“Um tribunal que não se respeita perde a legitimação democrática”

Luiz Fux disse que pode se instaurar a desobediência civil caso o STF mude a regra sobre as prisões em segunda instância.

O Globo reproduziu seu discurso no TJ do Rio de Janeiro:

“O que eu disse nesse julgamento recente é que não tem sentido que um ano e meio depois se possa mudar a jurisprudência, porque a jurisprudência é um argumento da autoridade. E para se ter autoridade tem que se ter respeito. E um tribunal, para gerar respeito junto à cidadania, tem que se respeitar. Um tribunal que não se respeita, ele perde a sua legitimação democrática. No momento em que um tribunal superior perde sua legitimação democrática, ele perde o respeito e se instaura a desobediência civil.”

Deixe seu comentário

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site; a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem. Em respeito a todos os leitores, não são publicados comentários que contenham palavras ou conteúdos ofensivos.
Tempo de publicação: 4 minutos

200

  1. luizs disse:

    UGVyZmVpdG8uIFF1YWxxdWVyIGJhbmRpZG8gdGVy4SBkaXJlaXRvIGEgYXBlbGFyIHBhcmEgbyBzdGYuDQpBIHZhbnRhZ2VtIGRhIG7jbyBwcmlz428gYXDzcyBzZWd1bmRhIGluc3TibmNpYSwg6SBxdWUgbm9zc2FzIGNhZGVpYXMsIENEUHMsIHBlbml0ZW5jaeFyaWFzLCBldGMsIHNlcuNvIGVzdmF6aWFkYXMu

Ler comentários
  1. Sergio disse:

    TyBCcmFzaWwgauEgdml2ZSBlbSBwbGVuYSBkZXNvYmVkaepuY2lhIHBhbGFjaWFuYS4=

  2. Giovana disse:

    UEFSQULJTlMgRHIuIEZ1eC4gVm9zc2EgRXhjZWzqbmNpYSBmYXogcGFydGUgZGEgbWVpYSBk+nppYSBxdWUgcHJlc3RhIGRlbnRybyBkYXF1ZWxlIFRyaWJ1bmFsLg==

  3. Consultor disse:

    VGFvIHRvZG9zIGVsZXMgYWdvcmEgY29tIG8ga3UgbmEgbWFvLG5lP08gY2xhbW9yIGRvIHBvdm8sZGFzIGZmYWEsZG9zIGp1cmlzdGFzIGRlIHZlcmRhZGUuLi50b2RvIG11bmRvIHF1ZXJlbmRvIGFjYWJhciBjb20gZXNzYSBlc2NyZXNjZW5jaWEgYm9saXZhcmlhbmEuQ29tZWNlbSBhcHJvdmFuZG8gbyBpbXBlZGltZW50byBkbyBtYWlzIGJhbmRpZG8gZSBzZW0tdmVyZ29uaGEgZGEgdHVybWEsbyBiZWljb2xhLGRlcG9pcyBzZSBuYW8gc2UgYWplaXRhcmVtIHBlZ3VlbSBvIGJvY2EtZGUtb3ZvLG8gd2lza3kgZSBvIGJhbGluaGFzLlRlbSBxICBjb21lY2FyIGEgbGF2YS10b2dhLGZhbGEscGFsb2NjaS4uLg==

  4. Marcos disse:

    RGUgY2FyYSwgMyBhbGkgcHJlc2lzYW0gc2VyIGV4dGlycGFkb3MsIHBvaXMgbuNvIGNvbmRpemVtIGFvIGNhcmdvIHF1ZSBvY3VwYW0gZSB0ZXJnaXZlcnNhbSBlbSBzdWFzIHRlc2VzIGFic3RyYXRhcywgbXVpdGFzIGRhcyB2ZXplcyBzZW0gcXVhaXNxdWVyIHNlbnRpZG8uLi4gVG9mb2xsaSwgTGV3YW5kb3dpc2t5IGUgR2lsbWFyLCBlc3NlcyBwZXJkZXJhbSBvIHNlbnRpZG8gZGEganVyaWNhdHVyYS4gTUFNIGZhbGEgYm9uaXRvLCBtYXMgdOEgZXNjbGVyb3NhZG8gZSBkZXZlIHNlciBzdWJzdGl0de1kbyBwb3IgdW0gcXVlIG7jbyBzZWphIHRlcnJvcmlzdGEganVy7WRpY28u

