBFbnRlbmRlPw==

  2. Heloisa disse:

    RW0gVG9mZm9saSBuaW5ndeltIGNvbmZpYS4gTWFzIHZhbW9zIGRpdnVsZ2FyIOAgZXhhdXN0428gYSBkZWNpc+NvIGRlc3NlIHRpcmFubyBjZW5zb3IsIHBlcnNlZ3VpZG9yIGRlIGNpZGFk429zLiBMdWxhL0RpcmNldSBwb2RlbSBkYXIgb3JkZW5zIHBhcmEgbyBlc3RhZmV0YSwgbWFzIGVzdGFyZW1vcyBhdGVudG9zIGUgZGlzcG9zdG9zIOA=

  3. J.TAJRA disse:

    U/MgZmFsdGEgYWdvcmEgYWxndW5zICJmaWxob3MgZG8gTHVsYSIgbm8gU1RGLCByZXZvZ2FyIGVzc2UgZW50ZW5kaW1lbnRvLCBjb21vIHF1ZXJlbSBhIG1haW9yaWEgZGVsZXMsIGUgbWFuZGFyIHNvbHRhciB0b2RvcyBvcyBsYWRy9WVzLCBjb3JydXB0b3MsIGxhdmFkb3IgZGUgZGluaGVpcm8sIGVzdGFtb3MgYXRlbnRvcyBhIGlzc28=

  4. Fernando disse:

    U2UgbWFudGVyZW0gYSBqdXJpc3BydWTqbmNpYSBvdSBubyBt7W5pbW8gbyBwcmVjZWRlbnRlIG8gc2VnbWVudG8gc2Vy4SBvIGRlIERpYXMgVG9mZm9saSBtYXMgY29tIEdpbG1hciwgTGV3YW5kb3dza2kgZSBDZWxzbyBkZSBNZWxsbyB0dWRvICBwb2RlIGFjb250ZWNlIGNvbnRyYSBvIHBh7XMgbWFzIGEgZmF2b3IgZG8gYmFuZGlkbyBMdWxhLg==

  5. mara disse:

    RGVjYWTqbmNpYSBkbyBTVEYgc2VyIHRvdGFsLCByZXZvZ2FyIGUgbWFuZGFyIHNvbHRhciB0b2RvcyBvcyBiYW5kaWRvcywgYy8gZGVzdGFxdWUgcCBvIGNvcnJ1cHRvIEx1bGEsIGRlc2VqbyBkYSBtYWlvcmlhIGRvcyBtaW5pc3Ryb3Mgc2VtIGVzY3L6cHVsb3MgZG8gU1RGLiBTb2NpZWRhZGUgYSBtZXJj6iBkZXNzZXMgaXJyZXNwb25z4XZlaQ==

  6. Laércio disse:

    UG9kZXLtYW1vcyBlc3RhciB0cmFucXVpbG9zLCB2aXN0byBxdWUgbHVsYSBq4SBmb2kgY29uZGVuYWRvIGVtIHRlcmNlaXJhIGluc3TibmNpYS4gTWFzLCBwb3LpbSwgdG9kYXZpYSwgY29udHVkbywgc2FiZSBu6SwgdGFsdmV6LCBwb2RlIHNlciwgLi4uLCBxdWUgcGFyYSB0aXJhciBsdWxhIGRhIGNhZGVpYSwgbyBzdGYgY29uc2lnYSB1bSBq

  7. Marga disse:

    Q2FkYSBkaWEgdGVtIG8gc2V1IG1hbC5Fc3NlIHBlc3NvYWwgY29udHLhcmlvIGEgMqogSW5zdOJuY2lhIHF1ZXIgcG9ycXVlIHF1ZXIgc29sdGFyIGFs6W0gZG8gbW9sdXNjbyBtYWlzIGRlIDE4MC4wMDAgcHJlc29zLkZpcXVlbW9zIGF0ZW50b3MgYSBlc3NhIDKqIFR1cm1hIGUgMyBkb3MgbWluaXN0cm9zIHJlaXRlcmFkb3MgaXJyZXNwb25z

  8. Putzzz... disse:

    ySBlc3RyYW5obyBxdWUgdGVudGVtIGpvZ2FyIGVzc2UgYXJndW1lbnRvIG51bSB0ZW1hIGrhIGNvbnNvbGlkYWRvIHBlbG8gc3RmLiBKdXJpc3BydWTqbmNpYSBjb20gcmVwZXJjdXNz428gZ2VyYWwhIERldmVyaWEgc2VyIHJlamVpdGFkbyBkZSBwbGFuby4=

  9. José disse:

    TuNvIGhhdmVy4SBwYXogbmEgTmHn428gZW5xdWFudG8gbyBTdXByZW1vIGNvbnRpbnVhciBhIHByb3RlZ2VyIG9zIGNyaW1pbm9zb3MhIFZhbW9zIGFzIHJ1YXMgZXhpZ2lyIG9yZGVtIGUgcmVzcGVpdG8gYXMgbGVpcyBkZW50cm8gZG8gU1RGLiBO428gaOEgc2HtZGEsIGFzIHJ1YXMh

  10. chrispiragibe@gmail. disse:

    M3gyIGRpZu1jaWwgZWxlcyBu428gZ2FuaGFyZW0sIG1hcyB1bWEgdmVyZ29uaGEuIEVzcGVybyBxIG8gb3V0cm8gcHJvY2Vzc28gc2VqYSBqdWxnYWRvIGxvZ28=

