Uma corte vacilante

Carlos Velloso disse a Sonia Racy, apelando para o bom senso de alguns ministros do STF:

“Decidir o tribunal, hoje, de forma contrária ao que decidiu ontem revela uma corte vacilante. Pior: redunda em insegurança jurídica. Que Deus inspire os juízes.”

Leia também:

VÍDEO: “O Supremo está muito vacilante e incerto”

Temas relacionados:

Deixe seu comentário

Os comentários não representam a opinião do site; a responsabilidade é do autor da mensagem;
Tempo de publicação: 4 minutos

200

  1. LUCAS disse:

    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

Ler comentários
  1. Lúzio disse:

    SU5TUElSQcfDTyBESVZJTkEgySBPIENBQ0VURS4gUFJFQ0lTQU1PUyBVUkdFTlRFIMkgREEgSU5URVJWRU7Hw08gTUlMSVRBUiBDT05TVElUVUNJT05BTCBQQVJBIFNBTFZBUiBOT1NTQSBBTUFEQSBQwVRSSUEgREFTIE3DT1MgREVTU0VTIFNPQ0lPUEFUQVMuIFZBTU9TIEFDT1JEQVIgRE8gU09OTyBEQSBJTkdFTlVJREFERSBFIENPTUXHQVIgQSBQRURJUiBJTlRFUlZFTsfDTyBVUkdFTlRFLg==

  2. ivanor disse:

    SXNzbyBzYWl1IGRlYmFpeG8gZG9zIGNhcmFj82lzIG91IGRvIHF1ZSByZXN0YSBkZSB0ZWxoYWRvIGFvIENhZXRhbm8/

  3. O disse:

    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

  4. O disse:

    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

  5. Dêxa disse:

    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

  6. Janaína disse:

    IlNlLCBhbOltIGRvIFBFTiwgb3V0cmFzIHNpZ2xhcyBwcm9wdXNlcmVtIG1lZGlkYXMgcGFyYSByZWRpc2N1dGlyIGEgcHJpc+NvIGFw83MgMi6qIGluc3TibmNpYSwgdG9kYSBzZW1hbmEgaXNzbyBzZXLhIGRlYmF0aWRvIG5vIFNURj8gySB0ZXJhdG9s82dpY28hIg0KLSBBZHZvZ2FkYSBlIGNvYXV0b3JhIGRvIHBlZGlkbyBkZSBpbXBlYWNobWVudCBjb250cmEgRGlsbWE=

  7. b.f.a.k. disse:

    Lg0KYSBWRVJEQURFIGTzaSENCm8gYnVz7Wxpcywgbm8gY2FzbywgbuNvIOkgcXVlIGEgY29ydGUgc2VqYSB2YWNpbGFudGUuDQpvIHF1ZSDJIEZBVE8g6SBxdWUgYWxndW5zICcnJ2NvcnRhbnRlcycnJyBTw08gIHZhJCQkaWxhbnRlJCQkICAhISEgISEhICEhIQ==

  8. Aurelio disse:

    TsNPIFPDTyBKVc1aRVMsIFPDTyBBRFZPR0FET1MgU1VQUkVNT1MgREUgQkFORElET1MgRE8gQ09MQVJJTkhPIEJSQU5DTy4gQ0FOQUxIQVMsIEZJTEhPUyBEQSBQVVRBISEhIQ==

  9. STF disse:

    VEEgRE9NSU5BRE8uLi4uVEEgVFVETyBET01JTkFETy4uLi4=

  10. KA disse:

    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

  11. Getulio disse:

    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

  12. KA disse:

    TuNvIHNvdSB1bSByb2L0IGUgcXVlcm8gSlVTVEnHQSEhIQ==

  13. O disse:

    VmFjaWxhbnRlLCAgdmVuZGlkYSBlIGRlIHF1YXRybyBwYXJhIGFsZ3VucyBwYXJ0aWRvcyBlIHBlc3NvYXMu

  14. torxta disse:

    RHIuIFZlbGxvc286IHBlbGEgZXhhZ2VyYWRhIGRlZmVzYSBxdWUgZmF6ZW0gZGEgbGliZXJkYWRlIGRvIHByZXNpZGnhcmlvIGNvcnJ1cHRvLCBwYXJlY2UgcXVlIEdNLCBMZXdhbmRvd3NraSwgVG9mZm9saSwgTUFNIGUgQ2Vsc28gZGUgTWVsbG8gbuNvICBlc3TjbyBidXNjYW5kbyBpbnNwaXJh5+NvIGNlbGVzdGlhbCBkZSBtb2RvIGFsZ3VtLiBNdWl0byBwZWxvIGNvbnRy4XJpby4uLg==

  15. eduardo disse:

    U08gVEVNT1MgTk8gU1RGIEFEVk9HQURPUyBERSBERUZFU0EgRSBOQU8gTUlOSVNUUk9TIERPIFNVUFJFTU8gSlVJWkVTIFFVRSBERVZFUklBTSBJTlRFR1JBUiBBIENPUlRFIFNBTyBQUkVFVEVSSURPUyBQT1IgQVBBRFJJTkhBRE9TIFBPTElUSUNPUyBHRU5URSBRVUUgU0UgQUNIQSBPIE1BWElNTyBFTSBJTlRFUlBSRVRBUiBBIENPTlNUSVRVScdBTyBFIFBSQVRJQ0EgQVRJVkFNRU5URSBPIE1BTlRSQSBETyBKVURJQ0lBUklPIEJSQVNJTEVJUk8gTEVCRVJBTElaQU5URSBgtFNPTFRBIFRPRE8gTVVORE9gYC5JTUJFQ0lTIFRPR0FET1MgUVVFIE5BTyBFTlRFTkRFTSBERSBMRUdJU0xBx0FPIEUgQ0FEQSBVTSBURU0gQSBTVUEgUEFSVElDVUxBUiBRVUUgQVBMSUNBIEFPIFNFVSBCRUwgUFJBWkVSIEUgRlJFUVVFTlRFTUVOVEUgQ09OVFJBIE8gRU5URU5ESU1FTlRPIERBIENPUlRFLExBTUVOVEFWRUwgTUFTIMkgQSBDQVJBIERPIEJSQVNJTCEh

  16. Sergio disse:

    TWFpcyB2YWNpbGFudGUgcXVlIGLqYmFkbyBmYXplbmRvIGRpc2N1cnNvIG5vIHNpbmRpY2F0byBkb3MgbWV0YWz6cmdpY29zLg==

  17. Hades disse:

    TuNvIGNoZWdhIGEgc2VyIHZhY2lsYW50ZS4gTyBTVEYgZXN04SBtZXNtbyB0ZW5kZW5jaW9zbyB0ZW50YW5kbyBzYWx2YXIgb3MgYmFuZGlkb3MsIGEgIHF1YWxxdWVyIHByZedvLCBhcnJpc2NhbmRvIHR1ZG8gaW5jbHVzaXZlIGEgbm9zc2EgZnLhZ2lsIGRlbW9jcmFjaWEuIFRlbSBnZW50ZSBnYW5oYW5kbyBtdWl0byBkaW5oZWlybyBuaXN0byBvdXRyb3MgZXN0428gY29tIG8gcmFibyBwcmVzbyBkZSB0YWwgb3JkZW0gcXVlIHRlbWVtIGEgTEFWQSBUT0dBLiBFc3TjbyBzZSBmYXplbmRvIGRlIHN1cmRvcyBhb3MgYXZpc29zIGRvIEdhbC4gVmlsbGFzIEL0YXMuIERlcG9pcyBu428gYWRpYW50YSBjaG9yYXIgbyBsZWl0ZSBkZXJyYW1hZG8u

  18. Almanakut disse:

    RXNzYSBtdWxoZXIgdmFpIHRpcmFyIG11aXRvcyB2b3RvcyBkbyBKb+NvIERvcmlhIQ==

  19. Petralius disse:

    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

  20. fabio disse:

    ZWxlcyBu428gc+NvIGp17Xplcy4gICBz428gYWR2b3JhdG9zIGNyaW1pbmFsaXN0YXMgc2luZGljYWxpc3Rhcy4=

    1. Lg0KIiIiYWR2b1JBVE9TIiIiIG11aXRvIGJlbSBwZW5zYWRvICEhIQ==