  5. Hell disse:

    Q0xBUCxDTEFQLENMQVAsQ0xBUCAgbXVpdG8gYm9tIE1pbmlzdHJvIEZVWC4=

  6. Mind disse:

    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

  7. Claudio disse:

    RGHtIHBhcmEgc2UgcGVnYXIgZW0gQVJNQSDpICB1bSBwdWxpbmhvIC4uLiBPIHF1ZSB2YWxlICDpICBvIHF1ZSBhIG1ham9yaXThcmlhICBtYWlvcmlhIGRhIHNvY2llZGFkZSBxdWVyIGUgbuNvIHVtYSBtZWlhIGT6emlhIGRlIHZpZ2FyaXN0YXMgY29ycnVwdG9zICAuLi4gTuNvICBxdWVyZW1vcyBtYWlzIGEgY29ycnVw5+NvICBlIHBvbnRvIGZpbmFsIC4uLiDJIGx1dGFyZW1vcyAgY29udHJhIG9zIGluaW1pZ29zICBkYSBw4XRyaWEgIGNvbSBBUk1BIGVtIHB1bmhvIHNlIGZvciBwcmVjaXNvLiAgTuNvIG5vcyBkb2JyYXJlbW9zIGEgZXN0ZXMgZ2FuZ3N0ZXIgc2FmYWRvcyAuLi4=

  8. Correto disse:

    RXJhIGV4YXRhbWVudGUgZXNzZSBvIGNhbWluaG8gcXVlIGVzdGF2YSBzZW5kbyB0cmlsaGFkbyBwZWxvIHRyaWJ1bmFsLg==

  9. Nasci disse:

    VGFvIHNhYmVuZG8gamEgcSBhIHNvY2llZGFkZSBkZWNlbnRlIHEgb3Mgc3VzdGVudGEgbmFvIHZhaSBhZ3VlbnRhciBtdWl0byB0ZW1wbyB0ZXIgMyBvdSA0IGNvcnJ1cHRvcyB2ZW5kaWRvcyBkZWNpZGluZG8gbyBkZXN0aW5vIGRlIDIwMCBtaWxob2VzLg==

  10. POR disse:

    UE9SIFFVRSBGVVggZSBvcyBvdXJsdHJvcyA3IE7DTyBERU5VTkNJQU0gQSBCQU5EQSBQT0RSRSBETyBTVEY/IEVsZXMgdOptIGVzc2EgcHJlcnJvZ2F0aXZhLCBu428/

  11. Ragnar disse:

    UG9pcyDpLCBkaXNzZSB0dWRvISEhIFRlbXBvcyBlc3RyYW5ob3MsIGp17XplcyBlc3RyYW5ob3MgbWV1IGNhcm8uLi4=

  12. Alex disse:

    UXVlIHJlc3BlaXRvIG8gU1RGIGFpbmRhIHRlbT8gVm9j6nMgc2UgbuNvIHNlIG1hbmNhcmVtIHbjbyDpIHNlciBwcmVzb3MgZSBjb25kZW5hZG9zIHBvciB0cmlidW5haXMgbWlsaXRhcmVzLg==

  13. pinguim disse:

    U2UgbyBTVEYgYXRyYXZlcyBkZSBtYW5vYnJhcyBkZSBtYWxhbmRyb3MgbmVsZSBpbmZpbHRyYWRvcyBjb25zZWd1aXIgcHJvaWJpciBwcmlz428gZW0gc2VndW5kYSBpbnN0YW5jaWEgbyBlbnRlbmRpbWVudG8gZ2VyYWwgc2Vy4SBxdWUg6SB0b3RhbG1lbnRlIHByb2liaWRvIGVtIHF1YWxxdWVyIGNpcmN1bnN0YW5jaWEgc2UgcHJlbmRlciBhbGd1ZW0gYW50ZXMgZG8gdHJhbnNpdGFkbyBlbSBqdWxnYWRvLiBTZXLhIG8gQ2Fvcy4=

  14. Guga disse:

    RnV4LCBvIHVuaWNvIGRvIFNURiBmYWl4YSBwcmV0YSBkZSBKaXVKaXRzdSBwZWxhIGZhbWlsaWEgR3JhY2llIQ==

  15. J disse:

    UVVFIElTU08gRklRVUUgQkVNIENMQVJPIFBBUkEgT1MgTEFDQUlPUyBBTU9SQUlTIERBIE9SQ1JJTSBRVUUgT0NVUEFNIE8gJFRGISBDSEVHQSBERSBGQVIkQSEgUVVFUkVNT1MgSlVTVEnHQSBERSBWRVJEQURFIE5PIEJSQVNJTCE=

