Proibição das conduções coercitivas ‘incentiva a impunidade’, diz promotor

A proibição das conduções coercitivas pelo Supremo Tribunal Federal incentiva à impunidade, no entender do promotor de Justiça do Distrito Federal Renato Varalda.

“[A decisão] foi um retrocesso e incentiva à impunidade em um país marcado por violência diária e corrupção.”

Para o promotor — porta-voz do grupo que foi ao STF em abril pedir a manutenção da prisão na segunda instância –, “a interpretação da Constituição se faz por meio da ponderação de valores e cabe, sim, ao STF dar prevalência a princípios que salvaguardem o cidadão de uma vida digna”.

“Como todos os princípios constitucionais são relativos, a segurança e o direito à vida preponderam sobre a presunção de inocência.”

Varalda lembra que o próprio Código de Processo Penal previa a condução coercitiva “para dar eficácia à verdade real durante a busca das provas”.

“Além disso, a condução coercitiva não viola o direito a não auto-incriminação, diante da possibilidade de permanecer calado ou negar os fatos ilícitos imputados.”

Deixe seu comentário

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site; a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem;
Tempo de publicação: 4 minutos

200

  1. Míriam disse:

    UGFyYSBvIFNURiBvIGNpZGFk428gY29tdW0gcXVlLCBhbGnhcywgcGFnYSBvcyBzYWzhcmlvcyBkb3MgbWluaXN0cm9zIGUgc2Vydmlkb3JlcyBu428gbWVyZWNlIG8gbWVzbW8gYXByZedvIHF1ZSBvcyBnYXR1bm9zIGRlIGRpbmhlaXJvIHD6YmxpY28=

Ler comentários
  1. Lauro disse:

    TyBzZWlzIHF1ZSB2b3RhcmFtIGNvbnRyYSBhIGNvbmR15+NvIGNvZXJjaXRpdmEsIHByZWNpc2FtIHZvbHRhciBhb3MgYmFuY29zIGVzY29sYXJlcywgc2UgbuNvIGZvaSBwb3IgZmFsdGEgZGUgY29uaGVjaW1lbnRvIGxlZ2FsLCBmaWNhIGEgc3VzcGVpdGEgZGUgcXVlIGZvaSBwb3IgbW90aXZvcyBlc2N1c29zLg==

  2. disse:

    UGVyZ3VudGFyIG7jbyBvZmVuZGU6IE1hcyBlc3NlIG7jbyDpIG8gZ3JhbmRlIG9iamV0aXZvIGRvIHBh7XMgLSBpbmNlbnRpdmFyIGEgaW1wdW5pZGFkZT8gUXVhbCDpIG8gYXNzdW50byBlbSBkaXNjdXNz428/IEVzc2UgauEgZXN04SByZXNvbHZpZG8gLi4uIGUgZXUgbuNvIGVzdG91IGZhemVuZG8gcGlhZGEu

  3. Krer disse:

    QW5vIGRlIGVsZWnn428gZSBpc3RvIOkgcmVhbDogTHVsYSBlc3ThIG5hIGNhZGVpYSEgTHVsYSBlc3ThIG5hIGNhZGVpYSEgDQpMdWxhIGVzdOEgbmEgY2FkZWlhIUx1bGEgZXN04SBuYSBjYWRlaWEhIEx1bGEgZXN04SBuYSBjYWRlaWEhIFNpbSDpIG11aXRvIHJlYWwh

  4. Kim disse:

    VW0gcHJvbW90b3IgcXVlIGRpeiBxdWUgdG9kb3Mgb3MgcHJpbmPtcGlvcyBjb25zdGl0dWNpb25haXMgc+NvIHJlbGF0aXZvcywgbuNvIOkgdW0gcHJvbW90b3Ig6SBz8yB1bSBtZXIuZGEuIA0KUXVlIHZlcmdvbmhhISANCkUgZXN0ZSBibG9nIHNlZ3VlIGFtcGxpZmljYW5kbyBpZGlvdGFzLiANClF1ZSB2ZXJnb25oYSE=

