Torquato: “Escolher a quem perdoar ou punir é retorno ao arbítrio”

Torquato Jardim, em coletiva há pouco para tentar explicar o indulto natalino, elencou seis “crimes principais no Estado moderno”: combate às drogas; ao tráfico de armas; ao tráfico humano; aos crimes financeiros (incluindo lavagem de dinheiro e corrupção); aos crimes cibernéticos; e ao terrorismo.

“Às vezes esses crimes principais estão na mesma organização criminosa. Como priorizar um [crime] sobre outro? Essa que é a pergunta ética que os críticos não atentaram. Como hierarquizar esses seis [crimes] para dar preferência a um?”

O ministro da Justiça disse que “a personalização do indulto e a busca de resultado concreto antecipado é incompatível com o Estado Democrático de Direito”.

“Isso é passado no Brasil. Escolher a quem perdoar ou punir antecipadamente é retorno ao arbítrio.”

Deixe seu comentário

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site; a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem;
Tempo de publicação: 4 minutos

200

  1. Nelson disse:

    Q29ycnVwdG9zIGRldmVyaWFtIHRlciBwdW5p5+NvIHByZWZlcmVuY2lhbC4=

Ler comentários
  1. PIETRO disse:

    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

  2. grilo disse:

    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

  3. Sergio disse:

    TyB0aW1lOiBTZWdveWEsIFRvcnF1YXRvLCBUZW1lciwgR2lsbWFyLCBTYXJuZXksIFJlbmFuLCBKdWNhLCBHbGVpc3kuLi4gVW1hIHNlbGXn428gdG9wIGNvbnRyYSBhIGxhdmEgamF0byBlIGV47W1pYSBlbSBwcm92ZXIgaW1wdW5pZGFkZS4=

  4. Carlos disse:

    SW5jb21wYXTtdmVsIGNvbSBvIEVzdGFkbyBEZW1vY3LhdGljbyBlIGRlIERpcmVpdG8g6SBvIGluZHVsdG8uIEJhbmRpZG8ganVsZ2FkbyBlIGNvbmRlbmFkbyB0ZW0gcXVlIGN1bXByaXIgYSBwZW5hIGF06SBvIPpsdGltbyBzZWd1bmRvIGUgZGUgcHJlZmVy6m5jaWEgY29tZedhbmRvIGrhIG5hIHByaW1laXJhIGNvbmRlbmHn428uIFF1ZSBvIGRlbGlucXVlbnRlIHJlY29ycmEgYXRyYXMgZGFzIGdyYWRlcy4=

  5. b.f.a.k. disse:

    Lg0KIiIiICIiIiAiIiIgLi4uIC4uLiAuLi4gbGF2YWdlbSBkZSBkaW5oZWlybyBlIGNvcnJ1cOfjbyAuLi4gLi4uIC4uLiAiIiIgIiIiICIiIg0KLg0KJ2luZHVsdG8nIGQuaS5yLmkuZy5pLmQubywgb3Ugc2VqYSwNCnNhZmFkZXphLCBkZXNmYedhdGV6LCBjYW5hbGhpY2UsDQphZm9yYSBhIEMuTy5OLkkuVi7KLk4uQy5JLkEgISEhICEhISAhISENCi4NCmEgQy5PLk4uSS5WLsouTi5DLkkuQSAhISEgISEhICEhIQ0KYSBDLk8uTi5JLlYuyi5OLkMuSS5BICEhISAhISEgISEhDQphIEMuTy5OLkkuVi7KLk4uQy5JLkEgISEhICEhISAhISE=

  6. Leonardo disse:

    RGFxdWkgYSBwb3VjbyB2428ganVzdGlmaWNhciBlc3NlIHRhbCBkZSBFc3RhZG8gRGVtb2Ny4XRpY28gZGUgRGlyZWl0byBwcmEgbWV0ZXIgdW1hIGJhbGEgbmEgbm9zc2EgY2FyYS4=

  7. Rogério disse:

    QXTpIHBhcmVjZSBxdWUgZWxlcyBu428gZXNjb2xoZXJhbSBvcyBiZW5lZu1jaW9zIHNlZ3VuZG9zIG9zIGJlbmVmaWNpYWRvcy4uLi4ubG9yb3RhIGVzc2EgZGUgcXVlIGZvcmFtIGlzZW50b3MuLi4uZm9yYW0gaXNlbnRvcyBkZSBob25lc3RpZGFkZS4uLi5jYW1iYWRhIGRlIG1hbGZlaXRvcmVzIGJlbmVmaWNpYW5kbyBtYWxmZWl0b3Jlcy4=