  16. Nelson disse:

    SG9ucmVtIGFzIGNhbOdhcyAob3UgZnJhbGRhcyBnZXJp4XRyaWNhcykgcXVlIHZlc3RlbSAh

  17. JP disse:

    U2UgcGFsbnRhcmVtIGEgcmVncmEgZGEgc2VndW5kYSBpbnN04m5jaWEsIGNvbGhlcuNvIGRlc29iZWRp6m5jaWEgY2l2aWwuIEZhdG8u

  18. Mind disse:

    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

  19. PATRIOTA disse:

    UEVSRkVJVE8gU1VCU1RJVFVJTkRPIFRSylMgQkFORElET1MgREUgVE9HQSAgIiBUT0ZGT0xJICwgTEVXQU5ET1dTS0kgRSBPIENPTVBBUlNBIERFIEJBTkRJRE9TIEdJTE1BUiBNRU5ERVMgQSBDT0lTQSBURU5ERSBBIE5PUk1BTElEQURF

  20. If disse:

    VGVtIHVtIHBhcmFmdXNvIGVzcGFuYWRvIGFpIG5vcyBjb21lbnThcmlvcy4uLkEgbWluaXN0cmEgc3Vic3RpdHVpIG8gUHJlc2lkZW50ZSBUZW1lciBz8yBob2plIGUgYW1hbmjjLiBBbnRhZ29uaXN0YXMgbuNvIGRlaXhlIG8gcGFyYWZ1c28gZXNwYW5hZG8gZmljYXIgcmVwZXRpbmRvIGVzdGEgaW5mb3JtYefjbyBub3MgY29tZW504XJpb3MuLi4u

  21. GMG59 disse:

    UGFyYWLpbnMgTWluaXN0cm8gRnV4LCBtdWl0byBib20uIEJvbHNvbmFybyAyMDE4Lg==

  22. NOVA disse:

    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

  23. montezuma disse:

    QW8gaW526XMgZGUgInRlbXBvcyBlc3RyYW5ob3MiIHRlbW9zIHEgZGl6ZXI6ICIgdGVtcG9zIHBlcmlnb3Nvcy4uLiI=

  24. KID disse:

    TyBQb3ZvIGVudGVuZGV1IHN1YSAgZmFsYSAgY2xhcm8gPz8/PyAgRnV4IGRpc3NlIGFvIHBvdm8gOiBQb2RlbSAgc2UgbWFuaWZlc3RhciAsIHByb3Rlc3RhciwgcXVlIG5vcyBwcmVjaXNhbW9zIGRlIHZvY2VzICwgcG9pcyAgYXF1aSBkZW50cm8gZG8gIFNURiAgdmFyaW9zIG1pbmlzdHJvcyAgcGVkZXJhbSAgYSB2ZXJnb25oYS4=

  25. E disse:

    RGlzc28gb3MgY2lkYWTjb3Mgc2FiZW0sIG1pbmlzdHJvLiBBbGdvIG1haXMgYSBhY3Jlc2NlbnRhcj8=

  26. Joe disse:

    UXVlIG11ZGUtc2Ugb3MgbWluaXN0cm9zIHF1ZSBu428gcmVzcGVpdGFtIG8gdHJpYnVuYWwu

  27. Willian disse:

    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

  28. Mário disse:

    UGVyZmVpdG8uDQoNCkFxdWkgZGUgYmFpeG8gZGl6ZW1vcy4uLg0KTyByZXNwZWl0byB2ZW0gZGUgY2ltYSE=

  29. Aedes disse:

    Q2FyYWNhISBVbSBtaW5pc3RybyBiaWT6ISBO428gcHJlY2lzYSBzZXIgdW0gRWluc3RlaW4gcGFyYSBzYWNhciBxdWUgdW1hIHBvcHVsYefjbyBkZSBjZXJjYSBkZSAyMDAgbWlsaPVlcyBwb2RlIHBhcnRpciBwYXJhIG8gZXN0b3VybyBkYSBib2lhZGEsIHNlIHNlbnRpciBxdWUg6SBjYWRhIHVtIHBvciBzaSBlIGRldXMgcG9yIHRvZG9zLi4uIERlcG9pcywgcGFyYSBhcnJlYmFuaGFyIG8sIGRlc2N1bHBlLCBnYWRvIHRhbHZleiB0ZW5oYW1vcyBtZXNtbyBkZSBjaGFtYXIgbyBtaWxpY28u