  5. SPA disse:

    QSBlc3RyYXTpZ2lhIGRvcyBTRUlTIHF1ZSB2b3RhcmFtIENPTlRSQSDpIGEgc2VndWludGUgOiBGVUdJUiBEQSBIVU1JTEhBx8NPIC4gSW1hZ2luZW0gdm9j6nMgLCAgbnVtIGZ1dHVybyBwcvN4aW1vICwgdW0gR2lsbWFyIGRlc3NlcyBzZW5kbyBjb25kdXppZG8gcC8gZGFyIGV4cGxpY2Hn9WVzIGFvIGp1aXogQnJldGFzID8=

  6. Lenha disse:

    U2Ugb3MgbWVtYnJvcyBkYSBsYXZhIGphdG8gdGl2ZXNzZW0gY3VtcHJpZG8gbyBxdWUgZXN0YWJlbGVjaWEgbyBhcnQuIDI2MCBkbyBDUFAgbmEg7W50ZWdyYSwgZXNzZSB0ZW1hIG5lbSB0ZXJpYSBjaGVnYWRvIGFvIFNURiEgTuNvIGFkaWFudGEgY2hvcm8sIOkgcHJlY2lzbyBtYWlzIHJlZmxleONvIGUgcmVzcGVpdG8g4HMgbGVpcyEgUHJpbWVpcm8gaW50aW1hLXNlIGUgc2UgZGVzY3VtcHJpZG8gYSBvcmRlbSwgZGVjcmV0YSBhIGNvZXJjaXRpdmEuIHBvbnRvLiBBZ29yYSBuZW0gaXNzbyE=

  7. Paulistano disse:

    RmFzY2lzbW8gY29tZedvdSBhc3NpbSAhIFRvZG9zIHPjbyBjdWxwYWRvcyBhbnRlcyBkZSBzZSBwcm92YXIgYSBjdWxwYSAhIE8gQnJhc2lsIHVtIHBh7XMgcXVlIHByZWNpc2EgZGUgZGVzcGFjaGFudGVzIHBhcmEgZHJpYmxhciBvcyBBc3BvbmVzIGRhcyByZXBhcnRp5/VlcyBw+mJsaWNhcyBlIGEgYnVyb2NyYWNpYSBlc3RhdGFsIGluZmVybmFsIHF1ZXIgbyBxdWU/IEJ1cm9jcmFjaWEgZXN0YXRhbCArIEFzcG9uZXMgPSBjb3JydXDn428gISBTaW1wbGVzIGFzc2ltICEgUmVkdXphbSBvIHRhbWFuaG8gZG8gRXN0YWRvICE=

  8. Edu disse:

    TyBleGNlc3NvIGRlICJkaXJlaXRvcyIgZSAiZ2FyYW50aWFzIiBlc3ThIHRyYW5zZm9ybWFuZG8gbyBCcmFzaWwgbnVtIHBh7XMgcGlvci4NCkVucXVhbnRvIGlzc28sIGV4cGxvZGUgb3Mg7W5kaWNlcyBkZSBjcmltaW5hbGlkYWRlIGUgY29ycnVw5+NvLg0KQXMgcGVzc29hcyBkZSBiZW0gZmljYW0gaG9ycm9yaXphZGFzIGUgYWN1YWRhcyBlIG9zIGRlbGlucXVlbnRlcyBhdGFjYW0gZGUgcXVhbHF1ZXIgZm9ybWE6IOAgcOksIGRlIGJpY2ljbGV0YSwgZGUgbGFtYnJldGEsIGRlIFRyYXgsIGRlIGNhcnJvLg==