  8. PIETRO disse:

    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

  9. Até disse:

    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

  10. Gustavo disse:

    TWFpcyB5bSBlc3R1cG9yIHNvY2lzbGlzdGEgbWVudGluZG8gZGVzY2FyYWRhbWVudGUuIEVzY29saGVyIGEgcXVlbSBwZXJkb2FyIGUgYSBxdWVtIHB1bmlyICDpIGV4YXRhbWVudGUgbyBxdWUgb2NvcnJlIGhvamUgZW0gZGlhLiBQb2JyZSBCcmFzaWwu

  11. Beto disse:

    P0VzY29saGVyIGEgcXVlbSBwZXJkb2FyIG91IHB1bmlyIOkgcmV0b3JubyBhbyBhcmLtdHJpbz86IEVudONvLi4uUGVyZG9hIHRvZG8gbXVuZG8uIEltYmVjaWwu

  12. Ricardo disse:

    UHJhIGNhbGFyIGEgYm9jYSBkbyBUb3JxdWF0bywgbmluZ3XpbSBuYSBlbnRyZXZpc3RhIGNvbGV0aXZhIGNpdG91IGEgcHJpc+NvIGRvIE1hcmluIG5vcyBVU0E/IGVzdGEgdHVybWEgZGUgam9ybmFsaXN0YXMg6SB1bSBsaXhvLi4uLg==

  13. MARCO disse:

    TyBSSU8gR1JBTkRFIERPIE5PUlRFIE8gRVNQRVJBIERFIEJSQcdPUyBBQkVSVE9TLCBNSU5JU1RSTy4NCkzBIE9TIElORFVMVEFET1MgRkFSw08gQVMgRkVTVEFTIERFIE5BVEFMIEUgRklNIERFIEFOTyBFTlFVQU5UTyBPIFBPVk8gRklDQVLBIFRSQU5DQURPIEVNIENBU0EgUkVaQU5ETyAgLiAuIC4gIEVTU0UgySBPIFZFUkRBREVJUk8gRVNQzVJJVE8gREUgUE9SQ08gTkFUQUxJTk8gLCBOySBNSU5JU1RSTz8hPyE/ISEv

  14. Rita disse:

    RXNzZSBpbnN1bHRvIGRlIE5hdGFsIGRldmUgdGVyIHNpZG8gY3JpYWRvIHBhcmEgc29sdGFyIG9zIGdyYW5kZXMgbm8gbWVpbyBkb3MgcGVxdWVub3Mgc2VtIGRhciBtdWl0byBuYSB2aXN0YS4gU/MgcXVlIG9zIHRlbXBvcyBtdWRhcmFtIGUgaG9qZSBlbnRlbmRlbW9zIHRvZGEgYSAicHJvYmxlbeF0aWNhIHBvciB0cuFzIGRhICJzb2x1Y2lvbmF0aWNhIi4=

  15. Belzebunda disse:

    TyBtaW5pc3RybyBkYSBqdXN0aedhIGVzdOEgY29tIG8gc2V1IGF0ZXN0YWRvIGRlIHNh+mRlIG1lbnRhbCBlbSBkaWE/

  16. Brasil disse:

    RHV2aWRvIHF1ZSB1bSBKYWlyIEJvbHNvbmFybyBkYSB2aWRhIGNvbW8gcHJlc2lkZW50ZSBhc3NpbmFzc2UgdW1hIGNvaXNhIGRlc3Nhcy4uLg==

  17. População disse:

    ySBhIHByb2NsYW1h5+NvIGRhIGRlc29yZGVtIHRvdGFsIHByb21vdmlkYSBwZWxvIHBy83ByaW8gZ292ZXJubyEhIEV1IHF1ZSBlcmEgY29udHJhIGEgaW50ZXJ2ZW7n428gbWlsaXRhciwgc/MgbWUgcGVyZ3VudG8gb25kZSBlc3TjbyBhcyBGRkFBPyANClByZWNpc2Ftb3Mgbm9zIGRlZmVuZGVyIGRhIGJhbmRpZGFnZW0gc29sdGEgZSBu428gdGVtb3MgYXJtYXMuLi4gYSBWZW5lenVlbGEg6SBhcXVpISE=

  18. jose disse:

    Q29tIGVzc2Ugbm9tZSwgbyBxdWUgc2UgcG9kZSBlc3BlcmFyID8gRSBvIG5vbWUgZG8gY2hlZmUgZGVsZSAgdGFtYultICDpIHN1Z2VzdGl2byAuLg==