  11. Denon disse:

    UHJpc+NvIGRldmVyaWEgc2VyIGFw83MgYSBjb25kZW5h5+NvIG5hIDGqIGluc3TibmNpYS4gQXMgbWFub2JyYXMgZXNw+nJpYXMgcGFyYSBzb2x0YXIgbyBjb25kZW5hZG8gZGUgQ3VyaXRpYmEgdGVudGFtIHN1YnZlcnRlciBhIGxlaSBlIG8gYm9tLXNlbnNvLiA=

  12. Cacevo disse:

    Tm9zc29zIGp17XplcyBlIG1pbmlzdHJvcyBz428gY2Fzde1zdGljb3MuIERlcGVuZGVuZG8gZGEgc2l0dWHn428sIGludGVycHJldGFtIGEgbGVpIGRlIGFjb3Jkby4gU2VndXJhbudhIGp1cu1kaWNhPyBQcmEgcXXqPw==

  13. Érika disse:

    UXVhbCBzZXLhIG8gZW50ZW5kaW1lbnRvIGRlc3NhIHZleiA/

  14. Francesco disse:

    QSBmYXJzYSBjb250aW51YS4gySBjb21vIGFxdWVsYSBoaXN083JpYSBkbyBwb2xpY2lhbCBib20gZSBvIG1hdS4gQ2FybWVtIEz6Y2lhIGZpbmdlIHNlciBvIHBvbGljaWFsIGJvbS4gVGVtIG8gZW5jaW1hIGRvIG11cm8gZSB0cupzIG1hdSBtYXUuIA==

  15. Joseluiz disse:

    QSBzZWd1bmRhIHR1cm1hIGRvIFNURiDpIDWqIGluc3TibmNpYSBkbyBKdWRpY2nhcmlvIQ==

  16. Oseias disse:

    QSBzb3J0ZSBxdWUgYSBDYXJtZW4gTHVjaWEgZSByZWxhdG9yYSxlbGEudmFpIGNvemluaGEgaXNzbyBhdOkgLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4uLi4u

  17. Daisy disse:

    VG9mZm9saSBu428gc2Ugc2VudGly4SBuYWRhIGNvbnN0cmFuZ2lkbyBhIG1hbnRlciBhIGRlY2lz428gbPpjaWRhIHF1ZSB0b21vdSwgYWZpbmFsLCBq4SBtYW5kb3Ugc29sdGFyIEpvc+kgRGlyY2V1Lg==

  18. Nei disse:

    RXNzZSBuZWfzY2lvIGRlIHNlZ3VuZGEgaW5zdOJuY2lhIOkgc/MgdGVhdHJpbmhvLCBvIFNURiB0ZW50YW5kbyBtb3N0cmFyIG1vcmFsLi4uIGRldmFnYXJ6aW5obyB0b2RvcyBzZXLjbyBzb2x0b3MuIFZvbHRvIGEgaW5zaXN0aXI6IFBvcnF1ZSBvcyBqdWl6ZXMgdGVtIHRhbnRvIG1lZG8gZG8gbHVsYS4g

  19. Filemon disse:

    QWxlcnRhIEJyYXNpbCEgTyBNaW5pc3RybyBCYXJyb3NvIGRlY2xhcm91LCBlbSBOb3ZhIFlvcmssICBxdWU6ICJPcyBtaW5pc3Ryb3MgZG8gU1RGIHRlbSBtYWlzIHJhaXZhIGRlIFByb2N1cmFkb3JlcyBlIEp1aXplcyBkbyBxdWUgZGUgQ3JpbWlub3NvcyBxdWUgU2FxdWVhcmFtIG8gQnJhc2lsIiBWaXZhIGEgTGF2YSBKYXRvISAgU09TICBGRkFB

  20. Xavier disse:

    TyBxdWUgZXNwZXJhciBkZXNzZSBzdWplaXRvISEhISEh

  21. Paul disse:

    Rm9y52FzIGFybWFkYXMgYWJyYW0gb3Mgb2xob3MgY29udHJhIGVzc2VzIGp1ZGljaeFyaW8gcHJvdGV0b3JlcyBkZSBiYW5kaWRvcyBlIGNyaW1pbm9zb3Mu

  22. Edson disse:

    VG9mZm9saSBkZXZlIHR1ZG8gYW8gUFQuLi4gdW1hIGhvcmEgb3Ugb3V0cmEgdmFpIG1vc3RyYXIgaXN0by4=

  23. PetralhasNaCadeia disse:

    VuNvIHNvbHRhciAxNjAgbWlsIGFzc2Fzc2lub3MsIGxhZHL1ZXMsIGVzdHVwcmFkb3JlcywgcGVk82ZpbG9zIGUgdG9kbyB0aXBvIGRlIGVzY/NyaWEsIHPzIHBhcmEgc29sdGFyIG8gcGF0cuNvLg==

    1. RWggdHVkbyBxdWUgYSBlc3F1ZXJkYSBxdWVyLi4uIGFudGVzIG5vc3NhIGVzcXVlcmRhIGZvc3NlIGFwZW5hcyB1bSBiYW5kbyBkZSBjb211bmlzdGFzLiBPIHF1ZSB0ZW1vcyBhcXVpIHNhbyB1bSBiYW5kbyBkZSBhbG9wcmFkb3MgYnVzY2FuZG8gbyBjYW9zIGRvIG5vc3NvIHBh7XMuIA==