  9. Celular disse:

    TnVtIHBh7XMgcXVlIG8gUHJlc2lkaeFyaW8gY29tZW50YSBmdXRlYm9sLCBvIHByZXNpZGnhcmlvIHVzYSBjZWx1bGFyIGUgY29tYW5kYSBvIGNyaW1lIGRhIGNhc2RlaWE/IEZyYW5jYW1lbnRlIHZhbW9zIGJvdGFyIG9yZGVtIG5vIGdhbGluaGVpcm8gISBGYXNjaXNtbyBxdWVyZW0gaW1wbGFudGFyIG8gZmFzY2lzbW8gcGFyYSBxdWVtIGVzdOEgZm9yYSBkb3MgcHJlc+1kaW9zICwgbWFzIGRlbnRybyBkb3MgcHJlc+1kaW9zIG8gY3JpbWUgY29tcGVuc2EgLCB0ZW0gYXTpIGJvbHNhIHByZXNpZGnhcmlvICFIaXBvY3Jpc2lh

  10. Enterraram disse:

    U2UgcHJlY2lzYSBkZSBjb2VyY2l2YSwg6SBxdWUg6SBjcmltaW5vc28tYmFuZGlkbywgb3MgdG9nYWRvcyBz428gY29udHJhICwgcG9pcyBu428gcXVlcmVtIGRvcm1pciBudW4gc3Vwb3N0byBjb2xjaONvIHByb2RpemRvIG5vIFNURi4=

  11. Marcelo disse:

    T3MgbWluaXN0cm9zIGRvIFNURiBz428gb3MgY2hlZmVzIGRhIGNvcnJ1cOfjbyBubyBCcmFzaWwgLCB2Y3MgYWNoYW0gcXVlIGVsZXMgaWFtIGRhciB1bWEgZGVjaXPjbyBjb250cmEgYSBxdWFkcmlsaGEgcXVlIGVsZXMgY29tYW5kYW0/

  12. Sergio disse:

    RXN0ZSBwcm9tb3RvciBkaXNzZSBvIPNidmlvLiBBZmluYWwsIGVzdOEgY2xhcm8gcXVlIG8gU1RGIGFnZSBjb21vIHVtYSBlc3DpY2llIGRlICJBZHZvY2FjaWEgZG8gUGxhbmFsdG8gZSBkbyBDb25ncmVzc28iLCBhIGFtcGFyYXIgZGUgYSBkZWZlbmRlciBhIGdhbmd1ZSBxdWUgaGFiaXRhIGEgUHJh52EgZG9zIFRy6nMgUG9kZXJlcy4gRW5maW0sIG8gU1RGIHNlIGFwZXF1ZW5vdSBjb21vIHVtICJwdXhhZGluaG8iIGRvcyBwb2ztdGljb3M7IG1lbm9zIG1vcmFsIGRvIHF1ZSBhcyBpbnN04m5jaWFzIGluZmVyaW9yZXMuLi4=

  13. O disse:

    buNvIG1leGFtIG5vcyBiZW5lZu1jaW9zIHF1ZSBldSBsaWJlcm8gYSBjb3JydXDn428=

  14. QUE disse:

    SVNUTyBRVUUgRMEgVU1BIE9SQ1JJTSBQUk9URUdJREEgUE9SIEFMR1VOUyBHRU5FUkFJUy4uLg==

  15. Inevitável. disse:

    RXN0YW1vcyBubyBCcmFzaWx6ZWNvLiBOZW5odW0gZG9zIHBvZGVyZXMgbWVyZWNlIG8gcmVzcGVpdG8gZG8gcG92bywgcG9pcywgIGVzdONvIHRvbWFkb3MgcG9yIGJhbmRpZG9zLiBFIHF1ZW0gZGV2ZXJpYSBlc3RhciB6ZWxhbmRvIHBvciBub3MsIGVzdOEgbWFpcyBpbnRlcmVzc2FkbyBlbSBjYXZpYXIsIGNhbWFy428gZSB2aW5obyBmcmFuY+pzLiBDaGVnYXLhIGEgaG9yYSBlbSAgYSBsdXRhIGRvIHBvdm8gIGNvbnRyYSB0b2RvcyBlc3RlcyBiYW5kaWRvcyBpbmNvbnNlcfxlbnRlcyBzZXLhIGluZXZpdOF2ZWwu