  30. cleuber disse:

    QWdvcmEgZW50ZW5kaS4gTyBjZWxzbyBkZSBtZWxsbyBz8yB2b2x0b3UgcGFyYSBvIHBhbG9jY2kgY29udGludWFyIHByZXNvLCBwb3JxdWUgZXN0ZSBu428gZGV2b2x2ZXUgbyBkaW5oZWlybywgYXNzaW0gY29tbyBvIEJlbmRpbmkuIE8gbWluaXN0cm8gY29udGludWEgY29udHJhIGEgcHJpc+NvIGRlIDJhLiBpbnN04m5jaWEuIE7jbyBkZXZlbW9zIHJlbGF4YXIu

  31. Guerreiro disse:

    UGFyYWLpbnMgTWluaXN0cm8gTHVpeiBGdXggcG9yIGRpemVyIGEgcHVyYSB2ZXJkYWRlLCBlbnRyZXRhbnRvIGFjaG8gICBxdWUgbyBwcm9udW5jaWFtZW50byBmZWl0byBWLkV4Y2lhLiBubyBUSiBkbyBSaW8gZGUgIEphbmVpcm8sIGRldmVyaWEgdGVyIHNpZG8gcHJvZmVyaWRvICBubyBwbGVu4XJpbyBTVEYsIGVtIEJyYXPtbGlhLCBhc3NpbSBjb21vIHRlbSBmZWl0bywgcG9yIGRpdmVyc2FzIHZlemVzLCAgbyBNaW5pc3RybyBMdWlzIFJvYmVydG8gQmFycm9zby4gU2VpIHF1ZSBu428g6SBm4WNpbCBlbmZyZW50YXIgZG9pcyBwc2ljb3BhdGFzIGNvbW8gR2lsbWFyIE1lbmRlcyBlIE1hcmNvIEF1culsaW8u

  32. WAGNER disse:

    THVpeiBGdXguLi5leGNlbGVudGUgb2JzZXJ2Yefjby4uLiBhIG1haXMgcHVyYSByZWFsaWRhZGUgZG8gcGHtcy4uLiBvIHBpb3IgY2VnbyDpIGFxdWVsZSBxdWUgbuNvIHF1ZXIgZW54ZXJnYXIuLi5pc3NvIHNpbSBz428gc2luYWlzIGRlIHF1ZSBhIGRlbW9jcmFjaWEgYnJhc2lsZWlyYSB04SBhbWFkdXJlY2VuZG8gIA==

  33. roberto disse:

    Q29uc3RhdGHn428gZmF07WRpY2EgRHIuIEZ1eC4gNS8xMSA9IDQ1LDUlIGRvIFNURiBq4SBjb21wcm92YXJhbSBhIHF1ZSB2aWVyYW0gZSBhIHF1ZW0gc2VydmVtLiBGYWx0YSBtdWl0YSBwb3VjbyBwYXJhIGVzc2EgZmFtaWdlcmFkYSBsZWdpdGltYefjbyBkZW1vY3LhdGljYSBpciBwYXJhIG8gZXNwYedvLiBTdWdpcm8gZXhvbmVyYefjbyBlIGNhZGVpYSBwYXJhIGVzc2FzIDUgVi5FeGFzLiBlIHF1ZSBhcyBGRkFBIGludGVydmVuaGFtIGRlIHZleiBwYXJhIGZheGluYXIgdG9kYSBlc3NhIGVzYvNybmlhLg==

  34. Gaudério disse:

    RXN04SBwYXNzYW5kbyBkYSBob3JhLCBkbyAiYmljbyIgZG8gIENPVFVSTk8sIGFycmViZW50YXIgYSBwb3J0YSBkbyBjb25ncmVzc28sIGRvIHN0ZiwgZG8gcGxhbmFsdG8gZSBkYXIgdW0gRklNIE5FU1NBIENPUkpBICE=

  35. Carlos disse:

    QXTpIGVudGVuZGksIG1hcyBwZWxvIGplaXRvIG8gdG9wZXRlIGFuZG91IHRlbmRvIGF1bGFzIGNvbSBhIG1hZ27ibmltYSBlc3RvY2Fkb3JhIGRlIHZlbnRvLg==