  16. Paulo disse:

    RXN0YSBkZWNpc+NvIGRvcyA2IGRvIFNURiBkZW1vbnN0cmEgbyBxdWFudG8gc+NvIGxlbmllbnRlcyBjb20gb3MgZ2Vub2NpZGFzIGRlIGNvbGFyaW5obyBicmFuY28sIGRvIHF1YWwgcGFzc2FtIHBhcmEgYSBzb2NpZWRhZGUgbyBxdeNvIGRpc3RhbnRlcyBlc3TjbyBkYSBhdXN0ZXJpZGFkZSBwYXJhIHNlIHF1ZWJyYXIgZXNzYSBjb3JydXDn428gc2lzdOptaWNhIGUgaW5zdGl0de1kYSBwb3IgdW1hIGNvcmphIHF1ZSBu428gY2Vzc2EgYSB2b2z6cGlhIGRlIGFzc2FsdGFyIG8gZXLhcmlvLiAgUGFyYWLpbnMgU1RGLg==

  17. Assoite disse:

    Q29tbyB0b2RvcyBzYWJlbSBhIGltcHVuaWRhZGUgc2UgYWxpbWVudGEgZGFzIGRlY2lz9WVzIGRvIFNURiwg6SBvIGJlcudvIGRhIGNvcnJ1cOfjbyBlIGRhIGltcHVuaWRhZGUgbmVzc2UgcGHtcy4gUGFyYSBkZWZlbmRlciBvcyBwb2Rlcm9zb3MgZWxlcyBzZSBsaXhhbSBwYXJhIG8gcmVzdG8gZG8gcGHtcywgcHJlY2lzYW1vcyBkZSB1bWEgcmVmb3JtdWxh5+NvICwgbm8gY29ycG8gZGUgbWluaXN0cm9zIGUgbmEgZm9ybWEgZGUgc3VhIGluZGljYefjby4=

  18. Cris disse:

    UmV0cm9jZXNzbyBkZSA4MCBhbm9zLi4uDQpHb3Zlcm5vIFRlbWVyICxvIEJyYXNpbCB2b2x0b3UgODAgYW5vcyBlbSAyLi4u

  19. Niina disse:

    RXNwZXJvIHZlciBvIFNURiBzZXIgc29sYXBhZG8sIG5lbSBxdWUgbyBwcmXnbyBzZWphIG8gcmV0b3JubyBkb3MgbWlsaXRhcmVzIG5vIHBvZGVyLiBQb3JxdWUgYW9zIHBvdWNvcywgZXNzZXMgbWluaXN0cm9zIGNyaW1pbm9zb3MgZSBkaXRhZG9yZXMgZXN0428gam9nYW5kbyBvIHBh7XMgbmFzIG3jb3MgZG9zIGJhbmRpZG9zIGUgZGl6aW1hbmRvIG8gdHJhYmFsaG8g4XJkdW8gZGEgbGF2YSBqYXRvLiBOdW5jYSB2YW1vcyBjb25zZWd1aXIgdmVuY2VyIGEgY29ycnVw5+NvLCBjb20gbyBTVEYgbGVnaXNsYW5kbyBjb250cmEu

    1. TmlpbmEsIHZvY+ogZXN04SBjZXJ07XNzaW1hLCBjYWRhIGRpYSBxdWUgcGFzc2EgbyBzZW50aW1lbnRvIOkgZXNzZSwgZXN0428ganVkaWNpYWxpemFuZG8gYSBmYXZvciBkZSB1bWEgaG9yZGEgZGUgYmFuZGlkb3MgcXVlIGVzdONvIG1hc3NhY3JhbmRvIGEgcG9wdWxh5+NvLiAgQSB0ZW50YXRpdmEgZGUgZGVzdHJ1aXIgYSBMYXZhIEphdG8g6SBjbGFyYSBlIG9iamV0aXZhLCBhY2hvIHF1ZSBwYXJhIGdhcmFudGlyIGEgbGVpIGUgYSBvcmRlbSBob2plLCBz8yBjb20gb3MgbWlsaXRhcmVzLg==

  20. Nathan disse:

    T3V2aWRvcyBtb3VjbyBkZSBqde16ZXMgbG91Y29zISAjQUJBTsJOSUHJVU1MSVhPIQ==

  21. Um disse:

    Q0VSVM1TU0lNTyBPIFBST0NVUkFET1IuIEUgRVNURSBURU0gU0lETyBPIFBBUEVMIERPIFNURi4gQUNBQkFSIENPTSBPINpMVElNTyBSRVNRVc1DSU8gREUgUFVOScfDTyBQQVJBIE9TIFJJQ09TIEUgUE9ERVJPU09TLiBBVMkgUE9SUVVFIFBPQlJFIEUgUFJFVE8gSsEgTsNPIFVTVUZSVUlBIERFU1RBIEpVU1RJx0EuIEVMRVMgVEVNIERBRE9TIFBBU1NPUyBMQVJHT1MgTkVTU0UgU0VOVElETy4gRSBERUZFTkRFTSBDT00gQSBNQUlPUiBDQVJBIERFIFBBVSBETyBNVU5ETy4gVkVSR09OSEEu

  22. MAIS disse:

    YXMgYXV0b3JpZGFkZXMgdGVy428gcXVlIGFndWFyZGFyIG8gaW52ZXN0aWdhZG8gc2UgZGVpeGFyIHNlciBlbmNvbnRyYWRvIHBhcmEgcXVlIGEgaW50aW1h5+NvIHNlamEgY29uc3VtYWRhLg0KRSBtYWlzOiBpbnZlc3RpZ2Fkb3MgdGVy428gYmFzdGFudGUgdGVtcG8gZGlzcG9u7XZlbCBwYXJhIGRlc3RydWlyIG91IGVzY29uZGVyIHByb3ZhcywgaW50aW1pZGFyIHRlc3RlbXVuaGFzIGUgY29tYmluYXIgZGVwb2ltZW50b3MgY29tIHNldXMgInBhcmNlaXJvcyIuDQrJIG8gSnVkaWNp4XJpbyBjb250cmEgYSBKdXN0aedhLg==

    1. U9MgUVVFIE8gUVVFIEVTU0VTICIgTUlOSVNUUk9TICIgQ09WQVJERVMgUVVFUkVNIMkgRVZJVEFSIFFVRSBBTEdVyU0gUFJPVkUgQUxHVU5IQSBDT0lTQSBDT05UUkEgRVNTRVMgQ09SUlVQVE9TLi4=

  23. Gilmar disse:

    U9MgUVVFIE8gUVVFIEVTU0VTICIgTUlOSVNUUk9TICIgUVVFUkVNIMkgRVZJVEFSIFFVRSBBTEdVyU0gUFJPVkEgQUxHVU5IQSBDT0lTQSBDT05UUkEgRVNTRVMgQ09SUlVQVE9TLi4=

  24. analu disse:

    RmljYSBjYWRhIGRpYSBtYWlzIGNsYXJvIHF1ZSBtZWlhIGT6emlhIGRlIG1pbmlzdHJvcyBkbyBTVEYgYWR2b2dhIHBhcmEgYmFuZGlkb3MuIFNpbXBsZXMgYXNzaW0uIA==

  25. Anônimo disse:

    RSBkZXBvaXMgcmVjbGFtYW0sIHF1YW5kbyBhIGdlbnRlIHBlZGUgaW50ZXJ2ZW7n428gbWlsaXRhci4gQXMgaW5zdGl0dWnn9WVzLCB0ZW9yaWNhbWVudGUgc2FsdmFndWFyZGFzIGRhIGxlZ2FsaWRhZGUsIGVzdONvIGNvcnJvbXBpZGFzLCBjb3Jyb+1kYXMgZSBwb2RyZXMuIEVudONvLCBvIHF1ZSBvcyBtaWxpdGFyZXMgZXN0428gZXNwZXJhbmRvPyBQZXJkZW0gbyB0aW1pbmcsIGFzc2ltLg==